City of Philadelphia v. Elliott

• Decision Date: 21 March 1831
• Citation: 3 Rawle 170
• Parties: The Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of PHILADELPHIA v. ELLIOTT, and another, Executors of WILLS.
• Court: Pennsylvania Supreme Court

3 Rawle 170

The Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of PHILADELPHIA v. ELLIOTT, and another, Executors of WILLS.

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.

March 21, 1831

A bequest to a corporation, not for its general purposes, but in trust for particular objects within the scope of its corporate duties, is good.

Therefore a bequest to the Mayor and Corporation of the City of Philadelphia, in trust to purchase a lot of ground, and erect thereon a hospital for the relief of the indigent blind and lame, and to manage and regulate the institution, & c. is a good and valid bequest to the Mayor, Aldermen, and Citizens of Philadelphia, for the purposes, and upon the trusts declared in the will.

IN this cause, a verdict was, by agreement of the parties, rendered for the plaintiffs, for the sum of one hundred thousand dollars, subject to the opinion of the court, whether upon the evidence, the plaintiffs were entitled to recover a residuary bequest contained in the will of James Wills, deceased. If the opinion of the court should be in favour of the plaintiffs, the judgment to be entered on the verdict, was by the agreement, to be released on the defendants' transferring to the plaintiffs certain stocks therein specified. The agreement contained other provisions which it is unnecessary to state.

The decision of the cause turned exclusively upon the question whether the bequest contained in the following clause in the will, was a good and valid bequest, according to the law of Pennsylvania.

" Item. All the rest, residue, and remainder of my estate, real, personal, and mixed, both that which I now hold, and all that I may hereafter acquire, I give and bequeath to the Mayor and Corporation of the City of Philadelphia for the time being, and to their successors in office forever, in trust for the purchase of a sufficient plot of ground in the city of Philadelphia, or in the neighbourhood thereof, and thereon erect, or cause to be erected, suitable buildings and accommodations for an hospital or asylum, to be denominated ‘ The Wills' Hospital for the relief of the indigent blind and lame. ’ The funds thus appropriated are to be put out on good mortgage security, or city stock, and after expending the necessary sum for the lot and improvements heretofore mentioned, the income of the remainder is to be exclusively applied to the comfort and accommodation of as many of the indigent blind and lame, as the income will admit of,...