Bouchat v. Bon-Ton Dept. Stores, Inc.

Decision Date17 October 2007
Docket NumberNo. 03-2173.,No. 03-2174.,No. 04-1008.,No. 03-2389.,03-2173.,03-2174.,03-2389.,04-1008.
Citation506 F.3d 315
PartiesFrederick E. BOUCHAT, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. The BON-TON DEPARTMENT STORES, INCORPORATED; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Maryland, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Annapolis, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory of Gaithersburg, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse Of Security, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Baltimore, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Reistertown, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Columbia, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Greenbelt, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Glen Burnie, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Frederick, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Jessup, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Waldorf, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Towson, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of City Place, Incorporated; Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse of Hunt Valley, Incorporated; Collectors Edge of Tennessee, Incorporated; ESPN, Incorporated; Football USA, Incorporated; Frank Sussman, Company; Giant Food Incorporated; Home Box Office of Warner Brothers and Time Warner, Incorporated; Nissan Motor Acceptance Corporation; Starwood Operating, Incorporated, a/k/a Starwood Asset Services, Incorporated, t/a Sheraton Hotels; Starwood Hotels & Resorts, t/a Sheraton Hotels; The Sports Authority, Incorporated; Value City Department Store; American Greetings-ACG, Incorporated; Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Incorporated, t/a Sheraton Hotels, Defendants-Appellees, and K-Mart Corporation; Balfour Company; Borders Group; Copeland's Sport Stores; CVS; Wal-Mart Associates, Incorporated; Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated; Wal-Mart Stores East, Incorporated; Wal-Mart Realty Company; Tripp Distributors, Incorporated; Delta Apparel Incorporated; Eastport Corporation; ESPN Internet Ventures, a/k/a Espn Network, a/k/a Espn Internet Group; Fogdog, Incorporated; Group W Television, Incorporated; The May Department Stores Company, t/a The Hecht Company; KW Textiles, Incorporated; Major League Vacations; Nascar Banner Plus; NFL Shop; NFL Store, a/k/a The Best NFL Store; R. Kaufman Jewelers; NFL Jewelry; Nissan Auto Receivables Corporation, II; Nissan North America, Incorporated; Oneita Industries, Incorporated; Proteam Com, Incorporated, a/k/a Proteam.com 2000; Puma North America; Rand McNally Company, a/k/a Rand McNally & Company; Rocky Mountain Sport; Rite Aid Corporation; Royal Vendors, Incorporated; Shop at Home, Incorporated; Sony Corporation; Target Corporation; Ticket Warehouse; TKO Marketing; TV Guide, Incorporated; Skymall, Incorporated; Walden Book Company, Incorporated; West Coast Novelty Corporation; Hasboro Promotions and Direct, Incorporated, t/a Starting Lineup Collector Club; Infinity Broadcasting Corporation, t/a WJFK Radio, t/a WLIF Radio, a/k/a Infinity Broadcast Corporation of Maryland, a/k/a Infinity Broadcasting Corporation of Washington, D.C., a/k/a Infinity Broadcast Corporation of Chesapeake; Rhode Island Novelty; Suntrust Bank, a/k/a Crestar Bank, N.A.; Online Sports, a/k/a Onlinesports.Com; Sportsline.Com, Incorporated, a/k/a Sportsline & Sportsline.Com, a/k/a Sportsline USA, Incorporated, Defendants. Frederick E. Bouchat, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Champion Products, Incorporated; AA World Class Embroidery Embellishment; Abbacus, Incorporated; ABC, Incorporated; ABC Sports, Incorporated; A.D. Suttons & Sons; Accessory Network; Acclaim Entertainment; Accolade, Incorporated; Accudart; Adidas America; Aerial Sports Photography, Incorporated; Ama International Group; American Needle & Novelty, Incorporated; Aminco International Incorporated; Andrew Noch & Associates; Angel Lake Multimedia, Incorporated; Anheuser-Busch Companies, Inc.; Ansa Kids, Incorporated; The Antigua Group, Incorporated; Antone's Gourmet Gifts; Aquarius Limited; Athletic Supply of Dallas; Audrey Creative Table Linen; Autographed Ball Company; Baby Fair, d/b/a Baby-Fair, Incorporated; Barrell Sportswear; Belding Sports; Bell Atlantic Mobile, Incorporated, t/a Bell Atlantic Corporation; Bernie Kosar Greeting Card Company; Best Company, Incorporated, a/k/a Treat Entertainment; Best Equipment; Best Personalized Books; Betras Plastics; Bic Corporation; Big League Promotions; Bike Athletic Company; Bnox, Incorporated; Bond Distributing Company; Bottom Line Images; Brandon Apparel Group, Incorporated; Buffalo Games, Incorporated; Bulova Corporation; CBS Corporation Group, d/b/a CBS Corporation; C & I Leasing Incorporated; Cable News Network, Incorporated; Cambridge Footwear Group, Limited; Campbell Soup Company; Cannon USA, Incorporated; Carretta Sport Incorporated; Casablanca Fan Company; Caseworks International; Castrol North America, Incorporated; Champion Glove; Chestnut Hill Market; Chicagoland Processing Corporation; Cincinnati Bengals, Incorporated; Classic Balloon Corporation; Cleo, Incorporated; The Coca-Cola Company; Colgate Palmolive Company; Collector's Edge L.P.; College Concepts; Color-Clings, Incorporated, d/b/a The Paper Magic Group, Incorporated; Colores International, Incorporated, t/a Division of Wincraft Incorporated; Columbia Tel-Com; Columbia Telecommunications; Cooperstown Bears Limited; Coordinated Strategic Alliances Incorporated; Corinthian, Incorporated; Costacos Brothers Sports; Crown Oil & Gas Company; Crownmark; CSS Industries, Incorporated; CUI, Incorporated, (Metallic Images); Custom Cribbage, Incorporated; Cybrcard; D. Glasgow & Sons, Incorporated; Dallas Cowboys; Danby Products, Incorporated; Day Dream Publishing; Derivative Works, Incorporated; Dick's Clothing & Sporting Goods, Incorporated; Direct Impulse Design; Disney Press/Hyperion Books; Dixie Seal & Stamp Company, Incorporated; Double Tree Hotel Corporation; DSJ & Associates; Duck House; Dynasty Apparel Industries; E & J Gallo Winery; Eastman Kodak Company; Easton Sports, Incorporated; Eller Media Company; Emerson USA; Equity Sports, d/b/a Equity Marketing Incorporated; ERTL Company, Incorporated; ESPN, Incorporated; Essex Manufacturing Company; Exclusive Pro Sports; Fabric Traditions, d/b/a N.T.T., Incorporated; Fantasma; Fiberlok, Incorporated; Fine Host Corporation; Fit for Sports; Fleer Corporation; Foot-Tec Industries; Ford Motor Company; Fossil, Incorporated; Foster Industries, Incorporated; Fox Entertainment Group, Incorporated; Franco Apparel Group, Incorporated; Franklin Sports Industries, Incorporated; Fremont Die Consumer Products, Incorporated; Front Pages Company; FSC Wallcoverings; Galoob Toys, Incorporated; Garan Incorporated; General Mills, Incorporated; Genesis Direct, Incorporated; GFG Incorporated; Gill Apparel Group/ Carl Banks; Good Stuff Corporation; Great American Products, Incorporated; Gridiron Golf; Gridiron Group; Grossman Cap Company Incorporated; H & H Furniture Manufacturing, Incorporated; Haddad Apparel Group Limited; Hallmark Emblems, Incorporated; Hallmark Licensing; Hasbro, Incorporated; Hasbro Toy Company; Hasbro Toy Group; Head Games; Helene Curtis, Incorporated; Hershey Food Corporation; Highgate Products LLC; Highland Mint; Home Innovations; Host Apparel; Hot Sauce Harry's; HPI; Hunter Manufacturing Group; Hunter Media; Hutch Sports USA; Ichauway Mills Incorporated; Identity, Incorporated; Ideal Rubber Products Company; Illinoy Toy, (Candy Cargo); IMC Products Corporation; Imprinted Products Corporation; Indianapolis Colts; Innovo Group Incorporated; Inventure Disk; Iron Knights/Chinin USA Incorporated; Its Academic; Jacksonville Jaguars, t/a Jacksonville Jaguars, Limited; J.D. Healy Specialties, Incorporated; J.F. Sports Company; J.W. Envisions, d/b/a Ultimate Vision; Jay Franco and Sons, Incorporated; Jeff Hamilton; Jester Company; John F. Turner & Company, Incorporated; John H. Harland Company; Joy Athletic; Kansas City Chiefs, t/a Kansas City Chiefs Football Club, Incorporated, Football Club, Incorporated; Kelly Russell Studios, Incorporated; Ken Norton Jr.'s Stars & Legends; Kenner Products; Kool Sport; Kooler Kraft; Kraft Foods, Incorporated; Kurt S. Adler; La Rue International; Legends Athletic; Lightfoot Photography; Limited Treasures, Incorporated; Logo Athletic, Incorporated; Lumatec Industrial; Majestic Athletic Wear, Limited; MBI, Incorporated; MBNA America, a/k/a MBNA Marketing Systems, Incorporated, a/k/a MBNA Corporation, a/k/a MBNA America Bank, NA; McArthur Towels, Incorporated; McKimson Productions, Incorporated; The Mead Corporation; Meltzer Industries; MGI USA Incorporated; MGWHIZ, Incorporated; Miami Dolphins, t/a Miami Dolphins, Limited; Michael Anthony Jewelers, Incorporated; Microsoft Corporation; Midatlantic Bottling, Limited; Midway Games, Incorporated; Midwest Swiss Embroideries Company, Incorporated; Miggle Toys, Incorporated; Miller Brewing Company; Mind Power; Mine Safety Appliances Company; Minnesota Vikings; Mirage, Division of Elliot Kastle, Incorporated; Henry Modell & Company, Incorporated, a/k/a Modell's Maryland, Incorporated, a/k/a Modell's, Incorporated; Moretz Mills, Incorporated; Motion Vision; Motorola, Incorporated; Mounted Memories, Incorporated; Museums Editions, Limited; Nanco, Nancy Sales Company; Nardi Enterprises, Incorporated; National Broadcasting Company, Incorporated; National Design Corporation; National Embroidered Emblem, a/k/a National Emblem, Incorporated; National Mat; New England Patriots, t/a New England Patriots L.P.; New Era Cap Company, Incorporated; New Life Art, Incorporated; New Orleans Saints, t/a New Orleans Louisiana Saints Limited Partnership; New York Giants, t/a New York Football Giants, Inc.; New York Jets, t/a New York Jets Football Club, Incorporated; NFL Enterprises LP, a/k/a NFL Enterprises Incorporated; NFL, Incorporated, a/k/a National Football League, Incorporated; National Football League, Incorporated Films, a/k/a NFL Films, Incorporated; Nicholas Simon Company; Nike, Company; Nike, Incorporated; Norman James Company, Limited, a/k/a Norman James International Corporation; North American Boot Company; NTN Communications, Incorporated; Nutmeg Mills, VF Corporation; Oakland Raiders, a/k/a The Oakland Raiders; Oakley, Incorporated; Orange Products, Incorporated; Outerstuff Corporation, d/b/a Outerstuff, Limited; Overtime Sports, Incorporated; Oxboro Outdoors; P & K Products Company, Incorporated, a/k/a PK Products Company; Pacific Trading Cards, Incorporated; Papel/Freelance Inc; Paul Arpin Van Lines, Incorporated; Penquin Products, Incorporated; Penninsula Vending, Incorporated; Pentagram, Incorporated, Best Bets; Pentech International, Incorporated; Pepsico, Incorporated; Pepsi-Cola Operating Company of Chesapeake & Indianapolis; Peter David, Incorporated; Philadelphia Eagles, t/a The Philadelphia Eagles Football Club, Inc.; Photo File Incorporated; Picture Me Books; Pine Hosiery Mills, Incorporated; Pinnacle Brands, Incorporated; Pittsburgh Steelers, t/a Pittsburgh Steelers Sports, Incorporated; Pique Embroidery; Playoff Corporation; Plymouth, Incorporated, d/b/a P.A. Plymouth, Incorporated; Positive Image Bracing System; Premier Concepts Incorporated; Pro Cube, Incorporated; Pro Elite, Incorporated; Pro Look, Incorporated; Pro Moves International, Incorporated; Pro Starr LLC; Pro-Peller DIV/IMC Products; Proctor & Gamble; Progressive Insurance, d/b/a Progressive Casualty Insurance Company; Provident Bank of Maryland; Psinet, d/b/a PSINet, Incorporated; Pyramid, Incorporated, d/b/a Pyramid Accessories, Incorporated; Quaker Oats Company, a/k/a The Quaker Oats Company; Racing Champions, Incorporated; Ralph Marlin & Company, Incorporated; RCA Consumer Electronics; Reebok International Limited; Regal Ware, Incorporated; Renaissance Editions; Rhode Island Novelty, a/k/a Rhode Island Novelty, Incorporated; Rico Industries, Incorporated; Ridell Incorporated; Rival Company; Rossmor Industries; Roxbury Industries, d/b/a Roxbury Industries Corporation; Russ Berrie & Company, Incorporated; Russell Athletic; Russell Corporation; San Diego Chargers, t/a Chargers Football Company; San Francisco 49ers, t/a San Francisco Forty Niners, Limited; Sanctuary Woods Multimedia; Sanford Berol USA, a/k/a Sanford L.P.; Saranac Glove Company; Sara Lee Knit Products, d/b/a Sara Lee Corporation; Sassi, a/k/a Sassi, Incorporated; Schuessler Knitting Mills; Scott Editions; SDI Technologies; Sears Roebuck and Company; Seattle Seahawks, t/a Football Northwest LLC; Sega of America, Incorporated; Seven Sons & Company, Incorporated; Shaw Creations, Incorporated; Shiara Holdings; Shirt Xplosion; Shoeware; Sierra Sun Editions; Signal Apparel Company, Incorporated; Simpson Products; Siskiyou Buckle Company; Smart Dog Products, d/b/a Smart Dog Products, Incorporated; Smithmark Publishing, Incorporated; Snap on Tools, d/b/a Snap-on Technologies, Incorporated; Sony Interactive; Southern Maryland Imports, Incorporated; Southwest Airlines; Sport Cook, Incorporated; Sportacular Art; Sports Accessories; Sports Coverage; Sports Illustrated Magazine, a/k/a Time Inc.; Sports Section; Sportscast; Sportspro Marketing; Sportstar; Sprint Communications Company L.P.; St. Louis Rams, t/a St. Louis Rams Partnership; Staples, Incorporated, d/b/a Staples the Office Superstore, Incorporated; Starline, Incorporated, a/k/a Starline Novelties Incorporated; Starter Corporation; Starwave Corporation; Sterling Sports, Incorporated; Stuffins, Incorporated; Stylus; Subtle Perfection; Sugar Plum; Sun Time Enterprises, Incorporated; Suncast Corporation; Swiss Army Brands, d/b/a Swiss Army Brands, Incorporated; Swiss Maid; Tabletop Enterprises; Tampa Bay Buccaneers; Team Editions Auto; Team Golf; Teamworks, Incorporated; Tennessee Titans; Terrisol, d/b/a Terrisol Corporation; Terry Manufacturing; The Bradford Exchange; The Northwest Company, d/b/a Wilmington Products USA Incorporated; The Party Animal, Incorporated; The Pasta Shoppe; The Snack Factory, Incorporated; The Topps Company, Incorporated; The Upper Deck Company, LLC; Walt Disney Company, Incorporated; The Wormser Company; Thermo-Serv, Incorporated; Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P.; Titleist and Footjoy Worldwide; Toon Art, Incorporated; Topperscot, Incorporated, d/b/a T. Swanson Incorporated; Toy & Sport Trends, Incorporated; Treasure Chest Novelty Corporation; Triumph Publishing; Tultex Corporation, Logo Athletic; Tundra/Standard Knitting Incorporated; Turbo