Brown v. People of State
| Decision Date | 31 January 1879 |
| Citation | 91 Ill. 506,1879 WL 8435 |
| Parties | ZERA BROWNv.THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS. |
| Court | Illinois Supreme Court |
OPINION TEXT STARTS HERE
WRIT OF ERROR to the Circuit Court of McLean county; the Hon. OWEN T. REEVES, Judge, presiding.
This was an indictment against Zera Brown for burglary. The record shows that the defendant was a weak, simple minded person, and the only evidence against him was his admissions and statements, induced after various threats and promises had been made to him.
Mr. B. D. LUCAS, and Mr. JAMES R. BROOKS, for the plaintiff in error:
A confession can never be received in evidence where the prisoner has been influenced by any threat or promise. Gates v. The People, 14 Ill. 437; Austin v. The People, 51 Ill. 239.
The accused was indicted for burglary, and on the trial he was found guilty, and sentenced to the penitentiary for the period of one year. On looking into the testimony found in the record we are satisfied it does not warrant the conviction. Much of the testimony admitted against the objections of defendant was incompetent. The accused was advised to make a confession, and in attempting to do so he made several different statements, all of which are shown by other testimony to be absolutely untrue.
The verdict is so much against the weight of the evidence it ought not to be permitted to stand, and for that reason we have not deemed it necessary to consider the instructions given at the trial.
The judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded.
Judgment reversed.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
State of Idaho v. Crump
... ... Dec. 465; McCreary v. Commonwealth, 29 Pa. St. 325; ... O'Brian v. Commonwealth, 9 Bush (Ky.), 339, 15 ... Am. Rep. 715; People v. Cage, 48 Cal. 323, 17 Am ... Rep. 436; Commonwealth v. Fitzpatrick, 121 Pa. St ... 115, 6 Am. St. Rep. 757, 15 A. 466.) The court erred in ... 386; Nolen v. State, 14 Tex. App. 474, 46 Am. Rep ... 247, and note; Barnes v. State, 36 Tex. 356; ... Redd v. State, 69 Ala. 255; Brown v ... People, 91 Ill. 506; State v. Jones, 54 Mo ... 478; People v. Mondon, 103 N.Y. 211, 57 Am. Rep ... 709, 8 N.E. 496; State v ... ...
-
People v. Buckminster
...People, 17 Ill. 426, 65 Am. Dec. 672;South v. People, 98 Ill. 261;Campbell v. People, 159 Ill. 9, 42 N. E. 123,50 Am. St. Rep. 134;Brown v. People, 91 Ill. 506. If this be the rule as to the character and weight of voluntary confessions when admitted against the person who made them, there ......
-
The Jacksonville v. Cox
... ... CHARLES S. ZANE, Judge, presiding.Messrs. DUMMER, BROWN & RUSSELL, and Messrs. PATTON & LANPHIER, for the appellant.Messrs. BRADLEY & BRADLEY, for the ... ...