Martin v. Fidelity National Title Insurance Co., 080513 FED5, 13-30013
|Opinion Judge:||PER CURIAM:|
|Party Name:||LLOYD RAYMOND MARTIN, III; NICOLE EASTERWOOD MARTIN, Plaintiffs-Appellants v. FIDELITY NATIONAL TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant-Appellee|
|Judge Panel:||Before KING, CLEMENT, and HIGGINSON, Circuit Judges.|
|Case Date:||August 05, 2013|
|Court:||United States Courts of Appeals, Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit|
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana USDC No. 2:09-CV-4195
Plaintiffs-Appellants Lloyd and Nicole Martin filed suit against Defendant-Appellant Fidelity National Title Insurance Co., asserting claims for breach of title insurance policy and bad faith. The district court granted Fidelity's motion for summary judgment on the Martins' claims, and the Martins appealed. For the following reasons, we AFFIRM the district court's judgment.
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Central to this case is the chain of title to property owned by Lloyd and Nicole Martin (the "Martins") in St. Tammany Parish, Louisiana. The property originally appears to have been owned by Herbert Nill. It then was acquired by Herbert Nill's son, William C. Nill, in 1959, and redeemed by him from a tax sale in 1988. On February 14, 2001, Hickory Glade, Inc. ("Hickory Glade"), despite holding no recorded interest, conveyed its interest in the property by quitclaim deed to William Magee, one of Hickory Glade's directors and officers. Magee proceeded to file a petition for declaratory judgment in Louisiana state court against Herbert and William C. Nill, their spouses, heirs, and assigns (the "Nills") on April 9, 2002, seeking recognition of ownership of the property. Because the attorney appointed by the state court to represent the Nills appears never to have contacted them, the Nills did not respond to Magee's suit. As a result, the state court entered a default judgment declaring Magee the owner of the property.
Magee then donated part of the property to the Great Commission Foundation of Campus Crusade for Christ, Inc. ("Great Commission Foundation"). Shortly thereafter, Magee and the Great Commission Foundation sold the property to Buddy Coate Homes, LLC ("Buddy Coate"). On August 16, 2005, Buddy Coate filed a petition for declaratory judgment in state court to quiet title against the Nills. Perhaps not coincidentally, Magee represented Buddy Coate in this action. As before, a default judgment was entered against the Nills.
Buddy Coate then sold the property to Mark and Kristen Graziani. The Grazianis, in turn, sold the property to the Martins. However, when the Martins tried to sell the property to Adam and India Sachitano, the Sachitanos' closing agent identified a problem with the Martins' title. After the attempted sale to the Sachitanos failed, the Martins filed a claim with their title insurance provider, Fidelity National Title Insurance Co. ("Fidelity"). The claim alleged a defect in title created by Magee's acquisition of the property from Hickory Glade. Fidelity proceeded to conduct an investigation and identified two surviving descendants of William C. Nill—Pamela Cummings and Paula Windham. A third descendant, William P. Nill, previously had died intestate without a spouse or dependants. Cummings and Windham executed quitclaim deeds in the Martins' favor for the sum of $16, 000. They also executed Affidavits of Death, Domicile and Heirship as to their father, William C. Nill, and their brother, William P. Nill.
Fidelity presented the quitclaim deeds to the Martins, who refused to accept them in satisfaction of Fidelity's obligation under the title insurance policy. Fidelity nevertheless recorded the deeds in St. Tammany Parish's conveyance records. Later, Fidelity also obtained quitclaim deeds and affidavits from other heirs of Herbert Nill for $16, 500.
On June 29, 2009, the Martins filed suit against Fidelity in district court for alleged breach of the title insurance policy and bad faith. Fidelity filed a third-party complaint in subrogration against the Martins' predecessors-in-title, including, inter alia, Magee, Buddy Coate, and the Grazianis. Magee and Buddy Coate moved for summary judgment on Fidelity's claims, which the district court denied on September 26, 2011. Then, on May 8, 2012, Fidelity filed motions for summary judgment against the Martins, Magee, and Buddy Coate. The district court granted Fidelity's motions on September 11. The court found that Fidelity had the right under the title insurance policy to attempt to cure the defect in the Martins' title, and did so by procuring quitclaim deeds from William C. Nill's only heirs. Accordingly, the court...
To continue readingFREE SIGN UP