Alonzo v. John

CourtTexas Court of Appeals
Writing for the CourtJerry Zimmerer, Justice
CitationAlonzo v. John, 647 S.W.3d 764 (Tex. App. 2022)
Decision Date29 March 2022
Docket Number14-20-00148-CV
Parties Roberto ALONZO and New Prime, Inc., Appellants v. Christine JOHN and Christopher Lewis, Appellees

Jessica Z. Barger, Natasha Taylor, Brittany Greger, Houston, Michael Walter Magee, for Appellant.

Jim S. Hart, Steven Joseph Kherkher, Kevin Haynes, Margot Trevino, Houston, Sharon McCally, Andrew Bender, Houston, for Appellee.

Panel consists of Justices Wise, Bourliot, and Zimmerer

Jerry Zimmerer, Justice

Appellant Roberto Alonzo, while in the course and scope of employment for appellant New Prime, Inc., was driving a tractor-trailer on Interstate 45 when he rear-ended a sedan containing appellees Christine John and Christopher Lewis. Appellants conceded liability, and a jury awarded appellees more than $12 million in damages for physical pain and mental anguish. Appellants challenge the trial court's judgment in twelve issues, complaining about errors during voir dire and closing argument, the admission of evidence, and the sufficiency of the evidence.1 We affirm.

I. SUFFICIENCY OF THE EVIDENCE

We address appellants’ complaints about the sufficiency of the evidence to support the damages awards before their other issues. See, e.g., Bradleys’ Elec., Inc. v. Cigna Lloyds Ins. Co. , 995 S.W.2d 675, 677 (Tex. 1999). In their sixth through eleventh issues, appellants contend that the evidence is legally and factually insufficient to support the jury's damages findings.2

A. Procedural Background

Appellants stipulated to liability. The first two jury questions asked what sum of money would fairly and reasonably compensate each plaintiff for their injuries. The question for John listed four potential elements of damages: past physical pain, future physical pain, past mental anguish, and future mental anguish. The question for Lewis asked only about past physical pain and past mental anguish. The jury answered unanimously as follows:

Question 1 – Christine John Question 2 – Christopher Lewis
Past physical pain: $2,500,000 Past physical pain: $150,000
Future physical pain: $4,700,000 Past mental anguish: $300,000
Past mental anguish: $1,700,000
Future mental anguish: $3,100,000

The charge instructed the jury to consider only the elements of damages listed above, to not award any sum of money on any element if the jury had otherwise awarded a sum of money for the same loss under another element, and to not compensate the plaintiffs twice for the same loss.

The trial court signed a final judgment consistent with the jury's verdict. Appellants’ motions for new trial and judgment notwithstanding the verdict were overruled by operation of law.

B. Standards of Review for Sufficiency Challenges

For a legal sufficiency challenge, we review the record in the light most favorable to the jury's verdict, crediting favorable evidence if a reasonable fact-finder could and disregarding contrary evidence unless a reasonable fact-finder could not. See City of Keller v. Wilson , 168 S.W.3d 802, 807 (Tex. 2005). We indulge every reasonable inference in support of the verdict. Id. at 822. We may not substitute our opinions on credibility for those of the fact-finder. See id. at 816–17, 822. The ultimate test for legal sufficiency is whether the evidence at trial would enable reasonable and fair-minded people to reach the verdict under review. Id. at 827.

In a factual sufficiency review, we will set aside the verdict and remand for a new trial if we conclude that the verdict is so against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence as to be manifestly unjust. Golden Eagle Archery, Inc. v. Jackson , 116 S.W.3d 757, 761 (Tex. 2003) (citing In re King's Estate , 150 Tex. 662, 244 S.W.2d 660, 661 (1951) ). We will weigh the evidence supporting the verdict along with evidence contrary to the verdict. See id. at 761–62. However, the fact-finder remains the sole judge of the credibility of witnesses and the weight to be given their testimony. Id. at 761. We must defer to the fact-finder's determinations so long as those determinations are reasonable. See Sw. Bell Tel. Co. v. Garza , 164 S.W.3d 607, 625 (Tex. 2004). We may not merely substitute our judgment for that of the fact-finder. Golden Eagle Archery , 116 S.W.3d at 761. The amount of evidence necessary to affirm the judgment is far less than the amount necessary to reverse. Harris Cnty. v. Coats , 607 S.W.3d 359, 381 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2020, no pet.).

C. General Principles for Pain and Mental Anguish Damages

Under Texas law, "whether to award damages and how much is uniquely within the factfinder's discretion."

Golden Eagle Archery , 116 S.W.3d at 772. The jury has broad discretion to award damages within the range of the evidence presented at trial. Critical Path Res., Inc. v. Cuevas , 561 S.W.3d 523, 561 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2018, pet. granted, judgm't vacated w.r.m.). Damages associated with physical injuries are "not subject to precise mathematical calculation" because physical pain and mental anguish are inherently subjective. Richards v. Tebbe , No. 14-13-00413-CV, 2014 WL 2936425, at *5 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] June 26, 2014, no pet.) (mem. op.) (quoting Weidner v. Sanchez , 14 S.W.3d 353, 372 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2000, no pet.) ); see also PNS Stores, Inc. v. Munguia , 484 S.W.3d 503, 518 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2016, no pet.) ("The process of awarding damages for amorphous, discretionary injuries such as physical pain and mental anguish is inherently difficult because the alleged injury is a subjective, unliquidated, nonpecuniary loss.").

"Pain and suffering may be inferred or presumed as a consequence of severe injuries." Id. at 574. Although mental anguish cannot be inferred from any physical injury, it may be inferred as a natural consequence of severe physical injury. See Ontiveroas v. Lozano , No. 14-05-00294-CV, 2006 WL 1140374, at *2 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] Apr. 27, 2006, no pet.) (mem. op.) ; see also Parkway Co. v. Woodruff , 901 S.W.2d 434, 442, 445 (Tex. 1995) (noting that a threat to one's physical safety may justify an inference of mental anguish, and historically, if there was physical injury resulting from physical impact, "recovery of mental anguish damages was not hard to justify"). "Although the fact of a physical injury does not alone support an award for mental anguish damages, we can consider the traumatic nature of an injury as a factor in deciding whether the award is supported by the evidence." Katy Springs & Mfg., Inc. v. Favalora , 476 S.W.3d 579, 595 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2015, pet. denied).

Mental anguish is only compensable if it causes a ‘substantial disruption in daily routine or a high degree of mental pain and distress.’ Hancock v. Variyam , 400 S.W.3d 59, 68 (Tex. 2013). Thus, mental anguish damages cannot be awarded without either (1) direct evidence of the nature, duration, or severity of the plaintiff's anguish, thus establishing a substantial disruption in the plaintiff's daily routine; or (2) other evidence of a high degree of mental pain and distress that is more than mere worry, anxiety, vexation, embarrassment, or anger. Saenz v. Fidelity & Guar. Ins. Underwriters , 925 S.W.2d 607, 614 (Tex. 1996). The absence of direct evidence justifies close scrutiny of other evidence of mental anguish damages. Favalora , 476 S.W.3d at 594 (citing Parkway , 901 S.W.2d at 444 ).

Damages for future physical pain are recoverable if a jury could reasonably infer that the plaintiff will feel physical pain in the future. PNS Stores , 484 S.W.3d at 517. Similarly, damages for future mental anguish are recoverable if there is a reasonable probability that the plaintiff will suffer compensable mental anguish in the future. Id.

D. Evidence and Analysis of Christine John's Past and Future Physical Pain

In appellants’ seventh and eighth issues, they contend that the evidence is legally and factually insufficient to support the jury's damages award to John for past and future physical pain, respectively $2.5 million and $4.7 million. Appellants concede that John suffered physical pain after the accident and still had pain at the time of trial. But appellants contend that the jury's awards are excessive, and appellants ask this court to reverse and remand for a new trial or suggest a remittitur. Accordingly, we address their issues as a factual-sufficiency challenge. See Critical Path , 561 S.W.3d at 561 ("When a party argues on appeal that the damages awarded by the jury are excessive we review the evidence for factual sufficiency.").

John was twenty-four years old in September 2012. She was driving a Nissan Sentra on Interstate 45 when appellants’ tractor-trailer rear-ended her and pushed her into another vehicle. She hit her head during the accident and was taken to a hospital where she complained of head and neck pain. An MRI showed bulging and herniated discs in her spine. Her treating neurosurgeon testified that these conditions caused pain and that a herniated disc "doesn't go back in" and "doesn't go back to normal," which may cause lingering pain over time.

Within two weeks of the accident, she also started to feel sharp pain on the left side of her face that radiated from her ear to her lower jaw. She reported to one of her treating neurologists that the pain was a "10 out of 10," or the worst possible pain. It is a sharp and severe pain that occurs in bursts throughout the day. It can be triggered by touching her face, a cool temperature, cold air hitting her face, brushing her teeth, or talking, among other things. Multiple doctors—neurologists and neurosurgeons—diagnosed John with an uncommon condition known as "trigeminal neuralgia," meaning a damaged nerve in her face. The doctors opined that facial trauma from the accident caused the nerve damage.

The doctors described trigeminal neuralgia as a "very painful" syndrome: "probably the most excruciating pain you can imagine and—and that's kind of...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex
4 cases
  • Gregory v. Chohan
    • United States
    • Texas Supreme Court
    • June 16, 2023
    ...Show and Rodeo, Inc. v. Hamrick , 125 S.W.3d 555, 581 n.24 (Tex. App.—Austin 2003, no pet.), with Alonzo v. John , 647 S.W.3d 764, 778–79 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2022, pet. filed) (expressing skepticism about using the ratio of economic and noneconomic damages and upholding an award......
  • Yung-Kai Lu v. NG
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Northern District of Texas
    • May 23, 2023
    ... ... a person are insufficient evidence on which to base mental ... anguish damages.” Alonzo v. John, 647 S.W.3d ... 764, 772 (Tex. App.-Houston [14th Dist.] 2022, pet. filed) ... (citing Serv. Corp. Int'l v. Guerra, 348 S.W.3d ... ...
  • Kitchens v. State
    • United States
    • Texas Court of Appeals
    • March 28, 2024
    ...impact their deliberations. It was not an 'appeal to racial prejudice in language clear and strong,' but rather an appeal to impartiality." Id. [3] The motion requesting a hearing titled, "Motion Requesting a Hearing on Motion for New Trial Finding of Guilt," but the substance of the motion......
  • Alonzo v. John
    • United States
    • Texas Supreme Court
    • May 10, 2024
    ...and gender bias. The motion was overruled by operation of law, and the court of appeals affirmed the judgment. 647 S.W.3d 764, 770-71 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2022). Although a new trial is "strong medicine," the remedy is warranted on this record. See In re Rudolph Auto., LLC, 674 S......