637 A.2d 573 (N.J.Super.A.D. 1994), Prudential Ins. Co. of America v. Jackson

Citation:637 A.2d 573, 270 N.J.Super. 510
Opinion Judge:[10] Kleiner
Party Name:PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA, a New Jersey Corporation, Plaintiff-Respondent, v. Willard JACKSON, Defendant-Appellant, and Old Republic Insurance Company, Household Finance Corporation, Guardian Discount Corporation, C.I.T. Financial Services Inc., a Corp., Jersey City Medical Center, Family Medical Center, Defendants.
Attorney:[7] Gregory G. Diebold argued the cause for the appellant (Hudson County Legal Services Corp., Timothy K. Madden, Director, attorneys; Mr. Diebold, of counsel and on the brief).
Case Date:February 18, 1994
Court:Superior Court of New Jersey
 
FREE EXCERPT

Page 573

637 A.2d 573 (N.J.Super.A.D. 1994)

270 N.J.Super. 510

PRUDENTIAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA, a New Jersey

Corporation, Plaintiff-Respondent,

v.

Willard JACKSON, Defendant-Appellant,

and

Old Republic Insurance Company, Household Finance

Corporation, Guardian Discount Corporation, C.I.T.

Financial Services Inc., a Corp., Jersey

City Medical Center, Family

Medical Center, Defendants.

Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division.

February 18, 1994

Argued Dec. 7, 1993. [270 N.J.Super. 511]

Gregory G. Diebold, Jersey City, argued the cause for the appellant (Hudson County Legal Services Corp., Timothy K. Madden, Director, attorneys; Mr. Diebold, of counsel and on the brief).

Harold N. Kaplan, Westmont, argued the cause for the respondent (Federman and Phelan, attorneys; Mr. Kaplan, of counsel and on the brief).

Before Judges PRESSLER, BROCHIN and KLEINER.

The opinion of the court was delivered by

KLEINER, J.S.C. (temporarily assigned).

Defendant Willard Jackson appeals a foreclosure judgment routinely entered through the Superior Court Foreclosure Unit on July 1, 1993 on behalf of plaintiff Prudential Insurance Company of America. The foreclosure proceedings were initially commenced on June 13, 1991. Defendant filed an answer asserting three separate defenses. On a contested motion, plaintiff obtained an order striking defendant's answer on December 7, 1992. We conclude that the affidavit filed by defendant in response to the motion to strike his answer raised genuine issues of fact which necessitated a plenary hearing. We accordingly are constrained to reverse the entry of the foreclosure judgment, to reinstate the defendant's answer and to remand to the Chancery Division of Hudson County for trial.

The issues posed by defendant's initial answer and in his response to plaintiff's motion to strike raise questions of first impression on the appellate level in this State, although the legal [270 N.J.Super. 512] and factually analogous circumstances have been thoroughly discussed in two previously reported decisions: Associated East Mortgage Co. v. Young, 163 N.J.Super. 315, 394 A.2d 899 (Ch.Div.1978), and Heritage Bank, N.A. v. Ruh, 191 N.J.Super. 53, 465 A.2d 547 (Ch.Div.1983).

Page 574

The factual history of this particular mortgage transaction has been gleaned from a review of the pleadings which include certain stipulated facts jointly submitted to the trial court, as well as information argued by counsel on the motion to strike. On December 6, 1968, defendant Willard Jackson and his wife Katherine, who died March 19, 1991, 1 purchased a residence at 126 Wade Street in Jersey City. The entire purchase price of $22,800 was obtained by a mortgage loan granted by the Commercial Mortgage Company and guaranteed by the Veterans Administration (VA) 2 pursuant to 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 1801 to 1819 (now codified at 38 U.S.C.A. §§ 3701 to 3714). The mortgage bond required monthly payments of principal and interest amortized over a twenty-five year period yielding interest at 6.75 percent per annum plus the payment of one-twelfth of the annual taxes and insurance premiums. The mortgagee was granted the right to pay any installment of any tax, water rent, or other lien levied upon the property and to add any sum thus paid to the mortgage debt to be secured by the mortgage on the real estate. The mortgage was assigned on December 30, 1968 by the Commercial Mortgage Company to the plaintiff.

On January 19, 1990, plaintiff, by its servicing agent Metmor Financial Inc., paid $14,333.25 to the City of Jersey City to satisfy [270 N.J.Super. 513] a lien for unpaid water and sewage charges. 3 In February 1990, defendant was informed by plaintiff's servicing agent that he would be required to repay that sum in six monthly installments. When defendant remitted his regular mortgage payment in March 1990, plaintiff did not apply that payment to the principal, interest, taxes and insurance, as was customary, but chose to apply the payment to the outstanding portion of the mortgage debt attributable to the previously satisfied water and sewage debt. Jackson protested this action and ceased paying any further sum. Plaintiff then filed a foreclosure complaint which alleged a default as of March 1, 1990, and asserted that the principal mortgage debt as of February 1, 1990 was $6,480.46 excluding interest, late penalties and any monies paid by plaintiff as advances for taxes and insurance premiums or in satisfaction of the municipal lien, together with interest which had accrued on all sums advanced by plaintiff. The plaintiff also named as defendants six separate judgment creditors holding six docketed judgments against individuals bearing the name "Willard Jackson or Katherine Jackson" or similar names.

Defendant filed a timely answer and asserted three separate defenses: unclean hands, the violation of the duty of fair dealing, and the failure of plaintiff to comply with the statutory and regulatory prerequisites for foreclosure of this VA-insured mortgage. Thereafter, plaintiff filed a motion to strike the answer and for leave to enter a default against...

To continue reading

FREE SIGN UP