Thompson's Appeal

Citation22 Pa. 16
PartiesThompson's Appeal.
Decision Date15 September 1853
CourtUnited States State Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

APPEAL from the decree of the Common Pleas of Allegheny county.

Selden, for plaintiff in error.

Watson, for appellee.

The opinion of the Court was delivered, September 15, by LEWIS, J.

Whenever a trust-fund has been wrongfully converted into another species of property, if its identity can be traced, it will be held, in its new form, liable to the rights of the cestui que trust. No change of its state and form can divest it of such trust. So long as it can be identified either as the original property of the cestui que trust, or as the product of it, equity will follow it; and the right of reclamation attaches to it until detached by the superior equity of a bonâ fide purchaser, for a valuable consideration, without notice. The substitute for the original thing follows the nature of the thing itself so long as it can be ascertained to be such. But the right of pursuing it fails when the means of ascertainment fail. This is always the case when the subject-matter is turned into money and mixed and confounded in a general mass of property of the same description: Story's Equity, sec. 1257, 1258, 1259. This mixture has taken place in the case under consideration. It is impossible for a chancellor to lay his hand upon a single article of property or on a single dollar of money included in the assignment, and say that any particular thing or sum of money is either the original property of Seth Matthews' heirs or the product of it. The decree below was therefore erroneous.

Decree reversed, and decreed that the funds in the hands of the assignee be distributed pro rata among all the creditors of the assignor.

Record remitted.

To continue reading

Request your trial
34 cases
  • The Evangelical Synod of North America v. Schoeneich
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • 20 de abril de 1898
    ... ... H. Merten & Company, Appellant Supreme Court of Missouri, Second DivisionApril 20, 1898 ...           Appeal ... from St. Charles Circuit Court. -- Hon. E. M. Hughes, Judge ...           ... Affirmed ...          C ... Daudt for ... ...
  • People ex rel. Nelson v. People's State Bank of Maywood
    • United States
    • Illinois Supreme Court
    • 22 de dezembro de 1933
  • Sommers v. Bennett
    • United States
    • West Virginia Supreme Court
    • 15 de novembro de 1910
    ... ... gas rentals, or otherwise, accruing under such lease ...          Appeal ... from Circuit Court, Marion County ...          Bill by ... Martha M. Sommers and others against William G. Bennett and ... others ... ...
  • State v. Foster
    • United States
    • Wyoming Supreme Court
    • 5 de janeiro de 1895
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT