707 F.3d 319 (D.C. Cir. 2013), 12-5116, United Steel, Paper and Forestry, Rubber, Mfg., Energy, Allied Industrial and Service Workers Intern. Union, AFL-CIO-CLC v. Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp.
| Citation | 707 F.3d 319 |
| Opinion Judge | RANDOLPH, Senior Circuit Judge: |
| Party Name | UNITED STEEL, PAPER AND FORESTRY, RUBBER, MANUFACTURING, ENERGY, ALLIED INDUSTRIAL AND SERVICE WORKERS INTERNATIONAL UNION, AFL-CIO-CLC, on behalf of the Participants and Beneficiaries of the Thunderbird Mining Co. Pension Plan, et al., Appellants v. PENSION BENEFIT GUARANTY CORPORATION, Appellee. |
| Attorney | Andrew D. Roth argued the cause for appellant. With him on the briefs were Laurence Gold and David R. Jury. Jeremiah A. Collins entered an appearance. Kenneth J. Cooper, Assistant General Counsel, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, argued the cause for appellee. With him on the brief were Judi... |
| Judge Panel | Before: GARLAND and KAVANAUGH, Circuit Judges, and RANDOLPH, Senior Circuit Judge. |
| Case Date | January 11, 2013 |
| Court | United States Courts of Appeals, U.S. Court of Appeals — District of Columbia Circuit |
Page 319
Argued Nov. 5, 2012.
Page 320
Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Columbia (No. 1:09-cv-00517).
OPINION
This is an appeal from the district court's judgment affirming a decision of the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, the government agency that administers pension termination insurance under Title IV of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended, 29 U.S.C. §§ 1001-1461, commonly known as ERISA. In this case, participants in the Thunderbird Mining Company Pension Plan sought " shutdown" pension benefits. These early retirement benefits are triggered
Page 321
by a " permanent shutdown of a plant, department or subdivision thereof" and are payable to plan participants who meet certain age and years-of-service requirements.1 The agency denied the participants' requests.
Eveleth Mines, LLC, doing business as EVTAC Mining, and its wholly owned subsidiary, Thunderbird Mining Company (we refer to the two companies collectively as " Eveleth" ), produced taconite pellets in a plant in Minnesota. Taconite pellets are used in the production of iron and steel. In early 2003, Eveleth suffered a drastic reduction in orders when two of its primary customers (joint owners of an approximately 85 percent interest in Eveleth) decided to begin purchasing taconite pellets from other sources.
On February 14, 2003, Eveleth sent a confidential letter to the local district director of the United Steel, Paper and Forestry, Rubber, Manufacturing, Energy, Allied Industrial and Service Workers International Union, AFL-CIO-CLC, the union representing Eveleth's approximately four hundred hourly employees. Citing a " lack of customer orders," the letter advised the union of the company's intention to " close permanently" the mining operation " on or about May 14, 2003." The company noted that it was prepared to discuss its proposed course of action and invited the union to " suggest alternative courses."
Unable to secure new orders, Eveleth filed for bankruptcy under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code,2 and on May 15, 2003, ceased production and laid off all but four of its hourly employees. According to a March 10, 2003, notice that Eveleth issued to its employees,3 the closure was expected to be temporary, " but only if anticipated pellet orders are received during the shutdown period."
In connection with the shutdown, management instructed the four remaining hourly employees (and twenty-nine salaried employees) to secure the plant site by, among other things, welding shut the doors and gates, repairing damaged equipment and plumbing, shutting off the electricity, and disconnecting the batteries in equipment and vehicles. The plant had been temporarily shut down in the past, and similar work had been performed. But unlike during prior shutdowns, during this shutdown the plant was not maintained in " standby condition." On June 15, 2003, after this work was completed, Eveleth laid off the four remaining hourly employees, but retained a staff of salaried employees to handle administrative tasks and prevent fire and flooding. In a subsequent filing with the bankruptcy court (in October), the company stated that it " continue[d]
Page 322
to maintain the equipment and other assets associated with its mining operations to protect the enterprise value of its estate" while it sought a purchaser or funding for a plan of reorganization.
On July 5, 2003, Eveleth's president and the local union president met with Jim Oberstar, then a congressman from Minnesota, and discussed Eveleth's failure to secure new sales contracts. The congressman, who knew the Chinese ambassador to the United States, recommended that Eveleth negotiate with Laiwu, a Chinese corporation, to either secure new sales contracts or sell the company's assets. About three months later, in early October, Laiwu and an Ohio mining company offered to purchase Eveleth's assets, with the intention of operating the plant and producing taconite pellets. The proposed sale terms required Eveleth " to restore its mining operations to operating condition consistent with industry practice" in advance of the proposed closing on December 1, 2003. The bankruptcy court approved the sale on November 25, 2003, and the transaction closed on December 1, 2003. On that date, Eveleth permanently laid off all of its employees except three members of management. During the month of December, the purchasers hired substantially all of the company's former hourly employees under the terms of a new collective bargaining agreement.
Meanwhile, after receiving notice of Eveleth's bankruptcy filing in May, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation began analyzing the company's prospects and its ability to sustain its pension plan. The pension-guaranty agency insures participants in defined-benefit pension plans, such as the plan participants in this action, against the loss of certain benefits when the plan lacks sufficient assets to pay promised benefits in full. Subject to certain limitations, when an underfunded pension plan is terminated, the agency guarantees the payment of " nonforfeitable" benefits (i.e., those benefits for which a participant has satisfied the conditions for entitlement under the terms of the plan, as of the date of termination, see 29 U.S.C. § 1301(a)(8)). See id. § 1322; see also PBGC v. LTV Corp., 496 U.S. 633, 636-38, 110 S.Ct. 2668, 110 L.Ed.2d 579 (1990). (This insurance is funded, in part, from premiums paid by employers who sponsor covered pension plans, see 29 U.S.C. §§ 1306, 1307, and recoveries from employers whose underfunded plans have terminated, see id. § 1362.) If the agency determines that a pension plan will be unable to pay benefits when due or that the agency's loss with respect to the plan will increase unreasonably if the plan is not terminated, the agency may initiate proceedings to terminate the plan. See 29 U.S.C. § 1342(a)(2), (4).
Having determined that Eveleth's pension plan had a " funded ratio" of only 52 percent and that Eveleth had " no realistic prospect of adequately funding it," the agency concluded that the plan would be unable to pay benefits when due. The agency also concluded that its long-run loss with respect to the plan would increase unreasonably if the plan was not soon terminated. This was largely because, after Eveleth's bankruptcy filing and the cessation of production in May 2003, laid-off employees had submitted applications for shutdown pension benefits, asserting that their employer had permanently ceased operations. While Eveleth, in its role as plan administrator, took the position that the shutdown was only temporary and thus denied such benefits, the agency believed there was a strong possibility that the shutdown would soon become permanent. The agency determined that upon such a permanent shutdown, the plan would owe an additional $70 million in benefits, of which about $35 million would
Page 323
be guaranteed by the agency. In addition, as of August 1, 2003, the "...
To continue reading
Request your trial