Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc. v. 99 Cent Stuff-Trail Plaza, LLC
Citation | 811 So.2d 719 |
Decision Date | 20 February 2002 |
Docket Number | No. 3D01-1643.,3D01-1643. |
Parties | WINN-DIXIE STORES, INC., a Florida Corporation, Appellant, v. 99 CENT STUFF—TRAIL PLAZA, LLC, etc., and Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, a foreign corporation, Appellees. |
Court | Court of Appeal of Florida (US) |
Kaufman, Dickstein & Grunspan and Alan M. Grunspan, Miami, for appellant.
Broad and Cassel and Ronald M. Gache, West Palm Beach; Roth & Scholl and Jeff Roth, for appellee.
Before FLETCHER and SORONDO, JJ., and NESBITT, Senior Judge.
Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc., appeals an order granting its Motion for Temporary Injunctive Relief, claiming the relief granted was insufficient.
Winn-Dixie operated a supermarket in the Trail Plaza Shopping Center. Winn-Dixie's lease granted an exclusivity provision, restricting its landlord from permitting other tenants from selling certain products sold by Winn-Dixie. That lease provides in pertinent part:
Landlord covenants and agrees that the Tenant shall have the exclusive right to operate a supermarket in the shopping center * * * Landlord further covenants and agrees that it will not directly or indirectly lease or rent any property located within the shopping center * * * for occupancy as a supermarket, grocery store, meat, fish or vegetable market[;] * * * and Landlord further covenants and agrees not to permit or suffer any property located within the shopping center to be used for or occupied by any business dealing in or which shall keep in stock or sell for off-premises consumption any staple or fancy groceries, meats, fish, vegetables, fruits, bakery goods, dairy products or frozen foods without written permission of the Tenant; except the sale of such items is not to exceed the lesser of 500 square feet of sales area or 10% of the square foot area of any storeroom within the shopping center, as an incidental only to the conduct of another business[.] (Emphasis added.)
In 1999, Winn-Dixie's landlord leased approximately 22,000 square feet of space in Trail Plaza to 99 Cent Stuff for the operation of a "megastore." The 99 Cent Stuff lease listed several prohibited uses for the leased premises, including a provision that mirrored the Winn-Dixie exclusive:
EXHIBIT C
PROHIBITED USES
Shortly after 99 Cent Stuff opened, it began selling products which, according to Winn-Dixie, violated the above stated lease provisions. The supermarket complained to its landlord who then sent an agent to inspect. The agent concluded that 99 Cent Stuff was violating its lease. When notified, 99 Cent Stuff's Chief Executive Officer, John Isaac, responded that he would re-merchandise the store. By February 15, 2000, Isaac asserted that the problem had been corrected.
The landlord's agent reinspected, determined a lease violation continued, and issued a second notice.1 Isaac contacted the agent, arguing that his store was in compliance with its lease. Attempting to comply with the limitation on the sale of "staple or fancy groceries," while at the same time, no doubt, defining the terms at issue in a manner which would least fetter his store's permissible product base, in a feat of entrepreneurial jujitsu, Isaac had gone to the Florida Administrative Code, and from there, he had found a definition of general grocery items in a Tax Information Publication. Isaac concluded that nothing in the store's price...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc. v. Dolgencorp, LLC
...state interpreting a restrictive covenant materially identical to many of those at issue here. See Winn–Dixie Stores, Inc. v. 99 Cent Stuff–Trail Plaza, LLC, 811 So.2d 719 (Fla. 3d DCA 2002). As we read controlling Florida law, “groceries” broadly includes food and “many household supplies ......
-
In re Standard Jury Instructions—Contract & Business Cases
...Dade Cnty., 65 So.2d 729, 731 (Fla.1953); Langley v. Owens, 52 Fla. 302, 42 So. 457, 460 (1906); Winn–Dixie Stores, Inc. v. 99 Cent Stuff–Trail Plaza, LLC, 811 So.2d 719, 722 (Fla. 3d DCA 2002); Institutional & Supermarket Equipment, Inc. v. C & S Refrigeration, Inc., 609 So.2d 66, 68 (Fla.......
-
Mark-It Place Foods, Inc. v. New Plan Excel Realty Trust, Inc., 2004 Ohio 411 (Ohio App. 1/26/2004)
...other goods sold by a "grocer" which was defined as a dealer in staple food stuffs and household supplies. Winn-Dixie Stores, Inc. V. 99 Cent-Stuff (Fla.App. 2002), 811 So.2d 719, 722. The Court noted that today, groceries include more than just food. These cases all appear to support the t......
-
Winn–Dixie Stores, Inc. v. Big Lots Stores, Inc.
...the phrase “staple or fancy groceries” is ambiguous, I distinguished this matter from Winn–Dixie Stores, Inc. v. 99 Cent Stuff–Trail Plaza, LLC, 811 So.2d 719 (Fla. 3d DCA 2002) [hereinafter 99 Cent ]. In 99 Cent, Winn–Dixie brought an action against one of its landlords to enforce the groc......