Butler v. Sports Haven Intern., 14750

Citation563 P.2d 1245
Decision Date13 April 1977
Docket NumberNo. 14750,14750
PartiesGerald M. BUTLER, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. SPORTS HAVEN INTERNATIONAL, Defendant and Respondent.
CourtSupreme Court of Utah

Lambertus Jansen, Murray, for plaintiff and appellant.

John H. Snow and Elliott J. Williams, of Worsley, Snow & Christensen, Salt Lake City, for defendant and respondent.

CROCKETT, Justice:

Plaintiff, Gerald M. Butler, brought suit against defendant, Sports Haven International, alleging that its negligence in operation of its swimming pool resulted in the drowning of the plaintiff's three-year-old son, Gerald M. Butler, Jr. Defendant denied any negligence or any causation of the drowning. From the granting of defendant's motion for summary judgment, plaintiff appeals.

Defendant is a nonprofit corporation which maintains recreational property and facilities near Fairview, Utah. Members join it by buying the property in acre parcels. They can develop their own land as they desire, and are entitled to use the recreational facilities, including the clubhouse and the swimming pool. Plaintiff became a member in 1970.

The swimming pool and dressing facilities were enclosed with a chainlink fence and were accessible only through a gate. Its latch was broken so it would not shut and hold properly. No lifeguard was on duty and there was a sign posted that children under 14 years of age should not use the pool without being attended by an adult.

On July 18, 1973, plaintiff, his wife, their five children and two guests were staying in his trailer, which was parked about 100 yards from the swimming pool. That afternoon, Mrs. Butler, the children and the guests had all gone swimming. Mr. Butler was occupied repairing the refrigerator in the trailer. They all returned from the pool and had dinner. At about 7:00 p.m., the older daughters of the plaintiff, between ten and fifteen years of age, returned to the pool. The deceased, Gerald Jr., and his sister Susie went to play in the swing area, which is a short distance from the pool. Plaintiff went back to repairing the refrigerator while his wife did the dinner dishes. Around 7:15 Susie returned to the trailer without Gerald Jr., who was going to stay at the swings a while longer. Shortly thereafter, as the older children were returning from the pool, plaintiff's wife yelled down to them, asking if Gerald Jr. was with them, to which they replied no. They then returned to the trailer.

When Gerald Jr. did not appear within a few minutes, the family became concerned and began searching for him. Plaintiff went to check the swimming pool, but says he could see nothing because of the murkiness of the water. After they looked everywhere else without finding him, they returned to the pool, with Mr. Wendell A. Davis, the then President of defendant. As they were looking at the water, they saw Gerald Jr.'s shirt rise to the surface. Plaintiff dove in and found the body of his son lying on the bottom. All efforts to revive him failed.

Based on the foregoing, plaintiff contends that there are disputed issues of material fact, i.e., as to the defendant's negligence and its causation of the drowning, which should have precluded the granting of the motion for a summary judgment.

The framers of our constitution recognized that access to the courts for the settlement of disputes is essential to a well ordered society. Art. I, Sec. 11 of our Constitution provides:

Courts open--Redress of injuries. All courts shall be open, and every person, for any injury done to him in his person, property or reputation, shall have remedy by due course of law, which shall be administered without denial or unnecessary delay; . . ..

We agree that the mere privilege of filing an action only to be summarily rejected and turned out of court may not seem to give much substance to that constitutional assurance to one who seeks an adjudication on and redress for a wrong he claims to have suffered. Nevertheless, the party so accused (defendant) likewise has rights to be asserted and protected. Among these are the right to move for a summary judgment, which challenges the...

To continue reading

Request your trial
7 cases
  • Wycalis v. Guardian Title of Utah
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Utah
    • 29 Agosto 1989
    ..."doubt or uncertainty as to the questions of negligence ... should be resolved in favor of granting ... a trial." Butler v. Sports Haven Int'l, 563 P.2d 1245, 1246 (Utah 1977). See also Anderson, 671 P.2d at 172; Rees v. Albertson's, Inc., 587 P.2d 130, 133 (Utah With the foregoing standard......
  • White v. Deseelhorst
    • United States
    • Supreme Court of Utah
    • 16 Agosto 1994
    ...as to the defendant's negligence under the circumstances." Wycalis, 780 P.2d at 825 (citations omitted); see also Butler v. Sports Haven Int'l, 563 P.2d 1245, 1246 (Utah 1977). We first examine the applicability of Utah's inherent risks of skiing statute. The statute provides that "no skier......
  • English v. 1st Augusta Ltd.
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Southern District of Georgia
    • 10 Julio 1985
    ...Ga.App. 330, 331-32, 154 S.E.2d 659, 661 (1967); Knowles v. Larue, 102 Ga.App. 350, 116 S.E.2d 248 (1960); Butler v. Sports Haven International, 563 P.2d 1245 (Utah S.Ct. 1977); Kandrach v. Chrisman, 63 Tenn.App. 393, 473 S.W.2d 193, 198 (1971); Lynch v. Motel Enterprises, Inc., 248 S.C. 49......
  • Spafford v. Granite Credit Union
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Utah
    • 25 Noviembre 2011
    ...or even contend that any ruling of the trial court violated settled appellate law. They cite Butler v. Sports Haven International, 563 P.2d 1245 (Utah 1977), a negligence case that applies a light constitutional patina to common rules of summary judgment. See id. at 1246–47. Butler states [......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT