Board of Ed. of Town of West Orange v. Wilton

Citation273 A.2d 44,57 N.J. 404
Parties, 76 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2500, 64 Lab.Cas. P 52,489 BOARD OF EDUCATION OF the TOWN OF WEST ORANGE in the County of Essex, a corporation, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Elizabeth WILTON and Administrators Association of West Orange Public Schools, Defendants-Respondents.
Decision Date26 January 1971
CourtUnited States State Supreme Court (New Jersey)

Samuel A. Christiano, West Orange, for appellant.

Thomas P. Cook, Princeton, for New Jersey School Bd. Ass'n, amicus curiae.

John H. Dorsey, Cedar Grove, for respondents Elizabeth Wilton and Admrs. Ass'n of West Orange Public Schools.

Theodore A. Winard, Deputy Atty. Gen., for respondent Public Employment Relations Commission (George F. Kugler, Jr., Atty. Gen. of N.J.).

The opinion of the Court was delivered by


After the Legislature adopted the New Jersey Employer-Employee Relations Act, L.1968, c. 303, N.J.S.A. 34:13A--1 et seq., certain administrative employees of the West Orange Board of Education organized the Administrators Association of the West Orange Public Schools and requested the Board to recognize it as the collective negotiating unit for all supervisory personnel, except the Superintendent of Schools. N.J.S.A. 34:13A--5.3. On February 10, 1969, the Board recognized the Association as negotiating representative for principals, assistant principals, subject matter directors, and administrative assistants but excluded from the unit 'Directors who act in supervisory capacity' over such personnel. Pursuant to this resolution, the Board refused to accept the Association as the appropriate negotiating unit for Elizabeth Wilton who holds the supervisory position of Director of Elementary Education.

The Association then filed a petition with the Public Employment Relations Commission asking that it be designated as the exclusive representative of all supervisory personnel of the Board, including Miss Wilton. N.J.S.A. 34:13A--6(d). Miss Wilton who had become a member of the Association joined in the petition. By way of answer, the Board of Education admitted that it had accepted the Association as the negotiating unit for the employees in the described categories. However, it asserted that the unit was not appropriate for Miss Wilton because her status as Director of Elementary Education invested her with such supervision over the other employees included therein and such intimacy with the managerial aspects of the Board's operation that she should be excluded. The Commission referred the matter to a Hearing Officer for the taking of testimony and the making of a report and recommendation.

At the hearing, the Board's position was that Miss Wilton is a top echelon supervisor and as such does not belong in the same negotiating unit with principals, assistant principals, subject matter directors and administrative assistants because her duties require her to supervise them in the interest of the Board's management and control of the school system. On the other hand the Association, relying on N.J.S.A. 34:13A--3(d) and 34:13A--5.3, contended that all employees of the public school system, including those who have supervisory duties over teachers, excepting only the superintendent of schools, are eligible under the Act to join an employee organization. Section 13A--3(d) provides among other things that the term 'employee' shall include any person holding 'employment in the service of a public employer * * * provided that in any school district this shall exclude only the superintendent of schools or other chief administrator of the district.' And under Section 13A--5.3 public employees are granted the right to join an employee organization, provided, however, that the right shall not extend to 'any managerial executive' except that in a school district such executive 'shall mean the superintendent of schools or his equivalent.' It is provided also that 'except where established practice, prior agreement, or special circumstances dictate the contrary,' no 'supervisor having the power to hire, discharge, discipline, or to effectively recommend the same' shall 'have the right to be represented in collective negotiations by an employee organization that admits nonsupervisory personnel to membership, and the fact that any organization has such supervisory employees as members shall not deny the right of that organization to represent the appropriate unit in collective negotiations * * *.' The section further directs that the 'negotiating unit shall be defined with due regard for the community of interest among the employees concerned * * *.'

N.J.S.A. 34:13A--6(d) contains a further direction to the Commission with respect to the ascertainment of the appropriate unit. It says that 'except where dictated by established practice, prior agreement, or special circumstances, no unit shall be appropriate which includes * * * both supervisors and nonsupervisors * * *.' It may be noted in passing that no teachers actively engaged as such in the West Orange schools are members of this Association; its members are drawn exclusively from the administrative echelons. Moreover, there is no issue here concerning the propriety of including principals and assistant principals in the same negotiating unit. The possibility of conflict arising out of the principals' duty to supervise assistant principals, which might arise in certain settings (which we do not consider in this case), is not involved because the Board of Education has raised no issue with respect to this joint membership in the Association.

Substantial evidence was adduced before the Hearing Officer to show Miss Wilton's place in the administrative structure of the school system. Under Article V, Section 1 of the Board of Education Policy Manual, the Board appoints a Director of Elementary Education and a Director of Secondary Education 'who shall be directly responsible to the Superintendent of Schools in the performance of all duties.' To qualify for such appointment, the Directors must have experience at their respective levels in teaching, supervision and administration, and 'a broad knowledge of educational problems.' The Board's organization chart shows the Director of Elementary Education (Miss Wilton) on a higher plane in the administrative hierarchy than elementary school principals. In the chain of authority, it positions the Director on a direct line above the principals below whom it places the 'teachers, nurse, pupils, secretaries and custodians.' The Director of Secondary Education is shown on the chart on the same plane as the Director of Elementary Education. In a direct line below the Director of Secondary Education (and on the same level as the elementary principals) are the secondary principals, below whom appear assistant principals, administrative assistant, department chairman, counselors, teachers, nurse, pupils, secretaries, custodians and cafeteria staff. The Board's Policy Manual, already referred to, reveals that among other things the Directors have the duties (1) of making recommendations and advising the Superintendent as to 'needed extensions or readjustments of the educational program, services and activities of the school,' (2) of assisting 'teachers, principals, and other members of the professional staff in the improvement of instruction,' (3) of encouraging the 'continuous study of curriculum problems by principals' and promoting 'all efforts for curriculum development and improvement in keeping with the best current practices and thought,' and (4) of assisting 'the Superintendent in the recruitment, selection, assignment, and transfer of teachers.'

Each elementary or secondary school principal is in charge of a school building, and he in turn is 'directly responsible to either the Director of Elementary Education or the Director of Secondary Education.' Each principal has the further duty of making 'all reports for his school as required by law or by the Directors of Education, and the Superintendent.' In the area of secondary education where assistant principals are appointed, such persons are directly responsible to the building principal who is charged with the assignment of their duties.

In his testimony, the Superintendent of Schools outlined Miss Wilton's position as a supervisor in the administrative heirarchy of the West Orange schools. He said that as Director she is responsible for the administration of the elementary schools; she supervises the work of each of the nine elementary school principals and evaluates their performance for purposes of recommending tenure and salary increments for them to the Superintendent and the Board of Education. In this connection the Board of Education pointed out that its by-laws provide that:

Favorable reports by the Superintendent of Schools and those charged with supervisory responsibility, and approval by the Board of Education are prerequisite to the granting of All increases in salary. There shall be no automatic increments or increases in salary.

The Superintendent also pointed out that, as Director, Miss Wilton holds regularly scheduled monthly meetings with the elementary school principals and she is responsible for the instructional program and curriculum development in the elementary schools. She reviews the budget proposals of all principals. She recruits teachers for elementary schools, interviews the candidates and recommends them to the Superintendent for appointment; she recruits or screens the staff personnel of the schools and recommends them to the principal. In turn, the principals will interview and observe candidates recommended by Miss Wilton, but if she recommends a person for a teaching post in a particular school and the principal does not wish such person, she would have the final say in the matter, subject, of course, to approval of her recommendation by the Superintendent or the Board of Education.

The Superintendent gave a number of examples of Miss...

To continue reading

Request your trial
9 cases
  • New Jersey Turnpike Authority v. American Federation of State, County and Mun. Employees, Council 73
    • United States
    • New Jersey Supreme Court
    • July 14, 1997
    ... ... Such conflicts were addressed by this Court in Board of Education v. Wilton, which held that where "substantial ... relations material such as tape recordings of closed town council sessions. Ibid. Furthermore, the deputy clerk ... In Township of West Windsor v. PERC, this Court held that ... employee ... ...
  • State v. Professional Ass'n of N. J. Dept. of Ed.
    • United States
    • New Jersey Supreme Court
    • February 5, 1974
    ... ... 579, 267 A.2d 533 (1970); [315 A.2d 7] Bd. of Ed. of West Orange v. Wilton, 57 N.J. 404, 273 A.2d 44 (1971); Dunellen ... In almost all of these systems, as in New Jersey, a board or officer is authorized to fix an appropriate unit for ... ...
  • Lay Faculty Ass'n of Regional Secondary Schools of Archdiocese of Newark v. Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Newark
    • United States
    • New Jersey Superior Court — Appellate Division
    • February 2, 1973
    ... ... relief or remedy from the National Labor Relations Board because defendant is not an employer within definition of ... of Ed., West Orange v. Wilton, 57 N.J. 404, 273 A.2d 44 (1971); Bowman ... ...
  • Matters of State
    • United States
    • New Jersey Supreme Court
    • March 9, 1989
    ... ... 34:13A-5.3). Building on principles set forth in Board of Educ. of W. Orange v. Wilton, 57 N.J. 404, 273 A.2d 44 ... ...
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT