Adams v. Northern Illinois Gas Co.

Citation809 N.E.2d 1248,284 Ill.Dec. 302,211 Ill.2d 32
Decision Date01 April 2004
Docket NumberNo. 94748.,94748.
CourtSupreme Court of Illinois
PartiesChristy ADAMS, Special Adm'r of the Estate of Janice Adams, Deceased, Appellee, v. NORTHERN ILLINOIS GAS COMPANY, Appellant.

809 N.E.2d 1248
211 Ill.2d 32
284 Ill.Dec. 302

Christy ADAMS, Special Adm'r of the Estate of Janice Adams, Deceased, Appellee,
v.
NORTHERN ILLINOIS GAS COMPANY, Appellant

No. 94748.

Supreme Court of Illinois.

April 1, 2004.

Rehearing Denied May 24, 2004.


809 N.E.2d 1252
Gino L. DiVito, of Tabet, DiVito & Rothstein, and Tyrone C. Fahner, Roger J. Kiley, George J. Tzanetopoulos, Robert M. Dow, Jr., and Joel D. Bertocchi, of Mayer, Brown, Rowe & Maw, L.L.P., Chicago, for appellant

William F. Martin, of Hilfman, Fogel, Martin & Barr, P.C., and Thomas R. Rakowski, of Connelly, Roberts & McGivney, L.L.C., Chicago, for appellee.

Barbara Baran and Darren J. Hunter, of Ross & Hardies, Chicago, for amici curiae The Peoples Gas Light & Coke Co. et al.

Justice FREEMAN delivered the opinion of the court:

Plaintiff, Christy Adams, as special administrator of the estate of Janice Adams,

809 N.E.2d 1253
brought a wrongful-death action in the circuit court of Cook County against Northern Illinois Gas Company (NI-Gas). The circuit court granted NI-Gas' motion for summary judgment. The appellate court reversed the grant of summary judgment in favor of NI-Gas and remanded the cause for further proceedings. 333 Ill. App.3d 215, 266 Ill.Dec. 411, 774 N.E.2d 850. We allowed NI-Gas' petition for leave to appeal (177 Ill.2d R. 315(a)), and now affirm the appellate court

BACKGROUND

The record contains the following pertinent evidence. Since 1971, Janice Adams (decedent) resided in a house located at 1294 Greenbay Avenue in Calumet City. Decedent's mother, Lucia Georgevich, bought the house, but decedent paid the mortgage and the utilities. Various appliances in the house, including a range, were fueled by natural gas.

On the evening of December 7, 1995, decedent arrived home, opened a door, and stepped inside. The house exploded and was engulfed in flames, causing her death.

First at the scene was the Calumet City fire department. Assistant chief Dan Smits and fire investigator Joe Ratkovich investigated the cause and origin of the explosion. Smits saw the fire and saw that the walls of the house had been blown out. He observed the body of decedent just inside what had been an entrance to the house. Smits inspected the gas meter, gas piping, and gas appliances and directed that all those items be removed and preserved.

The Calumet City fire department determined that the cause of the explosion and fire was the failure of the flexible brass gas connector that connected the kitchen range to the gas supply. The brand name of the connector was "Cobra." Failure of the connector permitted a large amount of natural gas to escape and accumulate in the house. When decedent entered the house and turned on an electric light, a small spark from the switch ignited the gas. The Illinois State Fire Marshall, the United States Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, and the private fire investigator employed by the homeowner's insurance carrier also investigated the explosion and all agreed that it was caused by the failure of the gas connector to the range.

Plaintiff, one of decedent's daughters, brought a wrongful-death action in a two-count, first amended complaint. Count II named NI-Gas as a defendant.1 Plaintiff alleged that NI-Gas "knew that Cobra brand natural gas appliance connectors were defective and prone to failure resulting in natural gas leaks and explosions." Plaintiff alleged that NI-Gas "had a duty to warn its customers, including plaintiff's decedent, about the existence of Cobra brand natural gas appliance connectors and the dangers of natural gas leak, explosion and fire associated with these connectors." Plaintiff alleged that NI-Gas breached this duty to warn in that NI-Gas: failed to provide (a) any or (b) adequate

809 N.E.2d 1254
warning; (c) used an ineffective means to inform customers; (d) failed to initiate an inspection program to identify and remove Cobra brand natural gas appliance connectors from customer homes and businesses; and (e) failed to properly inspect decedent's home "to cause the removal of the aforesaid Cobra brand connector."

The record includes the depositions of several opinion witnesses, including Charles Lamar, Wayne Genck, Norman Breyer, and Edward Karnes. Their testimony adduced the following additional evidence.

The connector in this case was manufactured by the Cobra Hose Company, which has been out of business since 1979. Made as early as 1953, Cobra connectors were widely used in Illinois and other states. The Cobra connector essentially was a corrugated flexible brass tube with threaded brass connectors at each end that connect a gas appliance to the hard pipe gas source. The threaded connectors were telescoped and fastened to the ends of the corrugated brass tube by a process known as brazing. The compound used in the brazing process is composed of phosphorized brazing alloys containing a substantial portion of phosphorous and a high percent age of copper.

It is undisputed that natural gas, in its original state, is odorless. The chemical ethyl mercaptan, which is a sulfur component, is added as an odorant to give natural gas its distinctive smell. In addition to sulfur that is intentionally added, natural gas itself produces sulfur compounds through intrinsic chemical reactions. By law, NI-Gas is required to supply odorized gas to its customers as a safety precaution, so that customers more easily can detect a gas leak. The natural gas that NI-Gas supplied to decedent was as the law required it to be.

However, when sulfur is added to natural gas, as in the present chemical reaction begins to occur between the phosphorous brazing alloy and the sulfur. This chemical reaction causes the brazed joint to corrode and deteriorate. Over time, the deterioration of the brazed joint results in its separation from the corrugated tube and the consequent release of natural gas into the home. Even, the naturally occurring sulfides in the gas are sufficient to cause the brazed connector eventually to fail.

In 1968, the American National Standards Institute (ANSI)2 revised its standards on gas connectors and banned phosphprous brazing. ANSI's Z21 subcommittee on connectors is the committee that has jurisdiction over all domestic standards for natural gas ranges, furnaces, water heaters, and connectors. The Z21 specifications were modified to warn that the use of brazing compounds that contain phosphorous can result in a brittle joint and can be deadly.

The record contains evidence that NI-Gas was aware of the potential danger in homes using Cobra connectors. In May 1976, NI-Gas' supervisor of Research Services reported to the Z21 subcommittee that the "sudden, mysterious separation of brass connectors and their brazed-on end fittings has been a concern of gas utility people for several years." In a letter dated December 14, 1979, the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission informed

809 N.E.2d 1255
the American Gas Association (AGA) that Cobra connectors allegedly caused a number of fires in homes. According to the letter, while some jurisdictions did not allow the installation of Cobra connectors, many such connectors "may still be in service, and therefore may be susceptible to creating a significant hazard to the occupants of those residences equipped with such connectors." On December 19, the president of the AGA sent a letter to all its member companies, including NI-Gas, stating that the Commission had notified AGA that Cobra connectors had an increasing potential to fail over time

The record also includes copies of "Consumer News" notices that NI-Gas sent to its customers. The August/September 1978, June/July 1980, summer/fall 1981, and December 1981 notices indicated that an old connector could crack, creating an unsafe condition, when the appliance was moved. The December 1981, January 1985, May 1986, and June 1987 notices warned: "The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission has warned that certain appliance connectors manufactured prior to 1968 may be unsafe. If you are concerned, do not try to move the appliance to inspect the connector. Instead, call a qualified service agency of NI-Gas to make the inspection."

Also, NI-Gas knew that failed Cobra connectors were determined to have caused many explosions and fires within its service area, including Aurora, Evanston, and Rockford. In the 1970s there were a series of fires in the Village of South Holland associated with brazed connectors. Wayne Kortum, a volunteer firefighter in South Holland and a NI-Gas employee, informed NI-Gas supervisors at the Glenwood district office, the district that includes the decedent's home, about the connectors involved with these fires. Thereafter, Kortum attended a general meeting at the Glenwood office where NI-Gas supervisors informed him and other service employees that there were problems with brazed connectors and that the service employees should look for these connectors in customers' homes.

In November 1984, NI-Gas representatives participated in a meeting with officials from the Village of Skokie. The Skokie fire department had determined that several fires and an explosion in the Village were related to brazed connector failures. Carol Anderson, one of the NI-Gas attendees, testified that in the 1980s she was aware that brazed connectors were a hazard. According to John Agosti, a Skokie fire official, NI-Gas represented that it would notify its service and construction personnel about replacing brazed connectors. In turn, these employees would warn the NI-Gas customers with whom they came in contact.

Charles Henry, a trained NI-Gas serviceman, testified in a deposition as follows. NI-Gas instructed its service employees on the potential danger of Cobra connectors. When a NI-Gas employee encountered a brazed connector, the employee was required to tag the connector and advise the customer that the connector needed to be replaced as soon as possible.

Decedent's ex-husband...

To continue reading

Request your trial
532 cases
  • Schweihs v. Chase Home Fin., LLC
    • United States
    • Illinois Supreme Court
    • December 15, 2016
    ... ... CHASE HOME FINANCE, LLC, et al., Appellees. Docket No. 120041 Supreme Court of Illinois. Opinion filed December 15, 2016. 77 N.E.3d 53 Edward T. Joyce, Jennifer L. Doherty, and Joan M ... Adams v. Northern Illinois Gas Co. , 211 Ill.2d 32, 4243, 284 Ill.Dec. 302, 809 N.E.2d 1248 (2004) ... ...
  • Vision Point of Sale, Inc. v. Haas
    • United States
    • Illinois Supreme Court
    • September 20, 2007
    ... 875 N.E.2d 1065 ... 226 Ill.2d 334 ... VISION POINT OF SALE, INC., an Illinois Corporation, Appellee, ... Ginger HAAS et al., Appellants ... No. 103140 ... Supreme Court ... 939, 692 N.E.2d 1150 (1998); see also Adams v. Northern Illinois Gas Co., 211 Ill.2d 32, 48, 284 Ill.Dec. 302, 809 N.E.2d 1248 (2004) (setting ... ...
  • Guns Save Life, Inc. v. Ali
    • United States
    • United States Appellate Court of Illinois
    • March 13, 2020
    ... ... in his capacity as Cook County Sheriff, and the County of Cook, a county in the State of Illinois, Defendants-Appellees. No. 1-18-1846 Appellate Court of Illinois, First District, FIFTH DIVISION ... Adams v. Northern Illinois Gas Co. , 211 Ill. 2d 32, 42-43, 284 Ill.Dec. 302, 809 N.E.2d 1248 (2004). A ... ...
  • Great Am. Ins. Co. of N.Y. v. Heneghan Wrecking & Excavating Co.
    • United States
    • United States Appellate Court of Illinois
    • December 11, 2015
    ... ... Nos. 1133376 1133486. Appellate Court of Illinois, First District, Fifth Division. Dec. 11, 2015. 46 N.E.3d 862 Andreou & Casson Ltd., Chicago ... that remained as to whether the demolition was a substantial factor in the collapse of the northern wall of the Wirt Dexter building. The circuit court further denied Heneghan and Concord's motion ... Adams v. Northern Illinois Gas Co., 211 Ill.2d 32, 43, 284 Ill.Dec. 302, 809 N.E.2d 1248 (2004). The ... ...
  • Request a trial to view additional results
1 books & journal articles

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT