Cassidy v. Angell
Citation | 12 R.I. 447 |
Parties | JOHN CASSIDY, Administrator, v. WILLIAM H. ANGELL, Town Treasurer of North Providence. |
Decision Date | 26 July 1879 |
Court | United States State Supreme Court of Rhode Island |
When a plaintiff sues for injuries caused by the negligence of another, and his own case shows contributory negligence, he may be nonsuited, otherwise his case should be submitted to a jury.
A. was found fatally injured in an excavation in a highway. All that was known of the matter was that he had been seen walking along the highway in his usual manner. A.'s administrator sued the town, alleging that the negligence of its authorities resulted in A.'s death.
Held, that the case should be submitted to a jury and that the jury should consider A.'s habits as to temperance and caution, and his acquaintance with the locality, in deciding whether he had exercised reasonable care.
PLAINTIFF'S petition for a new trial.
The plaintiff sues as administrator of one Martin O'Malley claiming that O'Malley's death resulted from the negligence of the town of North Providence, in leaving one of the highways of the town in a dangerous condition and without proper guards. It appears from the record that the town authorities were cutting down a steep ascent on the Wilbur Hill road. The roadway had been excavated and was impassable but a foot-path remained along the side of the pit which had been made in blasting and digging. This path was used daily by persons passing up and down the hill. The last work done on the afternoon before O'Malley was injured was to throw blasted stone out of the pit on to the foot-path. A part of this stone was removed, but enough remained to obstruct the path. No lights were hung out and the roadway above and below the excavated spot was not completely barricaded. The accident happened on the night of January 19, 1871.
John Barnes testified before the jury:
As O'Malley did not return home his family became alarmed, went out to obtain information of his whereabouts and found him lying at the bottom of the excavation with a severe wound on the back of his head. O'Malley died a few days afterwards from the results of the wound.
No other evidence as to the occurrence was produced or is obtainable.
O'Malley knew about the excavation and was accustomed to pass by it in going to and from his work.
On this state of proof the presiding justice nonsuited the plaintiff, who excepted and brought this petition.
James M. Ripley, Albert R. Greene & Charles Bradley, for plaintiff.
James C. Collins, for defendant.
In this case after the plaintiff had put in his evidence he was nonsuited on the ground that he had produced no evidence to show that the deceased was in the exercise of ordinary care. And the defendant claims that this...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Duggan v. Bay State St. Ry. Co.
...615, 5 Sup. Ct. 1125, 29 L. Ed. 224;Northern Pacific R. R. v. Freeman, 174 U. S. 379, 19 Sup. Ct. 763, 43 L. Ed. 1014;Cassidy v. Angell, 12 R. I. 447, 448, 34 Am. Rep. 690;Denver City Tramway v. Cobb, 164 Fed. 41, 90 C. C. A. 459, 461;Baltimore & Ohio R. R. v. Whitacre, 35 Ohio St. 627, 630......
-
Ames v. Waterloo & C.F. Rapid Transit Co.
... ... of ordinary intelligence will not purposely expose himself to ... danger." Cassidy v. Angell , 12 R.I. 447 (34 Am ... Rep. 690) ... Discussing ... the same proposition, the New York court says: "The ... onus ... ...
-
Dunlap v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Company
... ... v. Deselms, 18 Okla. 108; Bradbury ... v. City, 80 Conn. 298; Hyde v. Mendel, 75 Conn ... 140; Railroad v. Webb, 116 Ga. 152; Cassidy v ... Town, 12 R. I. 447; Carpenter v. Town, 107 Wis ... 555; Powell v. Railroad, 125 N.C. 372; Hopkinson ... v. Co., 92 Iowa 330; Kern v ... ...
-
Lunde v. Cudahy Packing Co.
...814;Lymen v. R. R. Co., 66 N. H. 200, 20 Atl. 976, 11 L. R. A. 364;Penn. R. R. Co. v. Weber, 76 Pa. 157, 18 Am. Rep. 407;Cassidy v. Angell, 12 R. I. 447, 34 Am. Rep. 690;Johnson v. R. R. Co., 20 N. Y. 65, 75 Am. Dec. 375; R. R. Co. v. Landrigan, 191 U. S. 461, 24 Sup. Ct. 137, 48 L. Ed. 262......