Clinkscale v. State
Citation | 73 So.2d 244,37 Ala.App. 593 |
Decision Date | 01 June 1954 |
Docket Number | 6 Div. 819 |
Parties | CLINKSCALE v. STATE. |
Court | Alabama Court of Appeals |
Beddow & Jones, Roderick Beddow and Roderick Beddow, Jr. Birmingham, for appellant.
Si Garrett, Atty. Gen., and Jas. L. Screws, Robt. Straub and Arthur Joe Grant, Asst. Attys. Gen., for the State.
Under an indictment charging murder in the first degree, the defendant was convicted of murder in the second degree and punishment was imposed at ten years imprisonment in the penitentiary.
The evidence is undisputed that appellant killed Thomas William Smith by shooting him with a rifle.
Defendant and deceased were brothers-in-law, they having married sisters. They were joint owners of the farm on which they lived in houses a hundred and fifty or two hundred feet apart. Bad feeling had existed between defendant and deceased for some time. Defendant's testimony was to the effect that on several occasions deceased had cursed and abused him and threatened to kill him. At some of these times he either had a pistol in his hand or was holding his hand in his pocket in threatening manner.
He stated that on the morning of the killing defendant was working on his truck parked by his house and deceased was picking up coal about halfway between the two houses. Deceased would stoop over, pick up a little coal, throw it in the bucket and look around at defendant like this (indicating); then he would reach down and pick up another piece of coal. He reached down, got a handful of straw and all at once he grabbed his pistol and said 'Damn you, you ran from me yesterday.' As he was trying to remove the pistol from the front of his clothing his belt broke and the gun fell down in the bib of his overalls. While he was tussling with his pistol he was facing defendant. When the belt broke he caught his gun as it started down in his overalls. It was then that defendant shot at his legs, but just as the shot was fired deceased whirled and fell on his right side. The bullet entered the left hip from the rear.
State's witnesses Miles, who was working as an embalmer and ambulance driver, deputy sheriff Holmes and one Meagher testified there was a freshly torn belt under deceased's body and Miles and Holmes testified there was a pistol in deceased's overall bib.
The record discloses the following during defendant's redirect examination:
'Q. I will ask you to tell these gentlemen whether or not, prior to the date of the 11th of May, 1952, you knew him to be an habitual pistol toter?
'Mr. Thompson: Don't answer. I object.
'The Court: Sustain.
'Mr. Beddow, Sr.: We except.
'The Witness: Am I supposed to answer it?
'Mr. Beddow, Sr.: The judge says 'no.'
'Mr. Thompson: Same objection.
'The Court: Sustain.
'Mr. Beddow, Sr.: We except.'
. 40 C.J.S., Homicide, § 272(d), p. 1225. See also Wiley v. State, 99 Ala. 146, 13 So. 424; Naugher v. State, 116 Ala. 463, 23 So. 26; Cawley v. State, 133 Ala. 128, 32 So. 227; Degro v. State, 34 Ala.App. 232, 38 So.2d 354; Sprinkle v. State, 137 Miss. 731, 102 So. 844; People v. Allen, 378 Ill. 164, 37 N.E.2d 854; Kinder v. Commonwealth, 263 Ky, 145, 92 S.W.2d 8; Gibson v. State, 176 Ga. 384, 168 S.E. 47.
Under the theory of the defense, as gathered from the defendant's testimony before the jury, that the shot was fired under the honest apprehension that def...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Vander Wielen v. State
...Of course, the evidence must also show that defendant had knowledge of the habit of deceased in carrying weapons. Clinkscale v. State, 37 Ala.App. 593, 73 So.2d 244, and cases there cited. As was said in Sims v. State, 139 Ala. 74, 36 So. 138, the 'cases do not go to the extent of supportin......
-
Leigeber v. Boike
... ... This is not the case when the general charge is requested as to each count. Jones v. State, 236 Ala. 30, ... 182 So. 404; Ross v. Washington, 233 Ala. 292, 171 So. 893; Jackson v. State, 33 Ala.App. 42, 31 So.2d 514; Simmons v. McClendon, ... ...
-
Payne v. State, 7 Div. 274
...The deceased had a bad reputation for violence in the community, 1 and had a bad reputation for carrying a pistol. (Clinkscale v. State, 37 Ala.App. 593, 73 So.2d 244). The came in the club shortly before midnight and had a pistol partially concealed in his pocket. The deceased walked over ......
-
Snider v. State
...it was relevant whether appellant knew the deceased was in the habit of carrying a gun. The rule is stated in Clinkscale v. State, 37 Ala.App. 593, 73 So.2d 244: "* * * the general rule is that, where the evidence tends to show that accused might have acted in self-defense, evidence is admi......