720 Fed.Appx. 889 (9th Cir. 2018), 15-55952, Alvarado v. City of Los Angeles

• Docket Nº: 15-55952, 15-55955, 15-55956, 15-55957, 15-55958, 15-55959, 15-55960, 15-55962, 15-55964, 15-55965, 15-55966, 15-55969, 15-55974, 15-56324, 15-56325, 15-56899, 15-56949, 15-56957, 15-56959, 15-56960, 15-56961, 15-56962, 15-56963, 15-56964, 15-56967, 15-56969, 15-56973
• Citation: 720 Fed.Appx. 889
• Party Name: ROBERT ALVARADO, Plaintiff, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. and JEFFREY ANDERSON; RUDY BARRIGAN; KEITH BERTONNEAU; JAMES BROWN; PETER BUENO; ANDREW BUESA; GEORGE BUSH II; TIMOTHY COLOMEY; DAVID CORBET; RUBEN DE LA TORRE; REBECCA GALLEGOS; ROBERT GALLEGOS; MICHAEL GANNON; ULYSSES GASCA; ALAN GILMER; MICHAEL GLENN; ANTHONY GONZALES; R...
• Attorney: For Jeffrey Anderson, Rudy Barrigan, Keith Bertonneau, James Brown, Peter Bueno, Andrew Buesa, George Bush II, Timothy Colomey, David Corbet, Ruben DE LA Torre, Rebecca Gallegos, Robert Gallegos, Michael Gannon, Ulysses Gasca, Alan Gilmer, Michael Glenn, Anthony Gonzales, Robert Guyer, Loma Holla...
• Judge Panel: Before: LINN, BERZON, and M. SMITH, Circuit Judges.
• Case Date: April 30, 2018
• Court: United States Courts of Appeals, Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Tweet

 

FREE EXCERPT

Page 889

720 Fed.Appx. 889 (9th Cir. 2018) ROBERT ALVARADO, Plaintiff, and JEFFREY ANDERSON; RUDY BARRIGAN; KEITH BERTONNEAU; JAMES BROWN; PETER BUENO; ANDREW BUESA; GEORGE BUSH II; TIMOTHY COLOMEY; DAVID CORBET; RUBEN DE LA TORRE; REBECCA GALLEGOS; ROBERT GALLEGOS; MICHAEL GANNON; ULYSSES GASCA; ALAN GILMER; MICHAEL GLENN; ANTHONY GONZALES; ROBERT GUYER; LOMA HOLLAND; LYLE KNIGHT; LORI LEE; KEVIN LOVE; NICHOLAS MILAZZO; KURT MILES; JONATHAN MILLER; JAMES MOODY; KI NAM; JOSEPH O'DONNELL; ALAN RAMIREZ; JESSE REYES; RANDY RICO; RAY RODRIGUEZ; DOUGLAS ROLLER; LISA RUEGG; TERRY RUPPEL; CATHERINE RYMSZA-LEON; JOHNNY SANCHEZ; SUCHA SINGH, Jr.; AARON SKIVE; MICHAEL SLEDD; TANZA SMALLS; SANDRA SMITH; RONALD STAMPS; STEVEN STEAR; LANE STERLING; JOHN STIEGLITZ; JOHN THOMAS; GERALD TOMIC; TONY TRUS; OMAR VELOZ; RICHARD WAAK; CHRISTOPHER WALTER; DIONNE WATTS; MICHAEL WILLIAMSON; ERIC WINDHAM; PHILLIP WRIGHT, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. JASON ABNER, Plaintiff, and EDWARD ACOSTA; LUIS ALVARADO; VICTOR ALVAREZ; MICHAEL ARTEAGA; ALEXANDER BAUTISTA; ROBERT BISHOP; THOMAS BOJORQUEZ; SHANE BUA; JOHN CAMPOS; JUAN CAMPOS; FRANCISCO CARRILLO; CLAUDIA CASTRUITA; TOM CHAVEZ; JAMES CHONG; STEVE CHUNG; KIMBERLY CISCO; CHARLES CLAEYS; DIMITRIUS CONNOR; DIOSDADO CORONEL; HENRY COVARRUBIAS; LARRY COVINGTON; CARLOS DIAZ; REGGIE DICKERSON; OSCAR DUENAS; AMIE EL FARRA; CARLOS ESCOBAR; FERDINAND FAUSTINO, Jr.; MICHAEL FIELDS; TONY FITZSIMMONS; MARTIN FRANCO; MICHAEL FRIESENHAHN; ALEJANDRO GALVAN; FRANK GARCIA; RANDY GARCIA; MAGDALENO GOMEZ; ALBERT GONZALES; CLAUDIA GRAY; VICTOR GUTIERREZ; SEAN HART; PAUL HENDRY; DAVID HERNANDEZ; TERESA HERNANDEZ; MARK HUBERT; SAMER ISSA; JORGE JUAREZ; BRIAN KOREN; STEVEN KOTSINADELIS; R. MAGGIE LUQUIN; JAMES MARTINEZ; JOSEPH MCDOWELL; HEATHER MCLEAN; JOSE MIRELES; JAMES MUNIZ; RYAN NGUYEN; VICTOR NUNEZ; CARLOS OCEGUEDA; SAL OGAZ, Jr.; ISAIAS ORNELAS; ALFRED PASOS; MARTIN PERELLO; JOSE PEREZ; RICHARD PLATZER, Jr.; RICHARD RAMOS; CHRISTOPHER RAZO; JOSE REYES, Jr.; ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ; IRIS SANTIN; EDAN SHEKLOW; EDDIE SOLOMON; GREGORY STAATS; JUSTIN STEWART; CHARLES SURH; DARIUS TRUGMAN; HECTOR URENA; LILIA VELASCO; MATTHEW VOCKE; KEITH WASHINGTON; BART WITHEROW; EDMOND YAGUBYAN; CLIFTON YAMAMOTO; PHILIP ZALBA; EDWARD ZAMORA; SANDRA ZAMORA; CARLOS ZARAGOZA; MATTHEW ZEIGLER, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. MEGHAN AGUILAR, Plaintiff, and TEDDY AMSTONE; SANG AN; TERESA ANDERSON; JOSE ARELLANO; JUAN ARENAS; MARIO ARRIZON; JOSEPH AVILA; RUBEN BANUELOS; TERRY BARCLAY; MICHAEL BARZ; WILLIAM BATISTA; CYNTHIA BELLO; RYAN BELLOWS; JULIO BENAVIDES; RONALD BERDIN; LANCE BLAKE; GINA BRACHT; DANIEL CALDERON; JORGE CERVANTES; JAIME CHACON; TODD CHANEY; ENRIQUE CHAVEZ; RICHARD COMPTON; EFRAIN CONTRERAS; MIGUEL CONTRERAS; MARTY COTWRIGHT; RAQUEL CRUZ; ROBERT DEAMER; EMILY DELPH; FRANCISCO DIAZ, Sr.; CHARLES DICKINSON; JOSEPH DOMINGUEZ; VALENTINE FLORES; TIM GALLI; ALFRED GARCIA; LISA GARCIA; STEVE GARCIA; DANIEL GERSNA; ADRIANA GONZALEZ; JAMES GOODWIN; DANA GRANT; RONALD GRAY, Administrative Law Judge; MARK GRIEGO; OSCAR GUTIERREZ; IRSIE HENRY; RANDY HOFFMASTER; MICHAEL HOFMEYER; JENNIFER HOWLETT; LUIS JURADO; DOUGLAS KIRKLAND; JOHN KNIGHTON; LAURO LARRINUA; CESAR LEAL; DOUGLAS LONG; DEBBIE LOPEZ; ANDRES LUGO; PEDRO MACHUCA; EDWARD MACIEL, Jr.; LEONARDO MCKENZIE; SEAN MEADE; IGNACIO MIJARES; BILL MILLER; PAUL MILLER; MICHAEL MITCHELL; MARIA MONTOYA; BRENDA MORALES; HUGH O'GARA; JOSEPH OSEGURA; ROBERT PATERSON; EDWARD PETTEREZ; RUBEN QUINTANAR; STEVEN RALPH; MANUEL RAMIREZ; MARK REED; JOHN RICHARDSON; MICHAEL RICHARDSON; MICHAEL RIMKUNAS; MICHAEL RIPPE; EDWARD ROCHA; ROCAEL RODRIGUEZ; JOEL RUIZ; ROBERT RUIZ; ANTHONY SAENZ; DIANA SALCIDO; PAUL SANFILLIPPO; JOSE SANTIAGO; CARLOS SAVEDRA; CLAIRE SMITH; MICHAEL SMITH; ERIC SPEAR; CHARLES SPICER III; JEFFREY STAPLETON; CHRISTIAN URBINA; JAMES VENA; SHARLTON WAMPLER; MARK MASCARENO; GLORIA WOOD; CHARLES WUNDER; JAMES ZOUREK, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. FREDDIE ACKERLEY, Plaintiff, and RICHARD ACOSTA; ROBERT ANDRENO; MANUEL ARZATE; WENDI BERNDT; STEVEN BEUMER; JAVIER BORREGO; ROBERT BROPHY; STEPHEN BUCHER; ALMA BURKE; HOWARD CHOY; JOHN COLLYER; VINCENT DEGLINNOCENTI; MICHAEL DIAZ; JOHN DOWNEY; KENNITH FERRO; TRACYE FIELDS; GARRETT FITZGERALD; WILLIAM FLANNERY; CHRISTOPHER FORMBY; ANTONINO GIAMBRUNO; CYNTHIA GOMEZ; GERARDO GUTIERREZ; DAVID HABIBI; SHAWN HAVICAN; JAMES HAYS, Jr.; GEORGE HOOPES; LAMONT JERRETT; MARK JOHNSON; MYRA KELLUM; DONOVAN LYONS; CATHERINE MASSEY; JAMES MCSORLEY; ANGELEAN MONTERO; GERARDO MORALES; RAMON MUNIZ; MIKE NELSON; ANTHONY OCHOA; ELPIDIO OROZCO; JERRY PADILLA; JOHN PADILLA; LEWIS PARKER; JOSEPH PELAYO; REYNALDO PEREZ, Jr.; BRIAN PRESTON; STEVEN RAMIREZ; SHEILA RIZZOLO; HOWARD SILVERSTEIN; MAGE SIMERSKEY; THOMAS SMALL; CINTHIA TAPIA; FRED TREDY; JIM TUMBEIRO; ROBERT VARGAS; PAMELA VENTURA; WALTER WILLIS; BILL WILSON; JASON WITT; JOEY YANEZ; RENE ZAVALA, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. ANTHONY ACEVES, Plaintiff, and CRAIG ADAMS; FELICIA BAILEY; KENNETH BARTNICKI; JAMES BLAND; JULIE BROWNE; JULIAN CANALES; JOSE CASTELLANOS; JAMES CHONG; ROSALYN CLARK; CRYSTAL N. DAVIS; CRYSTAL NOVA DAVIS; JOYCE DAVIS; JORGE DE JESUS III; TRAVONNE DIXON; CHRISTY DONOROVICH O'DONNELL; LISA DURAN; GILBERT ESCONTRIAS; STACIE FRENCH; DANIEL GARCIA; RICHARD GARIBAY; STEPHEN GORDON; PATRICIA GUESSFERD; JOEL HERNANDEZ; EMERSON HOLDER; FRANCISCO HURTADO; JASON JACOBSON; MICHAEL JOLICOEUR; ROBIN JONES; MICHAEL KARATSONYI; HO KIM; KENT LAU; CELIA KOMATHY; RICHARD LARIMER; ROBERT LEWIS; CLANCY MAIHORI; GUS MARTINEZ; RICHARD MELENDEZ; HENRY MENDOZA; RODERICK MILLER; STEVE MORRIS; MARIA MORRISON; GREGORY NICHOLS; ADAM NIEBERGALL; DARYL ORDONE; JOHN PASQUARIELLO; YVETTE PERRODIN; ADRIANNA PRADO; LASHAWNA PUGH; DANIEL PUTZ; THOMAS RALPH; TED REYLAND; DOUGLAS ROACH; RICHARD RUSSELL; JAMES SANDS; SALLY SANTAMARIA; JOSEPH SATOW; ROSIBEL SMITH; LINDA THOMPSON; KYLE TOLLIVER; MICHAEL TOLMAIRE; MANUEL VIDES; SHAWNTRICE WATKINS; FELICIANO WILSON; LAURA WINDSOR; AMY WONG; ANTHONY VILARDO; MARIA YAMAMOTO; DIANA ZAMORA, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. FRANK AMADOR, Jr., Plaintiff, and MAURICE BRUNEL; WALLACE CARR; CHRISTIAN CHRISTENSEN; JOSEPH CIANCANELLI; JEFFREY COLLADO; MARLO CROSS; GARY CUSICK; PATRICK DELANEY; NGUYEN DO; TINA GLENN; STEVEN GROSS; MAURICE HALLAUER; EDWARD HEREDIA; MARK HERNANDEZ; GARY HOLBROOK; CHARLES HOWARD; MICHAEL KILPATRICK; EDWARD KIM; STEPHANIE KRAJCHIR; TERESA LINCOLN; HECTOR LOMELIN; JOHN LONG; JAMES MACDONALD; DAVID MORALES; MICHELL NOWLEN; JOHNY ONYSHKO, Jr.; ROBERT ORLANDO; GREGORY OWENS; JEFFREY PAILET; JOHN POLAND; MARK PRECIADO; DANIEL PUTNAM; ENGELBERT QUECHENBERGER; NICHOLAS TITIRIGG; JORGE TORRES; ALAN THATCHER; JOHN VACH, Jr.; PHIL WALTERS; DALE WASHBURN; BRIAN WILSON; WILLIAM YOUNG; JEREMY YAMAMOTO, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. TROY ABORDO, Plaintiff, and RICHARD ADAIR; STEVEN BISHOP; TIMOTHY BOHAC; OSMUND BOUILGNY; DARRYL BROWN; JAMES CLIFFORD; JOHN COFFEY; CASEY COX; KAREN CRAWFORD; DANIEL DAVIS; AJ DE BELLIS; VICTORIA DE BELLIS; SPREE DESHA; BERZON DISTOR; SERGIO DRIOTEZ; CARLOS FIGUEIRA; KELENE GIBSON; CESAR GONZALEZ; RYAN ICAGAN; SUSAN INVERNO; BILLY JOE; WILLIAM LANTZ; THOMAS LEE; GEORGE LEONARD; RICHARD LOKEN; RAMON MARTINEZ; SCOTT MOFFITT; PABLO MONTERROSA; RAYMONA MOUSSA; OSWALDO PEDEMONTE; RICHARD PEREZ; ROGER PEREZ; PAUL RICCHIAZZI; DAVID RODRIGUEZ; RICK ROY; PAUL RUMER; TIMOTHY TULLY SCOTT I; JOHN SMITH; MARK STRATTON; ANTONIO VARGAS; ROBERT VILLALOBOS; NEIL WANK; RICKY WEBB, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, Defendant-Appellee. TYRONE ACOSTA, Plaintiff, and MIGUEL AGUAYO; ROBERT AGUILAR; VINCENT AGUIRRE; CRAIG ALLEN; ADAM ALTAMMIRANO; FERNANDO ALVAREZ; RALPH ALVAREZ; MIGUEL ARAMBULA; LEONARD AVILA; MARIAN BAUSELY; MICHAEL BELMONTE; RIGO BONILLA; BARRY BOTTAI; INGE BOWMAN; RALPH CAMARILLO; DANIEL CAMPBELL; MARK CAMPBELL; GIL CARDINEZ; SANDRA CARLISLE; JOHN CASTILLO; FEDERICO CELIS; JOHN CHILSTROM; JIN CHO; ALFONSO CISNEROS; HENRY COLEBROOKE; JOSE CONTRERAS; VIC CORELLA; ROBERT COSNER; KRIS DAVIS; JOSE DE LEON; LUIS DELACRUZ; ALFREDO DELGADO; BLANCA DESORMAUX; EDDIE DIAZ; JOSEPH DUDAS; ROBERT DUKE; CORINNE ERNST; GISSELLE ESPINOZA; DONALD ESTRADA; JOSE FERRERIA; JEREMY FINK; PAUL FLOGE; MICHAEL P. FLYNN; MICHAEL R. FLYNN; AARON FOUGERE; RANDOLPH FUKUI; RAYMOND GALLUCCIO; ELMER GIBSON; ALICIA GILMER; ROBERT GOLDEN; MICHAEL GOMEZ; FIDEL GONZALEZ; JENNIFER GRASSO; CHRISTOPHER GREEN, Jr.; STEVEN GRIMMER; ANGEL GUERRA; RAY GUERRERO; CESAR GUITNON; ROSALINDA GUTIERREZ; RAY HALLENBECK; MICHAEL HILL; PETER HOPKINS; JOSE HURTADO; MARTHA JAIME; JESSE JAMES; RICKY JOHNSON; DANNY JONES; STANLEY KANE; WILLIAM KIPP; DAVID KONG; DAVID KRUMER; HERMAN LANDRY, Sr.; GARY LEFFEW; JAMES LENOUE; JERRY LIGGETT; HIPOLITO LIZARRAGA; THOMAS LO; RICHARD LOCKETT; RUSSELL LONG; ROBERT LOPEZ; MICHAEL LORENZ; CHRISTOPHER LUNA; FRANCISCO MACIAS; GERARDO MADERA; BRIAN MALNERITCH; JOSEPHINE MAPSON; AUGUSTO MARIANO; ROBERT MARTIN; JIMMY MARTINEZ; DAWN-AMBER MCCALLUM; VICTOR MEDRANO; GEORGE MEJIA; GINA MEZA; JAVIER MONTENEGRO; MICHAEL MORALES; TIMOTHY MORRIS; ERNESTO MUNOZ; ALEJANDRO NAVA; DAVID NUNEZ; LEROI O'BRIEN; MARIO ONTIVEROS, Jr.; DAVID ORTIZ; GREGORY ORTIZ; KAREN OWENS; MARIO PARRILLO; CHRISTOPHER PATERSON; SCARLETT PATERSON; NEAL PETERSON; CLINTON POPHAM II; ERI POSS; ALEXANDER POZO; JAMES QUINLAN; CARLOS QUINTERO; JEFF QUINTON; ROGELIO RAMIREZ; MARIO RAMIREZ, Jr.; ABE RANGEL; JOHN RAY; JAMES REDMAN; UNNEYUNG REE; JOHN RICE; DAVID RIDDICK; BERNICE RIVERA; RAYMOND ROBINSON; JUAN RODRIGUEZ; RAUL RODRIGUEZ; IGNACIO ROJAS; DAVID ROMERO; JOHN ROYSDEN; MATTHEW SAENZ; JOSE SALCEDO; PETER SANCHEZ; JUAN SANTOS; ERNIE SCHOOP; MICHAEL SEGUIN; HENRY SERVIN; KERRY SUPRENANT; ROBERT TAKANASHI; RICHARD...