Asbury v. Frisz

Decision Date25 May 1897
Docket Number18,195
Citation47 N.E. 328,148 Ind. 513
PartiesAsbury v. Frisz
CourtIndiana Supreme Court

Rehearing Denied October 12, 1897.

From the Vigo Circuit Court.

Reversed.

Josiah T. Walker, for appellant.

S. C Stimson, R. B. Stimson and H. A. Condit, for appellee.

OPINION

Howard, J.

This was an action to annul a judgment. The court sustained a demurrer to the complaint, and this is the only ruling assigned as error.

It is alleged in the complaint that, on April 17, 1895, the appellee filed his verified petition in the court below, stating therein that this appellant, "Jerome Asbury, is a resident of Vigo county, State of Indiana, and that he is of unsound mind and incapable of managing his own estate, and is now temporarily in the insane hospital at Indianapolis, Indiana, and that said Jerome Asbury draws a pension from the United States government; that it is necessary to have letters of guardianship and a copy thereof enclosed to and filed in the pension office in order to properly make out his pension voucher and draw said pension." The complaint asked that appellant be declared of unsound mind and incapable of managing his own estate, and that the appellee be appointed his guardian. May 6, 1895, was fixed as the date when the appellant should appear and answer to the complaint. On May 9, being the 4th day of the May term, both parties were defaulted, and the cause was dismissed at the costs of appellee, judgment being rendered against him. Said May term ended July 13, 1895; and it is alleged in the complaint to annul, that "The records of said court do not show that any steps were taken, or any proceedings had in said cause in said court after said cause was dismissed and judgment rendered against the petitioner therein, on the 9th day of May, 1895, until the 28th day of September, 1895, the same being the twenty-fourth judicial day of the September term of said court, at which time said cause was, without notice of any kind or character to this plaintiff, again placed upon the probate docket of said court. There was no written motion or complaint filed in said court on the 28th day of September, 1895, nor at any other time, asking that the default and judgment taken against the plaintiff therein on May 9, 1895, be set aside, or asking that said cause be reinstated for trial upon the docket of said court, and the records of said court do not show the filing of any such motion or complaint; that said court, on said 28th day of September, 1895, assumed jurisdiction of and in said cause, and, on its own motion without notice to this plaintiff, reinstated it on the docket of said court; that after said cause of action was dismissed, this plaintiff gave it no further attention, and at no time thereafter was this plaintiff, by summons or any other means, notified that there would be any further proceedings of any kind or character had in said cause. The records of said court do not show that plaintiff had any notice of the pendency of said action at any time after said dismissal thereof, May 9, 1895, neither were there any official returns made in or to said court showing that this plaintiff had in any way been served with such process or notice, and this plaintiff never had any such notice."

The proceedings had on September 28, 1895, being the only record made in the case after that of May 9, 1895, are as follows: "No. 2740. [being the same number used in the case filed April 17, 1895]. In re Alleged Insanity of Jerome Asbury. Pet. for App. of Guardian.

"Comes now in open court -----, and files verified petition herein, showing to the court that Jerome Asbury is a resident of Vigo county, State of Indiana, and is a person of unsound mind and incapable of managing his own estate, and prays that a guardian be appointed for the said Jerome Asbury. And the cause being now at issue is submitted to the court for trial, and it appearing to the court that the said Jerome Asbury has been duly served with process ten days before the day set for trial, and comes now the prosecuting attorney and files answer herein, and it being further shown to the court that the defendant is an inmate of the Central Hospital for the Insane at Indianapolis, Indiana, and cannot be produced in court without injury to his health. And the court, after having heard the evidence and being fully advised, finds that said Jerome Asbury is a resident of Vigo county and State of Indiana, and is a person of unsound mind and incapable of managing his own estate. And the court now appoints Joseph W. Frisz guardian of said Jerome Asbury, with a bond fixed at $ 500.00." Judgment was thereupon entered, in accordance with the finding.

The only complaint ever filed in the case was that filed April 17, 1895; and it is alleged that the said complaint was never refiled in the court. The docket for the September term shows that the proceedings had on September 28, 1895, when the alleged judgment was entered, were had upon the complaint filed April 17, 1895, the return day of which is shown to have been May 6, 1895.

It is further alleged that on September 28, 1895, the appellee, for the purpose of inducing the court to proceed with the trial of the cause in the absence of this...

To continue reading

Request your trial
1 cases

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT