Brandon Valley Independent School Dist. No. 150 v. Minnehaha County Bd. of Ed.
Decision Date | 10 November 1970 |
Docket Number | No. 10777,10777 |
Parties | BRANDON VALLEY INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 150, Appellant, v. MINNEHAHA COUNTY BOARD OF EDUCATION, Respondent. |
Court | South Dakota Supreme Court |
Woods, Fuller, Shultz & Smith, and John E. Simko, Sioux Falls, for appellant.
Bruce Blake, Deputy State's Atty., Sioux Falls, for respondent.
This appeal by the Brandon Valley Independent School District involves the propriety of a Resolution adopted by the Minnehaha County Board of Education dissolving the Renberg Common School District and attaching it to the appellant Independent School District. Respondent did not appear or file a brief in the matter.
The Renberg Common School District is situated immediately north of the city of Sioux Falls. A portion lies south of Interstate 90 in the Municipal Airport area bordered on the south by the Sioux Falls Independent School District. The district is bordered on the north by the Baltic Independent School District. Interstate 29 runs along the west boundary and U.S. Highway 77 the east boundary line. Except for these highways the Tri-Valley Independent School District adjoins Renberg on the west and the Brandon Valley Independent District on the north half of its eastern boundary. Another common school district adjoins it on the south half of its eastern boundary. In 1968--69 Renberg had approximately 175 elementary grade students and over 50 secondary grade students. Its high school students either attended the Baltic high school which operates busses in the area or the Sioux Falls high school. None attended school at Brandon Valley. Renberg has an assessed valuation in excess of $2,500,000 and no outstanding debt.
On April 30, 1969 the electros of Renberg voted to dissolve and attach to Brandon Valley to be effective July 1, 1970. The Minnehaha County Board of Education considered the proposition at its meeting on June 2, 1969 at which time delegations from Renberg, Baltic, Brandon Valley, and other school districts were present.
Brandon Valley protested the attachment of Renberg because it would cast an unwanted burden on the district. Brandon Valley had constructed a new high school facility in the fall of 1967 resulting in a bonded debt in excess of $900,000. The district had other outstanding obligations in excess of $300,000. The new school building had a peak capacity of 450 students which was expected to be reached during the 1970--71 school year from students within its own district. All of its school busses were being used to capacity. The influx of new students from Renberg would necessitate the purchase of at least three new busses at a cost of $7,500 each, additional teachers, rescheduling, overcrowding, and a probable increase in bonded debt to pay for the necessary expansion of programs. On the other hand, the Sioux Falls and Baltic Independent Districts were receptive to accepting Renberg students.
Contrary to the expressed wishes of Brandon Valley the Minnehaha County Board of Education adopted the following Resolution:
Now, Therefore, Be It Resolved that Renberg No. 5 is hereby dissolved and attached to Brandon Valley No. 150, effective July 1, 1970.'
The action of the Minnehaha County Board of Education was affirmed by the Circuit Court and this appeal followed.
Pertinent portions of the school dissolution statutes are as follows:
SDCL 13--6--34. 'A school district which by sixty per cent of the votes cast in a special election approves the dissolution of the school district and its combination with another school district or districts shall be combined with another district or other districts pursuant to §§ 13--6--35 and 13--6--36. * * *'
In view of the patent ambiguity of the above statutes the Minnehaha County Board of Education was uncertain of its duties and powers thereunder. The chairman of the board sought information from the office of the State Superintendent of Instruction and was advised by an expert on reorganization that 'with the vote as you have there isn't any question but what you have to put them in Brandon Valley.' It is evident the Minnehaha County Board of Education acted accordingly. The members of the Board believed they had no discretion in the matter and were compelled to attach Renberg to Brandon Valley because of the Renberg election.
In the performance of its school reorganization duties the Minnehaha County Board exercises a legislative function, Dunker v. Brown County Board of Education, 80 S.D. 193, 121 N.W.2d 10. Sunnywood Common School District No. 46, etc. v. County Board of Education, 81 S.D. 110, 131 N.W.2d 105; Bandy v. Mickelson, 73 S.D. 485, 44 N.W.2d 341, 22 A.L.R.2d 1129. In reviewing questions of law the courts may determine whether or not the agency exceeded or misinterpreted its authority.
We do not construe SDCL 13--6--34 to be self executing. Following a special election approving dissolution the county board of education is under a duty to combine the dissolved district with another district or other districts pursuant to 13--6--35 and 13--6--36. This statute does not divest the county board of its delegated discretionary legislative function. It does not compel attachment with the election result. Instead, it broadly authorizes the county board to combine the dissolved district 'with another district or other districts'. As the wishes of the electors in the district to be eliminated have been expressed in a special election SDCL 13--6--35 eliminates the necessity of a public hearing to determine the same. It does not foreclose the county board from considering and following the wishes of the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
In re Estate of Neiswender
... ... (25%) interest in real property in Eddy County, New Mexico as follows: ... * * * ... ...
-
Elk Point Independent School Dist. No. 3 of Union County v. State Commission on Elementary and Secondary Educ.
...No. 230 of Brown County v. County Board of Education of Brown County, S.D., 179 N.W.2d 6; Brandon Valley Independent School District No. 150 v. Minnehaha County Board of Education, S.D., 181 N.W.2d 96. The Elk Point district contends that the commission here exceeded its granted authority. ......
-
State ex rel. Board of Ed. of Pollock Independent School Dist. No. 51 v. Pfeifle
...board or the state commission to attach Mound City Common to Pollock Independent, citing Brandon Valley Independent School District No. 150 v. Minnehaha County Board of Education, S.D., 181 N.W.2d 96, which held that a county board of education is not bound to attach a district dissolved pu......
-
Webster Independent School Dist. No. 101 of Day County v. County Bd. of Ed. of Day County
...of the children involved in the annexation of Kosciusko Common to Roslyn Independent. In Brandon Valley Independent School District v. Minnehaha County Bd. of Ed. (1970) 85 S.D. 255, 181 N.W.2d 96, this Court held that the County Board of Education does have discretionary legislative functi......