WOLLENSAK V. REIHER
Decision Date | 04 May 1885 |
Citation | 115 U. S. 87 |
Court | U.S. Supreme Court |
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
In view of the state of the art existing at the date of the patent granted to John F. Wollensak for an improvement in transom lifters by original patent No. 136,801, dated March 11, 1873, and by reissued patent No. 9,307, dated July 20, 1880, and the claims of that patent, it must be limited to a combination, with a transom, its lifting arm and operating rod, of a guide for the upper end of the operating rod, prolonged beyond the junction with the lifting arm, so as to prevent the operating rod from being bent or displaced by the weight of the transom, and it is not infringed by the device secured to Frank A. Reiher by patent No. 226,33, dated April 6, 1880.
This was a bill in equity to restrain infringements of a patent. The facts are stated in the opinion of the Court.
This bill in equity was filed by the appellant to restrain the alleged infringement by the defendant of reissued letters patent No. 9,307, dated July 20, 1880; the original patent, No.
136,801, dated March 11, 1873, having been issued to John Wollensak, the appellant, for an alleged new and useful improvement in transom lifters. This appeal is from a decree dismissing the bill for want of equity.
The specifications and drawings of the patent are as follows:
image:b
The defenses relied on were that the alleged invention was not patentable; that it had been anticipated by Bayley and McCluskey, to whom a patent had been granted dated July 7, 1868, No. 79,541, for an improvement in railroad car ventilators, and that the defendant's device, secured to him by a patent dated April 6, 1880, No. 226,353, did not infringe that of the appellant.
The specification and drawings of the appellee's patent are as follows:
image:c
Figures 1 and 2 show a front view and side elevation of my lifter attached to a transom hinged below. Figs. 3 and 4 show the lifter for transoms hinged above. Fig. 5 shows a front view of the lifter attached to a ventilating opening hanging obliquely. Fig. 6 shows the lifter attached to a transom hinged sidewise. Fig. 7 shows the lifter attached to a skylight. Fig.
8 shows a front view; Fig. 9 a vertical longitudinal section, and Fig. 10 an inverted plan of the casing. Figs. 11 and 12 show the top of lifting rod with adjusting block. Fig. 13 shows the lower part of the lifting rod with handle attachment.
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Scott Paper Co v. Marcalus Mfg Co
... ... Klein v. Russell, 19 Wall. 433, 466, 467, 22 L.Ed. 116; Garneau v. Dozier, 102 U.S. 230, 26 L.Ed. 133; Wollensak v. Reiher, 115 U.S. 87, 5 S.Ct. 1132, 29 L.Ed. 355; Beidler v. United States, 253 U.S. 447, 40 S.Ct. 564, 64 L.Ed. 1006; Mackay Co. v. Radio ... ...
-
Macbeth-Evans Glass Co. v. General Electric Co.
... ... 354, 357, 359, 360, ... 5 Sup.Ct. 174, 6 Sup.Ct. 451, 28 L.Ed. 665; Miller v ... Brass Co., 104 U.S. 350, 352, 26 L.Ed. 783; ... Wollensak v. Reiher, 115 U.S. 87, 101, 5 Sup.Ct ... 1132, 29 L.Ed. 355; Topliff v. Topliff, 145 U.S ... 156, 171, 12 Sup.Ct. 825, 36 L.Ed. 658; ... ...
-
Wollensak v. Sargent
...in combination with the rod and transom, and the rod, transom, and lifting arm.' The reissue was before this court in Wollensak v. Reiher, 115 U. S. 87, 94, 5 Sup. Ct. 1132, and the case disposed of on the ground of noninfringement; and the court there said: 'The specification of the compla......
-
Wollensak v. Sargent
... ... which are alleged to have been infringed, and other facts in ... regard to the character of the patented improvements, which ... need not be repeated ... The ... invention which was embraced in reissue No. 9,307 was ... declared by the supreme court in Wollensak v ... Reiher, 115 U.S. 87, 5 S.Ct. 1132, to be 'the ... combination with a transom, its lifting arm and operating ... rod, of a guide for the upper end of the operating rod, ... prolonged beyond the junction with the lifting arm, so as to ... prevent the operating rod from being bent or displaced by the ... ...