Macklanburg-Duncan Co. v. Aetna Cas. and Sur. Co.

• Decision Date: 05 December 1995
• Docket Number: 93-6158,D-M,Nos. 93-6143,93-6163 and 93-6181,A-1,93-6144,MACKLANBURG-DUNCAN,A-B,s. 93-6143
• Citation: 71 F.3d 1526
• Parties: CO.; Magnetic Peripherals, Inc.; McDonnell Douglas Corporation; PPG Industries; Weyerhauser Company; Wolverine Corporation, Plaintiffs-Appellants and Cross-Appellees, v. AETNA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY; Continental Casualty Company; Interstate Fire and Casualty Company; Stonewall Insurance Company, Defendants-Appellees and Cross-Appellants and Home Indemnity Company, Defendant. DOWNTOWN AIRPARK, INC., a Delaware corporation, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. CONTINENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY, a New Hampshire corporation; Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, a California corporation, Defendants-Appellees. UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff, v. Royal N. HARDAGE; United States Pollution Control; Oklahoma National Stockyards Company; Dal-Worth Industries; Double Eagle; Samuel Bishkin, doing business as Eltex Chemical; L & S Bearing Company; Kerr-McGee Corporation; Cato Oil; PPG Industries; The Firestone Tire and Rubber Company; Foster Feed & Seed Co.; Texaco, Inc.; Powell Sanitation Service, Inc., Defendants, HARDAGE STEERING COMMITTEE MEMBERS: Advance Chemical Distribution, Inc.; Allied-Signal, Inc.; AT & T Technologies, Inc.; Ashland Oil, Inc.; Atlantic Richfield Company; Borg-Warner Corporation; Exxon Corporation; Gencorp, Inc.; Bull HN Information Systems Inc.; Maremont Corporation; McDonnell-Douglas Corporation; Mobil Chemical Company; Nalco Chemical Company; Oklahoma Gas & Electric Company; The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Rockwell International Corporation; Texas Instruments, Incorporated; Uniroyal, Inc.; UOP, Inc.; Westinghouse Electric Corporation; Weyerhaeuser Company; Diffee Motor Company; Fruehauf Corporation, Fruehauf Division; Fruehauf Corporation, doing business as Hobbs Trailer; McAlester Public Schools; Bob McBroom, doing business as American Furniture Stripping, individually; Sooner Ford Truck Sales, Inc., Defendants-Third-Party-Plaintiffs-Appellants and Defendants-Third-Party-Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. A.H. BELO, doing business as Dallas Morning News; JOC Oil, Mornin
• Court: U.S. Court of Appeals — Tenth Circuit

Page 1526

71 F.3d 1526

MACKLANBURG-DUNCAN CO.; Magnetic Peripherals, Inc.;

McDonnell Douglas Corporation; PPG Industries;

Weyerhauser Company; Wolverine

Corporation, Plaintiffs-Appellants and Cross-Appellees, v. AETNA CASUALTY AND SURETY COMPANY; Continental Casualty

Company; Interstate Fire and Casualty Company;

Stonewall Insurance Company,

Defendants-Appellees and Cross-Appellants and

Home Indemnity Company, Defendant.

DOWNTOWN AIRPARK, INC., a Delaware corporation, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. CONTINENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY, a New Hampshire corporation;

Fireman's Fund Insurance Company, a California

corporation, Defendants-Appellees.

UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff, v. Royal N. HARDAGE; United States Pollution Control;

Oklahoma National Stockyards Company; Dal-Worth Industries;

Double Eagle; Samuel Bishkin, doing business as Eltex

Chemical; L & S Bearing Company; Kerr-McGee Corporation;

Cato Oil; PPG Industries; The Firestone Tire and Rubber

Company; Foster Feed & Seed Co.; Texaco, Inc.; Powell

Sanitation Service, Inc., Defendants,

HARDAGE STEERING COMMITTEE MEMBERS: Advance Chemical

Distribution, Inc.; Allied-Signal, Inc.; AT & T

Technologies, Inc.; Ashland Oil, Inc.; Atlantic Richfield

Company; Borg-Warner Corporation; Exxon Corporation;

Gencorp, Inc.; Bull HN Information Systems Inc.; Maremont

Corporation; McDonnell-Douglas Corporation; Mobil Chemical

Company; Nalco Chemical Company; Oklahoma Gas & Electric

Company; The Oklahoma Publishing Company; Rockwell

International Corporation; Texas Instruments, Incorporated;

Uniroyal, Inc.; UOP, Inc.; Westinghouse Electric

Corporation; Weyerhaeuser Company; Diffee Motor Company;

Fruehauf Corporation, Fruehauf Division; Fruehauf

Corporation, doing business as Hobbs Trailer; McAlester

Public Schools; Bob McBroom, doing business as American

Furniture Stripping, individually; Sooner Ford Truck Sales, Inc., Defendants-Third-Party-Plaintiffs-Appellants and Defendants-Third-Party-Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. A.H. BELO, doing business as Dallas Morning News; JOC Oil,

Morning News; ACME Fence & Iron Co.; Alamo Group Texas,

Inc.; AAR Oklahoma, Inc.; Aircraftsman, Inc.; Agnew Auto

Parts; American National Can Corporation; Anadite, Inc.;

Arrow Tank Trucks; Aztec Manufacturing; Arrow Industries;

Aviall of Texas, Inc.; BASF; Betz Laboratories, Inc.;

Blanks Engraving; Beazers Materials; Blackwell Zinc

Company, Inc.; Broadway Machine & Motor Supply, Inc.; The

Bucket Shop, Inc.; Charles Machine Works, Inc.; Container

Supply, Inc.; Carnation Company; Container Corp. of

America; Continental Can Company, Inc.; Cook Paint &

Varnish Co.; CTU of Delaware; Country Home Meat Company;

Dart Industries; Delta Faucet Company; Del Paint

Corporation; Dixico, Inc.; Downtown Airpark, Inc.; Drilex

Systems, Inc.; Dubois Chemicals, Inc.; Dresser Industries,

Inc.; Drillers Engine & Supply, Inc.; Fisher Controls;

GAF; E C Industries; Fred Jones Manufacturing Company;

General Dynamics; General Motors Corporation; Glidden

Company; SCM Corporation; Groendyke Transport, Inc.;

General Electric Company; Goodyear Tire and Rubber, Inc.;

H.W. Allen; Hudiberg Chevrolet; Ingersoll-Rand Oilfield

Products Company; Hinderliter Tool; Johnson Controls,

Inc.; Johnson & Johnson Medical, Inc.; Ortho

Pharmaceutical Corp.; Johnson-Johnson Hospital; Surgikos,

Inc.; Kelly Moore Paint; Kerr Glass Manufacturing;

Jones-Blair Co.; Laidlaw Waste; W.J. Lamberton; Master

Motor Rebuilders, Inc.; Fixture Morris Co.; Madix; George

McKiddie, doing business as Capitol Grease Co.; Motorolla;

Northrop Worldwide Aircraft, doing business as Earl D.

Mills; Packaging Corporation of America; Parker-Hannifin

Corp.; O'Brien Corporation; Printpack, Inc.; Proctor &

Gamble Manufacturing Co.; Quebecor Printing; Maxwell

Communication; Riverside Press; Reliance Universal, Inc.;

Rotex Corporation; Sherwin Williams Company; Star

Manufacturing; Sermatech; Southwest Electric Company;

Stearns & Foster Bedding; Susan Crane; Sublett &

Associates, Inc.; Teccor Electronics, Inc.; TRW, Inc.;

Turbodel; United Plating Works, Inc.; Valley Steel

Products Company; Unit Parts Company; United States Brass

Corporation; Van Der Horst USA; Waste Management of

Oklahoma; Western Uniform & Towel Service; Zoecon

Corporation; Xerox; Magnetic Peripherals, Inc.;

Consolidated Clean.; ABCO, Inc.; Advance Packaging, Inc.;

Amedco Steel Inc.; American Trailers; Anthes Inc., doing

business as Anthes Hi-Reach; Arthur G. McGee & Company; B

& J Tank Truck Service, Inc.; B.W. Solutions, Inc.; Bacon

Transport Company, Inc.; Beauty Craft Vanities; Blackwell

Industrial; Paul Boone, formerly doing business as Lawton

Plating Co., individually; C & H Services, Inc.; CMI

Corporation; Central Oklahoma Equipment Corporation;

Cimarron Aircraft Corporation; Cimarron Manufacturing

Company; Cliftco, Inc.; Day International Corporation;

D-Mac Leasing, Inc.; Eureka Tool Company; Ferris

Resources, Inc.; Hobbs Trailer; Vernon Garney, doing

business as Auto Saver, individually; Glidden Coating, a

Division of SCM Corporation; Hamm & Phillips Service

Company; Industrial Fabrication Co.; Jackie Cooper

Olds-GMC, Inc.; James Bute Company; William Jenkins, doing

business as Foster Septic Tank, individually; J.F. Smith &

Sons, Inc.; Kelsey-Hayes Corporation, also known as Kelsey

Axle & Brakes Co.; Bill Lance; Larry Goad & Company;

Lassiter Enterprises, Inc.; Materials Recovery Enterprises,

Inc.; Ray McGee, doing business as Quality Drum

Service, individually; Grease Company; Medley Material

Handling Inc.; Metroplex Sanitation, Inc.; Mistletoe

Express Service, Inc.; Napko Corporation; Newman Bros.

Trucking Company; Noble Chemical Corporation; The City of

Norman; Oklahoma Tank Service; Oklahoma Transportation

Company; Page Industries, Inc.; Powell Electric

Manufacturing Company; George Powell, doing business as

Powell Service Company, individually; Premier Industrial

Corp., doing business as Kent Industries; RWR Steel

Company; Rabar Enterprises, Inc.; Ram Transports, Inc.;

Reliance Universal Inc.; S & S Plating Company; Solvent

Manufacturing Company, Inc.; Sooner Oil Patch Services,

Inc.; Spector Red Ball, Inc.; Steelcraft, Inc.; Sunwest

Industries of Oklahoma, Inc.; Raymond Switzer, doing

business as Switzer & Gypsum Lime Company, individually;

T.I.P., Inc.; Thermo King Sales & Service of Oklahoma,

Inc.; Triangle Engineering Company; Trigg Drilling

Company, Inc.; Victor Equipment Co.; Waste Services, Inc.;

Welch Enterprises, Inc.; Jim Wesley, doing business as

Jim's Septic Tank, individually; Western Commercial

Transport, Inc.; Westran Corporation; Witco, Inc.; Xal

Corporation; Thomas Engel; A-Better Sanitation Service,

Inc.; Reagent Chemical & Research, Inc.; Sun Exploration &

Prod. Co.; Cameron Iron Works; J.C. Penney Co., Inc.;

Rohm & Haas Seeds, Inc.; Phillips Petroleum Company; South

Prairie Construction Co.; The Atchison, Topeka and Sante Fe

Railway Company; Nordam Corp.; National Can Corp.; Land &

Marine Rental Co., formerly known as Tesoro Land & Marine

Rental Co.; Crowl Machine & Heat Treating Co.; Crane

Carrier Co.; Corning Glass Works; Occidental Chemical;

John Zink Co.; Dura-Chrome Industries, Inc.; The Dow

Chemical Co., also known as Dow Industrial Service of the

Dow Chemical Co.; Dowell Division of the Dow Chemical Co. &

Brasos Oil & Gas Division of the Dow Chemical Co.; IUTS

Liquidating Corp., formerly known as Industrial Uniform &

Towel Supply Inc.; Clyde's Carburetor Service, Inc.; Amoco

Prod. Co., formerly known as Pan American Petroleum; Dover

Resources, Inc.; Hudiburg Chevrolet, Inc.; AMF Tuboscope;

Eason Oil Co.; Fox-Smythe Transportation Co.;

International Crystal Mfg. Co.; Kobe, Inc.; Nelson

Electric, Power Service, Inc.; Newspaper Printing

Corporation; Ryder Truck Rental, Inc., formerly known as

Wilco Truck Rental, Inc.; Southwest Electric Company; Star

Mfg. Co. of Oklahoma; Corken International Corp., formerly

known as Corken Pump Co.; Glow-Lite Corp. (Artra); Ford

Motor Co.; Monsanto Company; Conoco, Inc.; William C.

Whitehead; Ilene J. Whitehead; E.I. Dupont de Nemours &

Co.; Continental Oil Co.; Day International Corporation

(Electric Hose & Rubber); Central Sales Promotion, Inc.; W

& W Steel Co.; Chromalloy American; Brittain Brothers;

ICO, Inc., formerly known as Fodco, Inc., formerly known as

Sucker Rod Service, formerly known as Rodcore, Inc.; Homco

International, doing business as A-1 Bit & Tool; Tom

Brown's Optical Service, Inc., Farmers Home Administration,

Third-Party-Defendants,

Ralph L. Lowe, Fourth-Party-Defendant, and

Aetna Casualty and Surety Company; Continental Casualty

Company; Interstate Fire and Casualty Company;

Stonewall Insurance Company,

Garnishee-Appellees and

Garnishee-Appellants.

Nos. 93-6143, 93-6144, 93-6158, 93-6163 and 93-6181.

United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit.

Dec. 5, 1995.

Susan L. Gates (Michael D. Graves with her on the brief) of Hall, Estill, Hardwick, Gable, Golden & Nelson, P.C., Tulsa, Oklahoma, for Plaintiffs-Appellants and Cross-Appellees in Appeal Nos. 93-6143 and 93-6163, and Defendants-Third-Party-Plaintiffs-Appellants and Defendants-Third-Party-Plaintiffs-Appellees in Appeal Nos. 93-6158 and 93-6181.

F. Thomas Cordell, Jr., of Huckaby, Fleming, Frailey, Chaffin & Darrah, Chickasha, Oklahoma (John Dexter Marble of Huckaby, Fleming, Frailey, Chaffin & Darah, Chickasha, Oklahoma, Victor C. Harwood, III, Edward Zampino, and Peter E. Mueller of Harwood Lloyd, Hackensack, New Jersey, with him on the brief), for Defendants-Appellees and Cross-Appellants in Appeal Nos. 93-6143 and 93-6163, and Garnishee-Appellees and Garnishee-Appellants in Appeal Nos. 93-6158 and 93-6181.

June L. Chubbuck of Chubbuck, Bullard & Hoehner, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, Ira Goldberg of Long & Levit, San Francisco, California, Eileen M. Morris, Kenneth W. Elliott, and Duncan Parks of Elliott & Morris, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, Donald R. Wilson and Brenda K. Peterson of Fenton, Fenton, Smith, Reneau & Moon, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, and Marjorie H. Mintzer of ...