Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Horn
Decision Date | 16 June 1953 |
Docket Number | 7 Div. 258 |
Citation | 66 So.2d 202,37 Ala.App. 220 |
Parties | ATLANTIC COAST LINE R. CO. v. HORN. |
Court | Alabama Court of Appeals |
Graham, Bibb & Wingo, Birmingham, and Dempsey & Hardegree, Ashland, for appellant.
C. W. McKay, Ashland, for appellee.
This is an action in damages for killing plaintiff's bull by the alleged negligent operation of defendant's railway locomotive. In the court below there was a judgment in favor of the plaintiff.
The insistence is made that the complaint is subject to demurrer because it does not set out with sufficient certainty the place where the bull was killed.
In this aspect the allegation is: '* * * at a point approximately 100 yards, more or less, east of where the dirt road crosses said railroad adjacent to the home of plaintiff in Clay County, Alabama.'
This seems to be sufficient under the holding of Bugg v. Green, 215 Ala. 343, 110 So. 718.
Be this as it may, the undisputed evidence establishes that appellant's agents, who were operating the train, saw the bull on the railroad track and knew when and where it was killed. Tyson v. Winter, 225 Ala. 437, 143 So. 460; Bennett v. Bennett, 224 Ala. 335, 140 So. 378.
At the instance of the plaintiff the court gave this written charge:
'3. The Court charges the jury that if you find from the evidence that the view was obstructed by fog or smoke so as to limit the view of those operating defendant's train at the time the train approached when the bull was struck, as shown by the evidence, and you find further from the evidence, the train was being operated at a greater speed than it could be stopped within the view of person or persons who were on the lookout, then as a matter of law defendant would be negligent and your verdict should be in favor of the plaintiff.'
It is clear that the charge is bad. Any omission of duty or negligent conduct, to be available to the plaintiff, must be the proximate cause of the injury. Dudley v. Alabama Utilities Service Co., 225 Ala. 531, 144 So. 5; Carter v. Ne-Hi Bottling Co., 226 Ala. 324, 146 So. 821.
Appellant attempts to avoid the force and effect of the rule by insisting that we should apply the error without injury doctrine--and this because the oral charge of the court supplied the omission.
The authorities are committed to the holding that an error in a given written charge is not cured or rendered harmless by a correct statement of the law in the oral charge. Johnson v. Louisville & N. R. Co., 220 Ala. 649, 127 So. 216.
In the fairly recent case of Terry v. Nelms, 256 Ala. 291, 54 So.2d 282, the lower court gave two written charges which dealt with the doctrine of contributory...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Aggregate Limestone Co. v. Robison
...error and necessitates a reversal.--Mobile City Lines, Inc. v. Holman, 273 Ala. 371, 141 So.2d 180. See also: Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Horn, 37 Ala.App. 220, 66 So.2d 202; Johnson v. Louisville & Nashville R. Co., 220 Ala. 649, 127 So. 216; Harris v. Schmaeling, 270 Ala. 547, 120 So.2d......
-
Yarbrough v. Hovis
...the injury, are prejudicially erroneous. Mobile City Lines, Inc. v. Holman, 273 Ala. 371, 141 So.2d 180, citing Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Horn, 37 Ala.App. 220, 66 So.2d 202; Johnson v. Louisville & Nashville R. Co., 220 Ala. 649, 127 So. 216; Harris v. Schmaeling, 270 Ala. 547, 120 So.......
-
Perkins v. Reynolds Const. Co., 6 Div. 66
...harmless by a correct statement of the law in the oral charge. Smith v. State, 15 Ala.App. 662, 74 So. 755; Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Horn, 37 Ala.App. 220, 66 So.2d 202. While recognizing the above rule, however, the Alabama Supreme Court in Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Gorman, 237 A......
-
Mobile City Lines, Inc. v. Holman
...prejudicially erroneous in omitting that the alleged negligence must be the proximate cause of the injury. See Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Horn, 37 Ala.App. 220, 66 So.2d 202; Johnson v. Louisville & Nashville R. Co., 220 Ala. 649, 127 So.2d 216; Harris v. Schmaeling, 270 Ala. 547, 120 So......