86 S.W. 990 (Ky.App. 1905), Com. v. Lee

CourtCourt of Appeals of Kentucky
Writing for the CourtBARKER, J.
Citation86 S.W. 990,120 Ky. 433
Date02 May 1905
Docket Number.
PartiesCOMMONWEALTH, to Use of LEE, v. LEE.

Page 990

86 S.W. 990 (Ky.App. 1905)

120 Ky. 433




Court of Appeals of Kentucky.

May 2, 1905

Appeal from Circuit Court, Marshall County.

"To be officially reported."

Action by the commonwealth for the use of Thomas R. Lee, against W. P. Lee, on his official bond as judge of the Marshall county court, to recover damages for his acceptance of Mary Lee as surety on the bond of T. D. Brown, guardian of T. R. Lee. From a judgment in favor of defendant, plaintiff appeals. Reversed.

Hendrick & Miller, for appellant.

R. O. Hester, for appellee.


This is an action by the commonwealth of Kentucky, for the use of Thomas R. Lee, against the appellee, W. P. Lee, on his official bond as judge of Marshall county court, to recover damages alleged to have been sustained by his accepting Mary Lee as surety on the bond of T. D. Brown as guardian of T. R. Lee, when he knew she was insolvent.

The following sections of the Kentucky Statutes of 1903 are necessary to a discussion of the questions raised by the record before us:

"Sec. 2017. No guardian except a testamentary one for nurture and education, can act until he has been appointed by the proper county court, and given covenant to the commonwealth, with good surety, approved by the court, faithfully to discharge the trust of guardian. The bond shall be carefully kept by the county court clerk in a book to be provided for that purpose."

"Sec. 2018. If the court fails to take such covenant, or accept such person or persons as surety as do not satisfy it of their sufficiency, the judge so in default and his sureties shall be jointly and severally liable to the ward for any damage he may sustain thereby."

"Sec. 2034. No disbursements shall be allowed the guardian for the maintenance and education of the ward beyond the income of the estate, except in the following cases, unless authorized by the deed or will under which the estate is derived: (1) When the ward is of such tender years or infirm health that he cannot be bound out as an apprentice, or no suitable person will take him as such. (2) When it is best for the ward that the principal of his personal estate shall be applied for his board and tuition, and the court, upon settlement of the accounts, shall deem such application to have been judicious and properly made. But neither the ward nor his real estate shall be liable for any such disbursement.

"Sec. 2035. If, from any source, a balance is owing by a guardian at the end of any year, counting from the time of his appointment, which ought to have been invested or loaned out for the benefit of the ward in reasonable time, but which remains in the hands of the guardian, he shall be charged with interest from the end of the year in

Page 991

which such balance arose; and thereafter he shall be charged with interest upon interest, in biennial rests, and the guardian shall account to his ward for whatever profit or rate of interest he receives from loans or investments of the trust funds."

J. F. Lee, the father of T. R. Lee, died intestate in Marshall county, Ky. in 1877, leaving a widow, Mary Lee, and five children. His estate consisted of land worth $3,000, and an insurance policy on his life for $5,000, together with other personalty, which realized at sale over $3,000. After the death of J. F. Lee, his son-in-law, T. D. Brown, was appointed and qualified as administrator of his estate, and collected the insurance policy, sold and converted into cash sufficient other personalty to realize the sum of $3,011.53, and out of this sum paid off debts amounting in round numbers to $1,800. This left in his hands a balance of $6,211.53, one-third of which was distributed to the widow, and the remainder divided equally among the five children. Afterwards, on the 7th day of October, 1878, appellee, as judge of the Marshall county court, appointed T. D. Brown guardian of T. R. Lee, then an infant about two years old, and accepted as surety on his bond Mrs. Mary Lee, the mother of the infant. Upon qualifying as guardian, Brown charged himself with the infant's distributable share of his father's estate; thereby becoming, in law, responsible for it in this fiducial capacity. He remained guardian for his infant brother-in-law, without having executed a new bond, throughout the infancy of the latter. Upon the ward's arriving at lawful age, this action was instituted against appellee upon his official bond; the petition stating substantially the...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT