American Water Development, Inc. v. City of Alamosa, s. 92SA141
| Citation | 874 P.2d 352 |
| Decision Date | 09 May 1994 |
| Docket Number | Nos. 92SA141,92SA263,s. 92SA141 |
| Parties | AMERICAN WATER DEVELOPMENT, INC., a Colorado corporation, Applicant-Appellant, v. CITY OF ALAMOSA; County of Alamosa; Alexander Ranch; Darell Keith Alexander; Richard Angell; Baca Grande Water & Sanitation District; Fred Bauder; Harold L. Bennett; Richard Blumenhein; Bonanza Road Water Users, Owners and Objectors; Lena C. Chiles; Floyd D. Chiles; Terry R. Chiles; Cyril Clayton; Dave Collins; David P. Collins; Barbara J. Collins; Colorado Division of Wildlife; Colorado Water Conservation Board; Columbine Telephone Company; Conejos Water Conservancy District; Concerned Citizens of Crestone, Colorado and Vicinity; Richard E. Conour; Elizabeth A. Conour; Cotton Creek Ranch; Town of Crestone; Fred J. Davie; Douglas M. Davie; Michael R. Dennet; Tom Enos; Dennis L. Felmlee; Oliver Powell Roemer, III, Successor Trustee Under the Trusts Under the Will of Avis Neal Roemer; First Pegasus Corporation; Freel Ranch; Eugene W. Freel; Beverly Freel; Harold L. Freel; Terry Lee Freel; Fullenwider Ranch, Inc.; Ernest Lamar Goodwin; Haidakhandi Universal Ashram; Ernest T. Harer; Grace Harer; Richard W. Hanby; Pamyla Hill; D. Robin Hood; Town of Hooper; J. Richard Johnston; Mary A. Johnston; L.D. Ranch; Town of LaJara; Henry R. Lamm; Mable A. Lamm; John N. Lawrence; KSD, Ltd.; Lazy KV Estates Homeowners Association, Inc.; Timothy N. Lovato; Lori S. Lovato; Marold Ranches; R.G. Marold; Barbara Mertian; A & M Farms; Pamela Bertin; Phillip Briscoe; Debra Briscoe; Eddie Clayton; Wayne C. Davis; Maggi Dessain; Margarita Diaz; Melvin E. Getz; Julie Goodnight; Greg Gosar; Margaret N. Herzfield; Maggie Houston-Smith; Pamela L. Lunt; Phil Martinez; Messick Farms; Richard A. Messick; Douglas G. Messick; Richard L. Messick; Sandra J. Murray; Curtis W. Nelson; Anne Silver Philleo; Robert S. Philleo; Marlene L. Pruitt; Robert A. Ress; Toni G. Romero; Marianne Sandstrom; Robert W. Simpson; W.E. Sisemote; C. Kimberly Snider; Francis E. Snider; M. Catherine Snider; Shella Snider; Katherine Steichen; Ha |
| Court | Supreme Court of Colorado |
Gale A. Norton, Atty. Gen., Raymond T. Slaughter, Chief Deputy Atty. Gen., Timothy M. Tymkovich, Sol. Gen., Patricia S. Bangert, Deputy Atty. Gen., Jennifer L. Gimbel, First Asst. Atty. Gen., Christine A. Klein, Bradley W. Cameron, Thomas W. Gibb, Asst. Attys. Gen., Natural Resources Section, Denver, for State of CO, CO Div. of Wildlife, CO Water Conservation Bd., and State and Div. Engineers for Water Div. 3.
Bruce McMillen, Saguache, for Richard Blumenhein, Bonanza Road Water Users, Owners and Objectors, David P. Collins, Barbara J. Collins, Ernest Lamar Goodwin, Lazy KV Estates Homeowners Ass'n, Inc., Marold Ranches, R.G. Marold, Loren Santisteven, Julie Santisteven, and Villa Grove Area Water Users, Owners and Opposers.
Janet Reno, U.S. Atty. Gen., Robert L. Klarquist, Atty., Appellate Section, U.S. Dept. of Justice, Environment and Natural Resources Div., Washington, DC, Michael J. Norton, U.S. Atty., James J. Dubois, Atty., General Litigation Section, U.S. Dept. of Justice, Environment and Natural Resources Div., Denver, for U.S.
Fred Bauder, pro se.
Moses, Wittemyer, Harrison and Woodruff, P.C., David L. Harrison, Raphael J. Moses, Steven P. Jeffers, Boulder, for Conejos Water Conservancy Dist., Oliver Powell Roemer, III, Successor Trustee under the trusts under the will of Avis Neal Roemer, and Howard R. Platz, Oasis Land and Cattle Corp.
No appearance for objectors-appellees Alexander Ranch, Darell Keith Alexander, Richard Angell, Baca Grande Water & Sanitation Dist., Harold L. Bennett, Lena C. Chiles, Floyd D. Chiles, Terry R. Chiles, Cyril Clayton, Dave Collins, Columbine Telephone Co., Concerned Citizens of Crestone, CO and Vicinity, Richard E. Conour, Elizabeth A. Conour, Cotton Creek Ranch, Fred J. Davie, Douglas M. Davie, Michael R. Dennet, Tom Enos, Dennis L. Felmlee, First Pegasus Corp., Freel Ranch, Eugene W. Freel, Beverly Freel, Harold L. Freel, Terry Lee Freel, Fullenwider Ranch, Inc., Haidakhandi Universal Ashram, Ernest T. Harer, Grace Harer, Richard W. Hanby, Pamyla Hill, D. Robin Hood, Town of Hooper, J. Richard Johnston, Mary A. Johnston, L.D. Ranch, Henry R. Lamm, Mable A. Lamm, John N. Lawrence, KSD, Ltd., Timothy N. Lovato, Lori S. Lovato, Barbara Mertian, A & M Farms, Pamela Bertin, Phillip Briscoe, Debra Briscoe, Eddie Clayton, Wayne C. Davis, Maggi Dessain, Margarita Diaz, Melvin E. Getz, Julie Goodnight, Greg Gosar, Margaret N. Herzfield, Maggie Houston-Smith, Pamela L. Lunt, Phil Martinez, Messick Farms, Richard A. Messick, Douglas G. Messick, Richard L. Messick, Sandra J. Murray, Curtis W. Nelson, Gayle Nichols, Anne Silver Philleo, Robert S. Philleo, Marlene L. Pruitt, Robert A. Ress, Toni G. Romero, Marianne Sandstrom, Robert W. Simpson, W.E. Sisemote, C. Kimberly Snider, Francis E. Snider, M. Catherine Snider, Shella Snider, Katherine Steichen, Harvey V. Sullivan, Liz Washburn, John R. Wright, George Whitten, Jr., Donald E. Whitten, Karen Whitten, Betty L. Worley, Town of Moffat, Jimmy R. Moore, Mary Moore, Morfitt Bros. Farm, Inc., Darrel Neese, Harold Neese, Gayle A. Nichols, Edward R. Oliver, Otaka Intern., Robert A. Owens, Edwin Pace, Rio Grande County Farm Bureau, Rito Alto and San Luis Ranches, Inc., Rito Alto Ranch, Inc., Rito Alto Ranchers, Arthur L. Rivale, Ileen J. Rivale, Rocky Mountain Bison, Inc., Thomas C. Sanderson, Town of Saguache, Neil F. Seitz, Valley View Hot Springs, Martin T. Shellabarger, Patricia Shellabarger, Kenneth L. Skoglund, Mary F. Skoglund, Spiritual Life Institute of America, Inc., David G. Stagner, Travelers Ins. Co., Thomas F. Trim, Annabelle R. Trim, Wagner Ranch, Ltd., John H. Wagner, Weiss Ranches, Inc., A.L. Wood, John M. Woodard, Erwin Young, and Lynne Young.
No appearance for objector-respondent Gayle Nichols.
NOTE--Some parts of this form are wider than one screen. To view
material that exceeds the width of this screen, use the right arrow
key. To return to the original screen, use the left arrow key.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. Procedural History and Issues Presented ................................... 357
II. Dismissal of the Land Grant Claims ........................................ 360
A. Factual Background 360
B. The Spanish and Mexican Land Grant Claim 362
C. The Claim Under the Act of June 21, 1860 365
III. Challenges to the Determination that Water Sought to be Withdrawn is 366
Tributary
A. Whether the Trial Court Properly Determined the Effect of AWDI's 367
Proposed Pumping on Surface Streams
B. Whether the Trial Court Properly Determined the Nature of the 368
Unconfined Aquifer and the Effect of AWDI's Proposed Pumping on that
Aquifer
1. Challenge to Natural Stream Legislation as Special Legislation 370
2. Inclusion of Unconfined Aquifer in Definition of Natural Stream
...To continue reading
Request your trial
-
City of Thornton v. Bijou Irr. Co.
...but derives from a separate legislatively-prescribed system based on ownership of the overlying lands. American Water Dev., Inc. v. City of Alamosa, 874 P.2d 352, 369 (Colo.), cert. den., 513 U.S. 1015, 115 S.Ct. 575, 130 L.Ed.2d 491 (1994). Because the 1953 decree essentially found no hydr......
-
In the Matter of Application for Water Rights of Park County Sportsmen's Ranch, LLP, Case No. 01SA412 (CO 2/14/2005)
...1987), Alamosa-La Jara Water Protection Ass'n v. Gould, 674 P.2d 914, 920 (Colo. 1983), and American Water Development, Inc. v. City of Alamosa, 874 P.2d 352, 368 (Colo. 1994)(hereinafter AWDI). In Kuiper, we merely observed that well-pumping may result in some reduction in evapotranspirati......
-
Sierra Club v. Dept. of Transp. of State
...could meet the statutory criteria in the future and receive the same benefits provided by the statute); Am, Water Dev., Inc. v. City of Alamosa, 874 P.2d 352 (Colo.1994) (determining that Colorado's natural surface stream legislation was not special legislation despite only applying to two ......
-
City of Aurora v. Colorado State Engineer
...Alamosa-La Jara Water Users Protection Ass'n v. Gould, 674 P.2d 914, 920 (Colo.1983), and American Water Development, Inc. v. City of Alamosa, 874 P.2d 352, 368 (Colo.1994) (hereinafter AWDI). In Kuiper, we merely observed that well-pumping may result in some reduction in evapotranspiration......
-
Recovery of Attorney Fees and Costs in Colorado
...Rodeo Cowboys, 832 P.2d 1099, 1102 (Colo.App. 1992). See also American Water Dev., Inc. v. Rio Grande Water Conservation Dist., 874 P.2d 352 (Colo. 1994)[ability of trial court to condition grant of voluntary dismissal on payment of costs and fees not limited by provisions of CRS § 13-17-10......
-
Recovering Actual Damages Under Colorado's Construction Defect Action Reform Act-part Ii
...expenses may do "double duty" as "response costs" and "defense costs" under CERCLA). 36. Compare Am. Water Dev., Inc. v. City of Alamosa, 874 P.2d 352, 389 (Colo. 1994) (expert witness costs properly include all costs for the expert's opinion formulation and testimonial preparation), In re ......
-
The Bill of Costs
...supra, note 7. 25. See Ballow v. PHICO Insurance Co., 878 P.2d 672, 684 (Colo. 1994); American Water Development, Inc. v. City of Alamosa, 874 P.2d 352, 388-390 (Colo.); but see Perkins v. Flatiron Structures Co., 849 P.2d 832 (Colo.App. 1992) (where it was unclear from the bills of the exp......
-
Disciplinary Opinion
...is "void ab initio" because it was "made by the Florida Bar counsel (and not by a referee)." See Am. Water Dev., Inc. v. City of Alamosa, 874 P.2d 352, 376 (Colo. 1994) ("Adoption of a prevailing party’s proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law is not necessarily improper."); Elec. ......