Billmeyer v. State, for Use of Whiteman

• Decision Date: 09 March 1949
• Docket Number: 91.
• Citation: Billmeyer v. State, for Use of Whiteman, 192 Md. 419, 64 A.2d 755 (Md. 1949)
• Parties: BILLMEYER v. STATE, for Use of WHITEMAN et al.
• Court: Maryland Court of Appeals

64 A.2d 755

192 Md. 419

BILLMEYER v. STATE, for Use of WHITEMAN et al.

No. 91.

Court of Appeals of Maryland

March 9, 1949

Appeal from Circuit Court, Allegany County; William A. Huster Judge.

Suit by the State of Maryland, for the use of Ethelinda WhitemanSharon Elaine Whiteman, and others, against Robert Odell Billmeyer for death sustained in an automobile accident Defendant's motion for a directed verdict and motion for judgment n. o. v. were overruled and judgment entered for plaintiffs for $11,480, and defendant appeals.

Judgment reversed without a new trial.

D. Lindley Sloan and William H. Geppert, both of Cumberland, for appellant.

Morgan C. Harris and William C. Walsh, both of Cumberland, for appellees.

Before MARBURY, C.J., and DELAPLAINE, COLLINS, GRASON, HENDERSON and MARKELL, JJ.

HENDERSON Judge.

This case grew out of a traffic accident at McCoole, Allegany County, Maryland, on December 21, 1945, in which a pedestrian, Robert Whiteman, 32 years old, was struck by an automobile driven by Robert Billmeyer and died of a fractured skull.Suit was brought under Art. 67 of the Code and resulted in a verdict of the jury in favor of the three minor children of the decedent.The widow, having remarried, was awarded no damages.At the close of the testimony the defendant filed a motion for a directed verdict on the issues of negligence, contributory negligence and proximate cause, which was overruled.A motion for judgment N.O.V. was also overruled, and apportioned judgment entered for $11,480.

McCoole is a small, unincorporated town or village on the state highway along the Potomac River between Keyser, West Virginia to the east and Westernport, Maryland to the west.The main street, or portion of the highway passing through McCoole, is known as Queen Street and is a straight, level, concrete road, 16 feet wide, with dirt shoulders and no sidewalks.Shortly after midnight on December 21, 1945, Whiteman arrived at the scene of the accident in a taxicab which stopped heading west with its left wheels on the edge of the concrete on the north side of Queen Street, opposite his brother's house, 75 Queen Street, on the south side, where he intended to spend the night.It was a clear, moonlight night, but cold and windy.The center of the road was dry and clear for three or four feet, but there was a light coating of hard packed snow and ice along the sides.There is a street or lane 14 feet wide, known as West Street, which intersects Queen Street at right angles on the north, but does not run through to the south.The entrance to 75 Queen Street is 45 feet from the southeast corner of the intersection, or what would be the corner if West Street were projected.There is a street light upon the telephone pole at what would be the southwest corner.

Whiteman got out of the right front seat of the taxicab.This would place him about eight feet from the front bumper.There was some delay while he paid his fare and searched for a quarter he had dropped in the seat.The point where the taxicab stopped was near the intersection of Queen Street and West Street, but not directly at the corner.The taxicab driver, Stoutameyer, testified, and the photographs show, there is a deep ditch and drain under the main highway at the northeast corner.He testified that he stopped 'two or three feet' from the corner; he had 'to travel about a car length to turn.'He'pulled out and turned to the right and went up to 90 West Street to discharge' his other passengers in the rear seat.He last saw Whiteman standing by the front door as he pulled away.Whiteman had been drinking, but was not staggering.Stoutameyer did not see any car approaching, nor did the other passengers.When he came back down West Street a few minutes later and turned east into Queen Street, he was 'flagged down' by Billmeyer.Whiteman's body was lying in the center of Queen Street illuminated by the headlights of a standing automobile headed west.His head was to the south of the center line, his feet were to the north in a diagonal direction.The point where he was lying was about a car length further to the east from the point where Stoutameyer had last seen him.Billmeyer told him he'was coming [east] down the highway and applied his brakes and his car skidded to the left and caused the left side of his car to hit Mr. Whiteman.'There were no skid marks.The handle of the left front door had been knocked off and was lying in the center of the road near the body.Billmeyer took Whiteman to the hospital, but Whiteman died within a few hours after admittance.His injuries consisted of scratches on the left hand, fracture of the skull (frontal bone), lacerations and contusions of the forehead, nose and eyelids.

Billmeyer, twenty-two years old, was a corporal in the Army Medical Corps home on furlough.He was driving his aunt's Dodge sedan, with her permission, and had just taken her home and driven a friend to his home in McCoole prior to the accident.The car had no chains on its wheels.He testified that the condition of the road did not require them.He had had two bottles and a glass of 3.2 beer in the course of the evening, but was not intoxicated.He testified that he was driving east on the right hand side of the highway, on the concrete, at about 25 miles per hour, when he saw a car, with headlights, on the north side of the road.He did not know it was a taxicab; apparently it had no distinguishing marks.He slowed down to about 20 miles per hour.As he was passing this car he saw a man opposite his left front fender walking across the road from behind the other car.He was 'blinded by this car that was setting there; his lights were on.* * * I couldn't see him for the cab.'He put on his brakes and swerved to the right.His car did not skid.He didn't have time to blow his horn.The man kept on walking, two or three steps, into the left side of the car alongside the driver's seat.(In a statement given to the State's Attorney he said one step.)The front of the car did not touch him, but the impact, or 'sideswipe,' knocked him down.Billmeyer continued on, turned at a filling station about 100 feet to the east, and came back so that his headlights would help him to render aid.Stoutameyer came along before he had attempted to move Whiteman, who was lying diagonally across the center of the road just opposite the entrance to 75 Queen Street.Stoutameyer helped him put Whiteman in his car to take him to the hospital.Another man picked up the broken door handle and handed it to Billmeyer.

In a pretrial deposition, offered in evidence over objection Billmeyer testified that Whiteman was lying diagonally across the center of the road with his head to the north of the center line and his feet to the...