Allen v. Town of Hampton

Decision Date30 September 1966
Citation222 A.2d 833,107 N.H. 377
PartiesFrancis E. ALLEN et al. v. TOWN OF HAMPTON.
CourtNew Hampshire Supreme Court

Shute & Engel and Francis J. Frasier, Exeter, for plaintiffs.

Perkins, Holland & Donovan, and William H. M. Beckett, Exeter, for defendant.

WHEELER, Justice.

Actions in case brought by Francis E. Allen and five other property owners against the town of Hampton, a municipal corporation, alleging that the defendant town was negligent in failing to properly maintain the municipal drainage system, as a result of which the plaintiffs' suffered extensive water damage to their real estate and personal belongings.

The defendant filed a motion to dismiss in each case alleging that no cause of action was stated and that the defendant town cannot be liable because of its sovereign immunity. These motions were denied and all questions of law raised by the defendant's exceptions to the ruling of the Court were reserved and transferred by Grant, J.

It does not appear from the record before us whether the municipal drainage system was a public, governmental undertaking on the part of the defendant or one which was performed by it in its private, corporate Capacity. In either event, however, it would be liable in this case on the count alleging negligence if the excessive water causing the damage resulted from defendant's negligence. A municipality acts in a governmental capacity in the construction and maintenance of its highways and is ordinarily immune from liability for injuries caused by the negligent performance of such work. Fournier v. City of Berlin, 92 N.H. 142, 144, 26 A.2d 366, 140 A.L.R. 1054. An exception to this immunity exists, however, if the municipality, by the use of land which it holds only for public governmental purposes, such as a highway, negligently invades an adjoining owner's property rights. O'Brien v. Rockingham County, 80 N.H. 522, 526, 120 A. 254. 'For negligence in highway construction and maintenance within their borders municipalities are liable for resulting damage to neighboring property.' Gilman v. Concord, 89 N.H. 182, 185, 195 A. 672, 674. The damages paid to or the release given by the owner of land when a public highway is laid out includes 'damages arising from its proper construction and maintenance, but not from negligent or unreasonable construction and maintenance.' Hood v. City of Nashua, 91 N.H. 98, 101, 13 A.2d 726, 728; Wadleigh v. City of Manchester, ...

To continue reading

Request your trial
10 cases
  • Merrill v. City of Manchester
    • United States
    • New Hampshire Supreme Court
    • November 29, 1974
    ...that municipal corporations are now and have been for many years liable in torts for their proprietary activities. Allen v. Hampton, 107 N.H. 377, 222 A.2d 833 (1966). When so acting in their corporate capacity, their liability for torts is tested by the same principles applied to private c......
  • Tarbell Adm'r, Inc. v. City of Concord
    • United States
    • New Hampshire Supreme Court
    • September 12, 2008
    ...facilities ... is precisely the type of" discretionary decision entitled to immunity (emphasis added)), with Allen v. Hampton, 107 N.H. 377, 378, 222 A.2d 833 (1966) (holding that a municipality is not entitled to immunity for its negligence in constructing and maintaining a highway). In ot......
  • Tarbell Adm'R, Inc. v. City of Concord
    • United States
    • New Hampshire Supreme Court
    • September 12, 2008
    ...facilities ... is precisely the type of" discretionary decision entitled to immunity (emphasis added)), with Allen v. Hampton, 107 N.H. 377, 378, 222 A.2d 833 (1966) (holding that a municipality is not entitled to immunity for its negligence in constructing and maintaining a highway). In ot......
  • Murray v. Boston & M.R.R.
    • United States
    • New Hampshire Supreme Court
    • November 30, 1966
    ... ... In Chapman v. Town of Lee, 80 N.H. 484, 119 A. 440, upon which they rely, the Court, in setting aside a verdict, held ... ...
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT