Bryant v. Lake County Trust Co.
| Court | Indiana Appellate Court |
| Writing for the Court | SHARP; HOFFMAN, C.J., and STATON |
| Citation | Bryant v. Lake County Trust Co., 152 Ind.App. 628, 284 N.E.2d 537 (Ind. App. 1972) |
| Decision Date | 29 June 1972 |
| Docket Number | No. 272A103,272A103 |
| Parties | John BRYANT, Jr., et al., Appellants, v. LAKE COUNTY TRUST COMPANY, An Indiana corporation in its own right and as trustee under Trust 1953, et al., Appellees. |
Saul I. Ruman, Hammond, for appellants.
Kenneth D. Reed, Hammond, for appellees Lake County Trust Co. and Richard Klaas.
William J. Muha, Highland, for appellees Lake County Plan Commission and Board of Commissioners of Lake County, Indiana.
This case comes before us on an appeal from an order of the Lake Circuit Court granting Appellees' Motion to Dismiss under TR Rule 12(B), IC 1971, 34--5--1--1, Indiana Rules of Procedure and the trial court's subsequent denial of Appellants' Motion to Correct Errors.
This controversy involves a challenge by nearby property owners to a proposed construction of a large mobile home park in the rural southern part of Lake County. The property on which the project will be built was purportedly rezoned under a Mobile Home Ordinance by an amendment to the zoning ordinance passed by the Board of County Commissioners. Appellants filed a complaint in two paragraphs, the first seeking a declaratory judgment as to the validity of the amendment and an injunction against any construction under said amendment, and the second paragraph seeking a writ of certiorari to review the decision of the Lake County Plan Commission.
Appellants allege, inter alia, that they are owners of real property in the vicinity of the real estate in controversy and that they are adversely affected by the amendment to the zoning ordinance.
The Lake County Trust Company is the title holder of record under a trust agreement. During January 1971 Richard Klaas, a developer and beneficial owner of the land, filed a request with the Plan Commission for various zoning changes, one of which was to rezone part of the property to PUD (Planned Unit Development), Class I. At the time of such request the County Zoning Ordinance did not provide for a classification PUD, Class I.
Subsequent to the request, the Plan Commission gave notice of the hearing on the proposed rezoning of the property from A--1 agricultural to PUD, Class I. At the time of the notice, PUD, Class I was not used in any Lake County Ordinance. The classification only appeared in a proposed Mobile Home Ordinance, which at the time of the notice had not yet been adopted.
On February 8, 1971, the Board of County Commissioners passed the Mobile Home Ordinance, which requires ten (10) days notice to be given the public prior to a Plan Commission hearing on an amendment. On the same day the Plan Commission considered the request on the proposed amendment which would rezone the property to PUD, Class I and recommended to the Board of County Commissioners that the amendment be adopted.
At its regular meeting of May 10, 1971, the Board of County Commissioners considered the recommendation to amend the zoning ordinance. One of the commissioners moved for adoption, but his actual vote was not recorded and the other two commissioners voted against the proposed amendment.
After the 30 day statutory period for appeal had expired with no further action having been taken by either side, the Lake County Trust Company brought an action in the Lake Superior Court in the case of Lake County Trust Co. v. The Board of Commissioners of Lake County, Cause Number 571--418, for a Declaratory Judgment, essentially arguing that in order to defeat a favorable recommendation of the Plan Commission, the Board of County Commissioners must unanimously vote against said recommendation. None of the Appellants, who were remonstrators against the amendment, were made parties to that action. On August 6, 1971, judgment was rendered in the Lake Superior Court declaring that the land had been rezoned as of the date when the Board failed to unanimously reject the Plan Commission's recommendation. On August 9, 1971, final approval was given the revised plans for the construction of the mobile home park by the Plan Commission.
Within 30 days from the date of final approval of the construction plans by the Plan Commission, Appellants filed the complaint here in the Lake Circuit Court. The complaint was in two legal paragraphs, the first paragraph of which prayed for an injunction against the proposed construction and for a judgment declaring that the amendment to the zoning ordinance was illegal and void because of defective notice and because the amendment was defeated at the Mary 10, 1971, meeting of the Board of County Commissioners. Appellees filed in the trial court a Motion to Dismiss under Rule TR 12(B)(1), (2), (6) and (7). Said motion was granted by the trial court but it did not designate which ground or grounds constituted the basis for the dismissal. The sole issue in this appeal is whether the trial court properly granted appellees' Motion to Dismiss.
The primary thrust of Appellees' Motion to Dismiss may be summarized as asking the trial court to dismiss Appellants' complaint for the reason that Appellants failed to timely challenge the rezoning in the exclusive manner prescribed by law pursuant to IC 1971, 18--7--5--1 et seq., Ind.Ann.Stat. § 53--701 et seq. (Burns 1964). Thus the motion to dismiss concludes that Appellants have not properly perfected their remedy under the statute and that the trial court lacked jurisdiction over the subject matter of the complaint. Failure to comply or to pursue statutory remedies is jurisdictional and is properly raised by a Rule TR 12(B)(1) motion. Cooper v. County Board of Review, Ind.App., 276 N.E.2d 533 (1971); City of Hammond v. Board of Zoning Appeals, Ind.App., 284 N.E.2d 119 (1972). When a trial court grants a motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter it has no further power to adjudicate whether or not the complaint stated a claim upon which relief could be granted pursuant to Rule TR 12(B)(6). Cooper v. County Board of Review, supra.
The first issue is whether the trial court properly granted the motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter. Essentially, it is the contention of Appellants that Appellees failed to appeal the amendment to the zoning ordinance to the Board of Zoning Appeals as provided in IC 1971, §§ 18--7--5--82 through 18--7--5--93, Ind.Ann.Stat. §§ 53--778 through 53--789 (Burns 1964 Repl.). The Board of Zoning Appeals is empowered to hear and determine appeals from any order, requirement, decision or determination made by a board charged with the enforcement of any ordinance or regulation duly adopted. It is not endowed with the power to overturn or veto, in its entirety, an amendment to a zoning ordinance enacted by the Board of County Commissioners, although it can grant a variance thereto.
While the General Assembly may confer upon the several counties, cities, towns, etc., powers of local legislative and administrative character, such powers are not self-executing and the statutory directions concerning the manner in which said power may be executed must be followed to give validity to any act taken pursuant to such power. Board of Zoning Appeals v. Parsons, 136 Ind.App. 520, 202 N.E.2d 589 (1964). All actions taken under said power and grant of authority must clearly conform to the terms of the grant and any amendment to a zoning ordinance must be pursuant to and in substantial compliance with the statute granting such power.
In Indiana, the power to zone or rezone property is vested in the City Council or the Board of County Commissioners. IC 1971, 18--7--5--58, Ind.Ann.Stat. § 53--756 (Burns 1964 Repl.). City of East Chicago, Indiana v. Sinclair Ref. Company, 232 Ind. 295, 111 N.E.2d 459 (1952), and the adoption of a zoning ordinance or an amendment thereto is a legislative function of those bodies. Only an amendment to a zoning ordinance can effectuate a variance which substantially alters the character of an area so that it is no longer in harmony with the general purpose and intent of said ordinance. Antrim v. Hohlt, 122 Ind.App. 681, 108 N.E.2d 197 (1952); Civil City of Indianapolis v. Ostrom Realty & Construction Co., 95 Ind.App. 376, 176 N.E. 246 (1932); and City of East Chicago v. Sinclair Ref. Co., supra. Thus the Board of Zoning Appeals does not have the authority to rezone land nor does it have the authority to invalidate an amendment to a zoning ordinance. It does possess the power to grant a variance thereto, but only if said variance does not substantially alter the character of the general area. Antrim v. Hohlt, supra. IC 1971, 18--7--5--82, Ind.Ann.Stat. § 53--778 (Burns 1964), provides an administrative remedy for persons whose property is unreasonably restricted by the terms of the ordinance or where, owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement of the ordinance will result in unnecessary hardship. City of East Chicago v. Sinclair Ref. Co., supra. It does not provide an administrative remedy for property owners in the vicinity who wish to contest the validity of an amendment to a zoning ordinance.
Also, the Appellants assert that the ordinance is void in its entirety for, among other reasons, lack of adequate notice. Where it is claimed that the entire zoning ordinance is void, the remedy is not by resort to an appeal to the Board of Zoning Appeals or by writ of certiorari, but may be asserted by direct action. City of South Bend v. Marckle, 215 Ind. 74, 18 N.E.2d 764 (1938). In State ex rel. Saylor Development Co. v. Circuit Court of Marion County, 240 Ind. 648, 649, 167 N.E.2d 470, 471 (1960), there was a complaint for an injunction which alleged ' that the purported amendment of the zoning ordinance for the proposed use as a shopping center was illegal and void for a number of reasons, among them, that the requisite statutory notice was not given to certain property owners'. Judge, now Chief...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Cohalan v. Schermerhorn
...American Law of Zoning § 14.68 at 61; Mayflower Prop., Inc. v. City of Fort Lauderdale, 137 So.2d 849 (Fla.App.); Bryant v. Lake County Trust Co., 284 N.E.2d 537 (Ind.)). In determining whether the zoning province of the legislative body has been invaded, size is a significant factor (Van D......
-
Indiana Waste Systems, Inc. v. Board of Com'rs of Howard County
...not a judicial decision. Such legislative decisions are not appealable under the procedure set out in Ind.Code 17-1-14-24. Bryant v. Lake County Trust Co., supra; Christy v. Board of Commissioners of Porter County, Had Systems attempted to challenge the validity of the Ordinance by appealin......
-
Wilson v. Review Bd. of Indiana Employment Sec. Division
...A failure to pursue statutory remedies is jurisdictional and may be raised by a motion to dismiss. Bryant v. Lake County Trust Co. (1972), 152 Ind.App. 628, 284 N.E.2d 537. IC 1971, 22-4-17-12 (Burns Code Ed.) provides that either party to the dispute, the Indiana Employment Security Board,......
-
Marhoefer Packing Co., Inc. v. Indiana Dept. of State Revenue
...Marhoefer has failed to meet the mandatory requirement to invoke the court's jurisdiction for judicial relief. Bryant v. Lake County Trust Co. (1972) Ind.Ct.App.) 284 N.E.2d 537 and Cooper v. County Board of Review of Grant County (1971), Ind.App., 276 N.E.2d 533 clearly hold that jurisdict......