Board of Commissioners of St. Joseph County v. State ex rel. Michener

Decision Date29 October 1889
Docket Number14,892
Citation22 N.E. 339,120 Ind. 442
PartiesBoard of Commissioners of St. Joseph County v. The State, ex rel. Michener, Attorney General
CourtIndiana Supreme Court

From the St. Joseph Circuit Court.

Judgment affirmed.

J. E Howard, for appellant.

L. T Michener, Attorney General, J. H. Gillett and L. Hubbard, for the State.

OPINION

Elliott, C. J.

Within the county of St. Joseph are lands which were set apart to the school fund by the act of Congress; these lands were sold by the county authorities for $ 13,750, of which amount one-fourth was paid in cash, and the remainder of the purchase-money was secured by mortgage. The whole amount for which the lands were sold was reported, as the law requires, to the superintendent of public instruction, and the county was charged with it. The purchase-money was not paid, and the lands were forfeited. The question which we are required to decide is this: Is the county chargeable with interest on the entire amount of the price of the land, or only upon the amount received in cash?

The case is governed by section 4346, R. S. 1881, which reads thus: "One-fourth of the purchase-money shall be paid in hand and the interest for the residue for one year in advance, and the residue in ten years from such sale, with like interest annually in advance; and deferred payments shall be regarded as part of the congressional township school fund, and reported as such by the auditor to the superintendent of public instruction." We can discover neither obscurity nor ambiguity in this statute, and there is no room for construction. Where the words of a statute are free from obscurity or ambiguity, nothing remains but to enforce them as they are written. We can not conceive how it is possible to choose words that would more plainly convey the meaning that the unpaid purchase-money is a part of the congressional township school fund. The words are: "and deferred payments shall be regarded as part of the congressional school fund," and "shall be reported as such." The deferred payments go into the fund as part and parcel of it. From this conclusion there is no escape, save by striking out the words of the Legislature and substituting others for them, and this no court would dream of doing.

Counties are public corporations, and over them the legislative authority is very great and extensive. The Legislature, in the exercise of this authority may, undoubtedly,...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT