Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc.
| Court | U.S. District Court — Southern District of California |
| Writing for the Court | JEFFREY T. MILLER |
| Citation | Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc., 913 F.Supp.2d 1001 (S.D. Cal. 2012) |
| Decision Date | 20 December 2012 |
| Docket Number | Case Nos. 3:11–cv–2609–JM (WMC), 3:10–cv–2671–JM (WMC). |
| Parties | Gina BALASANYAN; Nune Nalbandian, on behalf of themselves all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, v. NORDSTROM, INC., a Washington corporation; and Does 1–100, inclusive, Defendants. Gino Maraventano; and Neesha Kurji, Plaintiffs, v. Nordstrom, Inc., a Washington corporation; and Does 1–100, inclusive, Defendants. |
OPINION TEXT STARTS HERE
Darcy R. Harris, Jeff D. Neiderman, Kathryn Lee Boyd, Sherli Shamtoub, Schwarcz Rimberg Boyd and Rader LLP, Los Angeles, CA, Steven M. Barnhill, Maxim Vaynerov, Barnhill & Vaynerov LLP, Beverly Hills, CA, Matthew Archbold, David Douglas Deason, Deason & Archbold, Newport Beach, CA, for Plaintiffs.
Joshua D. Levine, Julie A. Dunne, Lara K. Strauss, Litter Mendelson, San Diego, CA, Michael G. Leggieri, Littler Mendelson, P.C., Sacramento, CA, for Defendants.
ORDER GRANTING THE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON BALASANYAN'S FAIR LABOR STANDARDS ACT CLAIM AND DENYING THE MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL OTHER CLAIMS
On October 8, 2012, Nordstrom, Inc. (“Nordstrom”) filed two motions for summary judgment against two proposed class action law suits, Case No. 3:11–cv–2609 (“ Balasanyan ”) and Case No. 3:10–cv–2671 (“ Maraventano ”) (). The Balasanyan complaint was originally filed in Los Angeles Superior Court on April 5, 2011, then removed to federal court, and later transferred to this district on November 9, 2011, 2011 WL 5520051. The Maraventano complaint was originally filed in San Diego Superior Court, North County, in October 2010 and was removed to this court in December 2010. For the reasons stated below, the motion for summary judgment is GRANTED for Balasanyan's Fair Labor Standards Act claim,1 but is DENIED for all other claims.
Nordstrom's salespeople work on commission rather than per hour. Nordstrom calculates each salesperson's commissions at the end of each period and compares their commissions with the guaranteed minimum that they would have received had they been working at an hourly rate. Maraventano Motion for Summary Judgment (“MMSJ”) at 4; Balasanyan Motion for Summary Judgment (“BMSJ”) at 3–6. If a given employee's commissions per selling hour equaled or exceeded their guaranteed minimum, Nordstrom paid commissions. MMSJ at 4–5; BMSJ at 4–5. If their commissions did not equal or exceed the guaranteed minimum, Nordstrom paid the employee's commission plus the amount necessary to bring them to the guaranteed minimum draw rate 2 for all selling time. MMSJ at 4–5; BMSJ at 4–5. Selling time includes 30 minutes of daily stocking assignments as well as up to 40 minutes of pre-opening and post-closing time. 3 MMSJ at 4–5; BMSJ at 4–5. Nordstrom separately paid employees an hourly rate for all non-sell time, which consists of stock assignments in excess of 30 minutes and pre-opening and post-closing assignments in excess of 40 minutes.4 MMSJ at 6; BMSJ at 5–6. According to Nordstrom, the average hourly salary received ranged from $10.85 to $73.39 for Balasanyan, $10.85 to $43.17 for Nalbandian, $10.85 to $35.38 for Maraventano, and $11.31 to $17.02 for Kurji. BMSJ at 9; MMSJ at 22.
The named Balasanyan Plaintiffs are both salespeople at Nordstrom stores in Los Angeles County. Balasanyan Second Amended Complaint (“BSAC”) ¶¶ 5, 6. Plaintiffs and members of the proposed Balasanyan class are paid on commission based on net sales. The Balasanyan complaint alleges that Nordstrom has underpaid its salespeople across the country by only compensating them for time spent on stocking assignments, pre-opening, and post-closing periods through commissions earned, which they believe can only be used to compensate for commission producing activities. Id. ¶¶ 13, 14. The non-commission producing activities include performing marketing activities such as contacting customers to inform them of new product lines. Id. According to the BSAC, “[t]he combined time [Balasanyan] Plaintiffs and Class Members are required to engage in non-commission producing activities totals at least one (1) hour and thirty (30) minutes per work shift” for which there is no compensation. Id. ¶ 16. The BSAC states six causes of action: (1) Nonpayment of Wages under Cal. Labor Code § 1194; (2) Nonpayment of Wages under 29 U.S.C. § 206 (the Fair Labor Standards Act, or “FLSA”); (3) Breach of Contract; (4) Declaratory Relief under Cal. Civ.Code Proc. § 1060; (5) Unfair Business Practices under Cal Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200; and (6) a PAGA claim under Cal. Labor Code § 2699.
Unlike Balasanyan, the proposed Maraventano class only consists of California employees. Plaintiff Maraventano was an employee of Nordstrom in San Diego County and Plaintiff Kurji was an employee in Orange County. The Maraventano First Amended Complaint (“MFAC”) alleges that Nordstrom did not pay employees for “stocking time ... unless they failed to meet their minimum commission draw.” MFAC ¶ 21. It states four causes of action: (1) Violation of Cal. Labor Code § 1197; (2) Violation of Cal. Labor Code §§ 201–203; (3) Willful violation of Cal. Labor Code § 226; (4) Unfair Business Practices under Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200. Unlike the Balasanyan Plaintiffs, the Maraventano Plaintiffs did not assert a FLSA claim.
A moving party is entitled to summary judgment where “there is no genuine issue as to any material fact ....” Fed.R.Civ.P. 56(c); Prison Legal News v. Lehman, 397 F.3d 692, 698 (9th Cir.2005). The court must examine the evidence in the light most favorable to the non-moving party. United States v. Diebold, Inc., 369 U.S. 654, 655, 82 S.Ct. 993, 8 L.Ed.2d 176 (1962). While Rule 56 contains “no express or implied requirement ... that the moving party support its motion with affidavits or other similar materials negating the opponent's claim,” Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323, 106 S.Ct. 2548, 91 L.Ed.2d 265 (1986), “the moving party bears the burden of proof at trial, [and] it must come forward with evidence which would entitle it to a directed verdict if the evidence were uncontroverted at trial.' ” Houghton v. South, 965 F.2d 1532, 1536 (9th Cir.1992).
If the moving party meets its initial burden of production, the burden shifts to the non-moving party to go beyond the pleadings by citing materials in the record to show a genuine issue for trial. Celotex, 477 U.S. at 324, 106 S.Ct. 2548 (citation omitted). The opposing party also may not rely solely on conclusory allegations unsupported by factual data. Taylor v. List, 880 F.2d 1040, 1045 (9th Cir.1989). Nevertheless, the ultimate burden of persuasion on the motion remains with the moving party. Nissan Fire & Marine Ins. Co., Ltd. v. Fritz Cos., 210 F.3d 1099, 1102 (9th Cir.2000). Doubt as to the existence of any issue of material fact requires denial of the motion. Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S. 242, 255, 106 S.Ct. 2505, 91 L.Ed.2d 202 (1986).
III. DISCUSSIONA. Maraventano and BalasanyanCalifornia Labor Code § 1197 Claims
Nordstrom contends that its commission plan does not violate California Labor Code §§ 1194 and 1197 because “California law permits employers to pay commissions for all hours worked and does not impose any restrictions on the type of work employers can pay with commissions.” MMSJ at 7 (emphasis in original). Nordstrom alternatively asserts that commissions may be used to compensate employees for “non-sell time” work as it is part of the services provided in connection with sales. Nordstrom believes that its commission plan, which guaranteed that Plaintiffs received an effective minimum hourly draw rate that exceeded minimum wage for all selling time, therefore complied with federal and state minimum wage laws. MMSJ at 3; BMSJ at 3–4. Finally, Nordstrom contends that the employment contracts, which they insist comply with California's minimum wage laws, should govern. MMSJ at 13; BMSJ at 14.
To support its first argument, Nordstrom relies on the California Wage Order 7, also known as the Mercantile Wage Order, which was written by Industrial Welfare Commission (“IWC”) 5 pursuant to California Labor Code § 1197. The Mercantile Wage Order requires every employer to pay “each employee ... not less than the applicable minimum wage for all hours worked in the payroll period, whether the remuneration is measured by time, piece, commission, or otherwise.” 6 Mercantile Wage Order § 4(B). The Mercantile Wage Order contains no limitation on commissions only being used to compensate employees for “sales hours.” MMSJ at 8–9. Nordstrom believes that the Mercantile Wage Order's silence on the type of work that commissions may be used to compensate necessarily means that it may use commissions to compensate for all work.
Furthermore, the California Department of Labor recognizes “Draws Against Commission” plans, which compensate employees exclusively through commissions with a minimum guarantee or advance for all hours. Cal. Dept. of Labor Standards Enforcement (“DLSE”) Policies & Interpretation Manual (“DLSE Manual”) § 34.2 (); DLSE Opinion Letter 1987.3.3 (“The minimum wage may be used as a Draw Against Commission provided that the commission equals or exceeds the minimum wage for that period.”). While California state courts have considered challenges to Draw Against Commission plans, they have never questioned employers' right to compensate salespeople through such plans. See e.g., Muldrow v. Surrex Solutions Corp., 208 Cal.App.4th 1381, 146 Cal.Rptr.3d 447 (2012) (); Ellis v. McKinnon Broad. Co., 18 Cal.App.4th 1796, 23 Cal.Rptr.2d 80 (1993) (...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Tri-Union Seafoods, LLC v. Starr Surplus Lines Ins. Co.
... ... 1. Legal Standard In Atlantic Marine Construction Company, Inc. v. United States District Court for the Western District of Texas, ––– U.S. ––––, ... See, e.g., Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc., 913 F.Supp.2d 1001, 1010 n. 9 (S.D.Cal.2012) (finding UCL claims survived ... ...
-
Oman v. Delta Air Lines, Inc.
... ... ( Id ... at p. 50, 155 Cal.Rptr.3d 18 ; see also Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc. (S.D.Cal. 2012) 913 F.Supp.2d 1001 [finding a violation of California wage law under Armenta where a department store paid ... ...
-
Villalpando v. Exel Direct Inc.
... ... 1) at 7; see also Defendants' Proposed Jury Instruction No.4 (Non-Payment of Minimum Wage—Essential Factual Elements) (citing Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc. , 913 F.Supp.2d 1001, 1006 (S.D.Cal.2012) ). With respect to the allegedly unlawful deductions, Exel appears to advance a similar ... ...
-
In re Certified Tire & Serv. Ctrs. Wage & Hour Cases
... ... a bench trial in favor of defendants 281 Cal.Rptr.3d 107 Certified Tire and Service Centers, Inc. (Certified Tire) and Barrett Business Services, Inc. (collectively defendants). Plaintiffs contend ... 323, 37 Cal.Rptr.3d 460 ; see also Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc. (S.D. Cal. 2012) 913 F.Supp.2d 1001, 1005–1006 ( Balasanyan ) [relying on ... ...
-
The Future of the Minimum Wage – 2015 and Beyond
...the city announced the rate would increase to $10.66 per hour on March 1, 2014. Sebastian Chilco Brian Dixon Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc., 913 F. Supp. 2d 1001 (S.D. Cal. 2012) 3 29 U.S.C. § 4 See, e.g., Alaska (Alaska Stat. § 23.10.055); California (California Wage Orders Nos. 1-13 & ......
-
The Future Of The Minimum Wage 2015 And Beyond
...LA Motors, LP, 215 Cal. App. 4th 36 (2013), Bluford v. Safeway Inc., 216 Cal. App. 4th 8642013), Balasanyan v. Nordstrom, Inc., 913 F. Supp. 2d 1001 (S.D. Cal. 3 29 U.S.C. § 207(i). 4 See, e.g., Alaska (Alaska Stat. § 23.10.055); California (California Wage Orders Nos. 1-13 & 15-16, § 1......
-
Employment Law Commentary -- Volume 25, Issue 9 -- September 2013: Where Average Isn’t Good Enough: California Courts Continue to Attack Piece-Rate and Commissions Compensation Plans
...Interpretations Manual §§ 49.2.1.6–8. 5 216 Cal. App. 4th 864 (2013). 6 Id. at p. 871. 7 Id. at p. 872 (citations omitted). 8 913 F.Supp. 2d 1001 (S.D. Cal. 2012). 9 Id. at p. 1007, fn. 7. We are Morrison & Foerster — a global firm of exceptional credentials. Our clients include some of......
-
Where Average Isnt Good Enough: California Courts Continue To Attack Piece-Rate And Commissions Compensation Plans
...and Interpretations Manual §§ 49.2.1.6-8. 5 216 Cal. App. 4th 864 (2013). 6 Id. at p. 871. 7 Id. at p. 872 (citations omitted). 8 913 F.Supp. 2d 1001 (S.D. Cal. 9 Id. at p. 1007, fn. 7. Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all si......