55 F.3d 827 (3rd Cir. 1995), 93-7829, Redland Soccer Club, Inc. v. Department of Army of United States

Docket Nº:93-7829.
Citation:55 F.3d 827
Party Name:REDLAND SOCCER CLUB, INC., Bretni Brink, a Minor, by Tamara Brink, Ryan Brink, a Minor, by Tamara Brink, Joseph Brtalik, Carole G. Brtalik, Joseph J. Brtalik, Brian Brtalik, Wendy Brtalik, a Minor, by Joseph and Carole G. Brtalik, Theodore F. Burd, Diane M. Burd, Christopher T. Burd, a Minor, by Theodore F. and Diane M. Burd, Gregory C. Burd, a Min
Case Date:May 15, 1995
Court:United States Courts of Appeals, Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
 
FREE EXCERPT

Page 827

55 F.3d 827 (3rd Cir. 1995)

REDLAND SOCCER CLUB, INC., Bretni Brink, a Minor, by Tamara

Brink, Ryan Brink, a Minor, by Tamara Brink, Joseph Brtalik,

Carole G. Brtalik, Joseph J. Brtalik, Brian Brtalik, Wendy

Brtalik, a Minor, by Joseph and Carole G. Brtalik, Theodore

F. Burd, Diane M. Burd, Christopher T. Burd, a Minor, by

Theodore F. and Diane M. Burd, Gregory C. Burd, a Minor, by

Theodore F. and Diane M. Burd, Dewitt J. Cline, Jr., Jan M.

Cline, Eric J. Cline, a Minor, by Dewitt J., Jr. and Jan M.

Cline, Jeromy J. Cline, a Minor, by Dewitt J., Jr. and Jan

M. Cline, Ronald W. Danner, Danielle M. Danner, a Minor, by

Ronald W. Danner, Craig A. Danner, a Minor, by Ronald W.

Danner, Theodore J. Elliott, Frances M. Elliott, Todd

Elliott, a Minor, by Theodore J. and Frances M. Elliott,

Tracey Elliott, a Minor, by Theodore J. and Frances M.

Elliott, Steven W. Haas, Irma L. Rodgers-Haas, Anthony M.

Rodgers, a Minor, by Steven W. Haas and Irma L.

Rodgers-Haas, Nicole C. Rodgers, a Minor, by Steven W. Haas

and Irma L. Rodgers-Haas, Lawrence E. Hager, Ruth A. Hager,

Samuel Hager, Benjamin Hager, a Minor, by Lawrence and

Ruth Hager, Shawn Hager, a Minor, by Lawrence and Ruth

Hager, Edward Hockenberry, Mary L. Hockenberry, Brett R.

Hockenberry, a Minor, by Edward and Mary L. Hockenberry,

Roger L. Hockenberry, Patricia D. Hockenberry, Keric L.

Hockenberry, a Minor, by Roger L. and Patricia D.

Hockenberry, Kodi B. Hockenberry, a Minor, by Roger L. and

Patricia D. Hockenberry, Klint D. Hockenberry, a Minor, by

Roger L. and Patricia D. Hockenberry, David G. Hooper,

Priscilla G. Hooper, David G. Hooper, II, John H. Knaub,

Deborah J. Knaub, Derek J. Knaub, a Minor, by John H. and

Deborah J. Knaub, Sean M. Knaub, a Minor, by John H. and

Deborah J. Knaub, Thomas R. Krause, Robert A. Krause, a

Minor, by Thomas R. Krause, Richard H. Lebo, Donna Lebo,

Trisha Lebo, a Minor, by Richard and Donna Lebo, Kristina

Lebo, a Minor, by Richard and Donna Lebo, Ralph E. McCarty,

Gale P. McCarty, Joshua H. McCarty, a Minor, by Ralph E. and

Gale P. McCarty, Lucas P. McCarty, a Minor, by Ralph E. and

Gale P. McCarty, James P. Meyers, Kim Meyers, Samantha

Meyers, a Minor, by James and Kim Meyers, Brett Meyers, a

Minor, by James and Kim Meyers, Thomas M. Morrow, Meredith

S. Morrow, Gregory M. Morrow, a Minor, by Thomas M. and

Meredith S. Morrow, Geoffrey T. Morrow, a Minor, by Thomas

M. and Meredith S. Morrow, Jack E. Muth, Kathleen L. Muth,

Robert C. Muth, a Minor, by Jack and Kathleen L. Muth, John

A. Nace, Jr., Linda M. Nace, Michael Nace, a Minor, by John

A. and Linda M. Nace, Robert Nace, a Minor, by John A. and

Linda M. Nace, Kenneth E. Nace, Pamela R. Nace, Jeremy M.

Nace, a Minor, by Kenneth E. and Pamela R. Nace, Kevin E.

Nace, a Minor, by Kenneth E. and Pamela R. Nace, Melissa A.

Nace, a Minor, by Kenneth E. and Pamela R. Nace, Dean G.

Newhouse, Norma J. Newhouse, Martin Newhouse, Eric Newhouse,

Benjamin Newhouse, a Minor, by Dean G. and Norma J.

Newhouse, Peter P. O'Neill, Alice L. O'Neill, Peter O'Neill,

Patrick O'Neill, Paul O'Neill, Patricia A. Palm, Dylan T.

Buckwalter, a Minor, by Patricia A. Palm, Michelle A.

Buckwalter, a Minor, by Patricia A. Palm, Robert J. Pontius,

Cindy L. Pontius, Jay Pontius, a Minor, by Robert J. and

Cindy L. Pontius, Debra S. Popp, Andrew J. Popp, a Minor, by

Debra S. Popp, Thomas M. Rados, a Minor, by Sonja Rados,

William P. Rehm, Jr., Kimberly A. Rehm, David A. Rehm, a

Minor, by William P., Jr., and Kimberly A. Rehm, Andar A.

Rehm, a Minor, by William P., Jr., and Kimberly A. Rehm,

Deon J. Rehm, a Minor, by William P., Jr., and Kimberly A.

Rehm, Michelle D. Rehm, a Minor, by William P., Jr., and

Kimberly A. Rehm, Ken Ribble, Susan Ribble, Scott Ribble, a

Minor, by Ken and Susan Ribble, Mark Ribble, a Minor, by Ken

and Susan Ribble, Nevin C. Shenck, Jr., Lisa L. Shenck,

Nathan S. Shenck, Aaron M. Shenck, a Minor, by Nevin C.,

Jr., and Lisa L. Shenck, Rebecca Shenck, a Minor, by Nevin

C., Jr., and Lisa L. Shenck, Bradley Shirk, Richard V.

Spong, Sr., Julia A. Spong, Richard V. Spong, Jr., Nathan M.

Spong, Joelle L. Spong, Barry L. Stone, Matthew D. Stone,

Corey J. Stroman, a Minor, by Lowell R. and Debra J.

Stroman, Donna L. Szoszorek, Shannon M. Szoszorek, A Minor,

by Donna L. Szoszorek, Shayna M. Szoszorek, a Minor, by

Donna L. Szoszorek, Eugene K. Torbek, Erik P. Torbek, a

Minor, by Eugene K. Torbek, Donald Williamson, Elizabeth M.

Williamson, Michael Williamson, a Minor, by Donald and

Elizabeth Williamson, William B. Wirt, Pamela A. Wirt,

Christine E. Wirt, Kevin M. Wirt, Timothy B. Wirt, a Minor,

by William B. and Pamela A. Wirt, Bryan C. Wirt, a Minor, by

William B. and Pamela A. Wirt, Burlin Covert, Joseph

Dorwart, III, Patricia A. Dorwart, Joseph Dorwart, IV, a

Minor, by Joseph Dorwart, III, and Patricia Dorwart, Alicia

Dorwart, a Minor, by Joseph Dorwart, III, and Patricia

Dorwart, Brent Dorwart, a Minor, by Joseph Dorwart, III, and

Patricia Dorwart, Jack H. Hershberger, Jr., June

Hershberger, Larry Smart, Carol Smart, Jeffrey Smart, a

Minor, by Larry and Carol Smart, Crystal Smart, a Minor,

by Larry and Carol Smart, Glenn Diller, Dale Kahler, Robert

E. Kane, Terrence L. Kemberling, David A. Kupp, E. Robert

McCollum, Herbert D. Myers, and Wilbur Yorty, Appellants,

v.

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY OF THE UNITED STATES of America and

the United States of America, Appellees.

No. 93-7829.

United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit

May 15, 1995

Argued June 22, 1994.

Page 828

[Copyrighted Material Omitted]

Page 829

[Copyrighted Material Omitted]

Page 830

[Copyrighted Material Omitted]

Page 831

[Copyrighted Material Omitted]

Page 832

Laurence W. Dague (argued), Glenn R. Davis, Raja G. Rajan, Shumaker & Williams, Harrisburg, PA, for appellants Redland Soccer Club, Inc., Bretni Brink, a Minor, by Tamara Brink, Ryan Brink, a Minor, by Tamara Brink, Joseph Brtalik, Carole G. Brtalik, Joseph J. Brtalik, Brian Brtalik, Wendy Brtalik, a Minor, by Joseph and Carole G. Brtalik, Theodore F. Burd, Diane M. Burd, Christopher T. Burd, a Minor, by Theodore F. and Diane M. Burd, Gregory C. Burd, a Minor, by Theodore F. and Diane M. Burd, Dewitt J. Cline, Jr., Jan M. Cline, Eric J. Cline, a Minor, by Dewitt J., Jr. and Jan M. Cline, Jeromy J. Cline, a Minor, by Dewitt J., Jr. and Jan M. Cline, Ronald W. Danner, Danielle M. Danner, a Minor, by Ronald W. Danner, Craig A. Danner, a Minor, by Ronald W. Danner, Steven W. Haas and Irma L. Rodgers-Haas, Anthony M. Rodgers, a Minor, by Steven W. Haas and Irma L. Rodgers-Haas, Nicole C. Rodgers, a Minor, Steven W. Haas and Irma L. Rodgers-Haas, Lawrence E. Hager, Ruth A. Hager, Samuel Hager, Benjamin Hager, a Minor, by Lawrence and Ruth Hager, Shawn Hager, a Minor, by Lawrence and Ruth Hager, Edward Hockenberry, Mary L. Hockenberry, Brett R. Hockenberry, a Minor, by Edward and Mary L. Hockenberry, Roger L. Hockenberry, Patricia D. Hockenberry, Keric L. Hockenberry, a Minor, by Roger L. and Patricia D. Hockenberry, Kodi B. Hockenberry, a Minor, by Roger L. and Patricia D. Hockenberry, Klint D. Hockenberry, a Minor, by Roger L. and Patricia D. Hockenberry, David G. Hooper, Priscilla G. Hooper, David G. Hooper, II, John H. Knaub, Deborah J. Knaub, Derek J. Knaub, a Minor, by John H. and Deborah J. Knaub, Sean M. Knaub, a Minor, by John H. and Deborah J. Knaub, Thomas R. Krause, Robert A. Krause, a Minor, by Thomas R. Krause, Richard H. Lebo, Donna Lebo, Trisha Lebo, a Minor, by Richard and Donna Lebo, Kristina Lebo, a Minor, by Richard and Donna Lebo, Ralph E. McCarty, Gale P. McCarty, Joshua H. McCarty, a Minor, by Ralph E. and Gale P. McCarty, Lucas P. McCarty, a Minor, by Ralph E. and Gale P. McCarty, James P. Meyers, Kim Meyers, Samantha Meyers, a Minor, by James and Kim Meyers, Brett Meyers, a Minor, by James and Kim Meyers, Thomas M. Morrow, Meredith S. Morrow, Gregory M. Morrow, a Minor, by Thomas M. and Meredith S. Morrow, Geoffrey T. Morrow, a Minor, by Thomas M. and Meredith S. Morrow, Jack E. Muth, Kathleen L. Muth, Robert C. Muth, a Minor, by Jack and Kathleen

Page 833

L. Muth, John A. Nace, Jr., Linda M. Nace, Michael Nace, a Minor, by John A. and Linda M. Nace, Robert Nace, a Minor, by John A. and Linda M. Nace, Kenneth E. Nace, Pamela R. Nace, Jeremy M. Nace, a Minor, by Kenneth E. and Pamela R. Nace, Kevin E. Nace, a Minor, by Kenneth E. and Pamela R. Nace, Melissa A. Nace, a Minor, by Kenneth E. and Pamela R. Nace, Dean G. Newhouse, Norma J. Newhouse, Martin Newhouse, Eric Newhouse, Benjamin Newhouse, a Minor, by Dean G. and Norma J. Newhouse, Peter P. O'Neill, Alice L. O'Neill, Peter O'Neill, Patrick O'Neill, Paul O'Neill, Patricia A. Palm, Dylan T. Buckwalter, a Minor, by Patricia A. Palm, Michelle A. Buckwalter, a Minor, by Patricia A. Palm, Robert J. Pontius, Cindy L. Pontius, Jay Pontius, a Minor, by Robert J. and Cindy L. Pontius, Debra S. Popp, Andrew J. Popp, a Minor, by Debra S. Popp, Thomas M. Rados, a Minor, by Sonja Rados, William P. Rehm, Jr., Kimberly A. Rehm, David A. Rehm, a Minor, by William P., Jr., and Kimberly A. Rehm, Andar A. Rehm, a Minor, by William P., Jr., and Kimberly A. Rehm, Deon J. Rehm, a Minor, by William P., Jr., and Kimberly A. Rehm, Michelle D. Rehm, a Minor, by William P., Jr., and Kimberly A. Rehm, Ken Ribble, Susan Ribble, Scott Ribble, a Minor, by Ken and Susan Ribble, Mark Ribble, a Minor, by Ken and Susan Ribble, Nevin C. Shenck, Jr., Lisa L. Shenck, Nathan S. Shenck, Aaron M. Shenck, a Minor, by...

To continue reading

FREE SIGN UP