Sportswear, Incorporated, d/b/a Turbo Holding Incorporated; Turner National Television; Twenty Fourth and Dean, Incorporated; Twins Enterprises, Incorporated; Ultimate Vision; Unique Premium Products; Unique Sports Generation; Universal Heights, Incorporated; Universal Marketing Associates, Incorporated; USA Games; USA Licensed Bows; Uvex Safety, Incorporated; V. Fraas, d/b/a V. Fraas (USA) Incorporated; Vermont Teddy Bear, d/b/a The Vermont Teddy Bear Company, Incorporated; VF Knitwear, Incorporated; Voyager Emblems, Incorporated; Washington Redskins; Waterford Wedgewood USA, Incorporated; Wells Lamont; Wemco; White Rose Collectibles; Williams Electronic Games, Incorporated; Williams Industries, Incorporated; Willow Hoisery Company, Incorporated; Wilson Sporting Goods, Company; Wincraft, Incorporated; Winner Distributing Company; Workman Publishing Company, Incorporated; Xerox Corporation; Zippo Manufacturing Company; 4 Sports Incorporated; 989 Studios; Pepsi-Cola Metropolitan Bottling Company, Incorporated; Custom Edge, Incorporated; Global Recognition; J.C. Penney Company, Incorporated; Venator Group, Incorporated, t/a Champs Sports, t/a Foot Locker, a/k/a Venator Retail Group, Incorporated; Mouse Products, Incorporated; B & B Holdings, Incorporated, d/b/a Arizona Cardinals; At-A-Glance Corporation, t/a The Mead Corporation, d/b/a At-A-Glance Group, a subsidiary of the Mead Corporation; The Five Smiths, Incorporated, d/b/a Atlanta Falcons; Aurafin LLC; Authentic Images, Incorporated; Bentley Lingerie, Incorporated, a/k/a Bentley; Buffalo Bills, Incorporated, a/k/a Buffalo Bills; Richardson Sports Limited Partnership, d/b/a Carolina Panthers; Chicago Bears Football Club, Incorporated, a/k/a Chicago Bears; Commemorative Brands, Incorporated; Crown Crafts, Incorporated; Crown Central LLC; Crown Pro, Incorporated; Denver Broncos Football Club, a/k/a Denver Broncos; The Detroit Lions, Inc.; Buena Vista Books; Drew Pearson Marketing, Incorporated; Electronic Arts Incorporated; Fleer Sky/Box International, LP; Foley-Martens Company; For Bare Feet, Incorporated; A.R.C. Holdings, Limited, d/b/a Fox Sports Direct; F. Schumaker & Company, a/k/a Village Wall Coverings; General Mills Sales, Incorporated; Green Bay Packers, Incorporated; Hallmark Cards, Incorporated; Candy Cargo; McDonald's Corporation; Papel Giftware, Incorporated; The Pfaltzgraff Company; Thomson Consumer Electronics, Incorporated; Triatic, Incorporated; Kentex; Licensed Lifestyles, Incorporated, d/b/a Tag Express; Dan River Incorporated; Coca-Cola Enterprise, d/b/a The Mid-Atlantic Coca-Cola Bottling Company, d/b/a The Mid-Atlantic Coca-Cola Bottling Company; Timezone Products; Turner Network Television, LP, LLP; SBM, Incorporated, d/b/a Scoreboard Memories; Bacou USA Safety, Incorporated; Pro Football, Incorporated; Nike Retail Services, Incorporated; NFL Productions, LLC; McMeel Publishing, formerly known as Andrews & McMeel; Biederlack of America, d/b/a Cushion Craft Andrews & McMeel; Biederlack of America, d/b/a Cushion Craft Biederlack Corporation; Vivendi Universal Games, Incorporated, formerly known as Cendant Software Corporation; Sierra Entertainment, Incorporated, formerly known as Sierra On-Line, Incorporated; Donruss Playoff; Summit America Television, Incorporated, formerly known as Shop at Home Incorporated; Football Northwest LLC; Tennessee Football, L.P., d/b/a Cumberland Football Management, Incorporated; Bow Line Family Products, d/b/a BowLine Family Products; Cendent Software; Golden Golf; Kittrich Corporation; KR Industries Incorporated; Milton Bradley, d/b/a Hasbro, Incorporated; Sierra Online; Lifestyles, Incorporated, d/b/a Tag Express; Treat Entertainment; VF Knitwear, Incorporated; Village Wall Coverings; Xpress Corporation, Defendants-Appellees, and Action Images, Incorporated; Adams U.S.A., Incorporated, d/b/a Neuman Tackified Glove; Allure Home Creation Company, Incorporated; America's Sweetheart; Baron Group, Incorporated; Alphabet City Records, Incorporated; Big Fork Boot Company; Brimms, Incorporated; Dolly, Incorporated; Everlasting Images, Incorporated; Foot Locker; Foto Fantasy; Fremont Consumer Die; Fruit of The Loom, Limited; Fuji Photo Film; Futech Designs; G-III Apparel Group, Limited; Gilman Gear; Global One Distribution & Merchandising; Golden Harvest Popcorn, Incorporated; Gotta Go, Incorporated, d/b/a Head Sokz; Harper Collins; Houston Harvest Gift Products, LLC; Kimberly Clark Corporation; Maxit Designs; Play-By-Play Toys & Novelties; Pro Team Playables; Salvino, Incorporated; Score Board; Simplicity Manufacturing; Sports Specialties; Tasco Sales, Incorporated; Team Mouse; United Parcel Service, Incorporated; US Playing Card Company; Warner Brothers; York Barbell Company, Incorporated; The Bibb Company, d/b/a Dan River Incorporated, Defendants. Frederick E. Bouchat, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Baltimore Ravens Limited Partnership; Baltimore Ravens Football Club, Incorporated; Baltimore Stadium Company, LLC, Defendants-Appellees. Frederick E. Bouchat, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. 7-Eleven, Defendant-Appellee.
CourtU.S. Court of Appeals — Fourth Circuit

To continue reading

Request your trial
61 cases
  • City of Carlsbad v. Shah, Civil No. 08cv1211 AJB (WMc)
    • United States
    • United States District Courts. 9th Circuit. United States District Court (Southern District of California)
    • 9 Febrero 2012
    ......Cal.1999); Lamps Plus, Inc. v. Seattle Lighting Fixture Co., 345 F.3d 1140, 1144-45 ... See Stop Youth Addiction v. Lucky Stores, Inc., 950 P.2d 1086, 1091 (Cal. 1998); Farmers Ins. ...1989).          4. See Bouchat v. Bon-Ton Dep't Stores, Inc., 506 F.3d 315, 330 (4th Cir. ......
  • Fischer v. Stephen T. Forrest, Jr., Sandra F. Forrest, Shane R. Gebauer, & Brushy Mountain Bee Farm, Inc., 14 Civ. 1304 (PAE) (AJP)
    • United States
    • United States District Courts. 2nd Circuit. United States District Courts. 2nd Circuit. Southern District of New York
    • 14 Julio 2017
    ......2007). Fischer cannot recover for the reasons set forth in Bouchat v. Bon-Ton Dep't Stores, Inc. , 506 F.3d 315, 329-32 (4th Cir. 2007), ......
  • Roberts v. Gordy
    • United States
    • United States District Courts. 11th Circuit. United States District Courts. 11th Circuit. Southern District of Florida
    • 8 Abril 2016
    ...... after the litigation commenced, First-N-Gold Publishing Inc. ("FNG") filed a motion to intervene. (DE 172). In that ... does not require a showing of fraud." Family Dollar Stores, Inc. v. United Fabrics Int'l, Inc. , 896 F.Supp.2d 223, ... notice of the facts stated in the registration); Bouchat v. Bon–Ton Dep't Stores, Inc. , 506 F.3d 315, 329 (4th ......
  • City of Carlsbad v. Shah
    • United States
    • United States District Courts. 9th Circuit. United States District Court (Southern District of California)
    • 9 Febrero 2012
    ......, 95 F.Supp.2d 1081, 1087 (C.D.Cal.1999); Lamps Plus, Inc. v. Seattle Lighting Fixture Co., 345 F.3d 1140, 1144–45 ...See Stop Youth Addiction v. Lucky Stores, Inc., 17 Cal.4th 553, 71 Cal.Rptr.2d 731, 950 P.2d 1086, ...          4. See Bouchat v. Bon–Ton Dep't Stores, Inc., 506 F.3d 315, 330 (4th ......
  • Request a trial to view additional results
1 books & journal articles

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT