Commonwealth Ins. Co. of NY v. O. Henry Tent & Awn. Co.
Decision Date | 05 April 1961 |
Docket Number | No. 13143.,13143. |
Citation | 287 F.2d 316 |
Parties | COMMONWEALTH INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW YORK, The Continental Insurance Company, Milwaukee Insurance Company of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and United States Fire Insurance Company, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. O. HENRY TENT & AWNING COMPANY, a corporation, Defendant-Appellee. |
Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Seventh Circuit |
John P. Gorman, Donald N. Clausen, Herbert W. Hirsh, Jerome H. Torshen, Chicago, Ill., for plaintiffs-appellants.
Morris A. Haft, Haft, Shapiro & Davis, Chicago, Ill., for appellee.
Before HASTINGS, Chief Judge, DUFFY, Circuit Judge, and GRUBB, District Judge.
This is an appeal from a judgment entered in an action for declaratory judgment brought by plaintiffs-appellants to determine the extent of their liability under policies of fire insurance containing a monthly reporting form endorsement. O. Henry Tent & Awning Company (hereinafter referred to as the "Insured") counterclaimed in the suit for the amount of its actual loss. For previous appeals in this case see Commonwealth Insurance Company of New York v. O. Henry Tent & Awning Company, 7 Cir., 1959, 266 F.2d 200 and 7 Cir., 1959, 273 F.2d 163.
On March 31, 1955, The Commonwealth Insurance Company, The Continental Insurance Company, Milwaukee Insurance Company, and United States Fire Insurance Company (hereinafter referred to as the "Insurers") each issued to the Insured an Illinois standard policy of fire insurance with Form No. 111 (Ed. June, 1953) "Multiple Location Reporting Form A, Monthly Average, With Premium Adjustment" attached thereto, for a period of one year, covering stock, materials, and supplies owned by the Insured while located at 3222-24 North Halsted Street, Chicago, Illinois. Total maximum liability in the sum of $50,000.00 was apportioned among the Insurers as follows:
Company Percentage of Limit of Liability ------------------------------------------------------------- The Commonwealth Insurance Company 15% The Continental Insurance Company 15% Milwaukee Insurance Company 35% United States Fire Insurance Company 35%
These policies contain the following provisions:
(Emphasis supplied.)
The Insured has been insured from 1940 through March 31, 1956, under policies of insurance containing a "Value Reporting Clause." The individual Insurers have been carrying the risk, wholly or in part, beginning with the years stated: The Continental Insurance Company, 1940; Milwaukee Insurance Company and United States Fire Insurance Company, 1949; and The Commonwealth Insurance Company, 1953.
On March 28, 1956, a fire occurred at 3222-24 North Halsted Street wherein certain property insured under these policies of an actual value of $32,188.29 was damaged and destroyed. The last report of value prior to the fire was for the month of December, 1955, and was filed on March 21, 1956. It reported a value on the contents located at the insured premises in the amount of $14,360.76. On April 27, 1956, the Insured filed reports of value with the Insurers for the months of January, February, and March, 1956, in the following amounts respectively: $16,726.76, $24,200.44, and $32,188.29. The premium computation in accordance with the Premium Adjustment Clause of the policies in question for the calendar year 1955-1956, resulting in a credit to the Insured, was based on an average value determined by inclusion of the declared March valuation.
At meetings held between the Insurers and the Insured after the fire, the Insurers expressed their willingness to pay to the Insured the amount of $14,360.76, the amount of value last reported prior to the fire, conditioned on a complete release as to further claims by the Insured. On or about February 15, 1957, the Insured filed with the Insurers sworn statements in proof of loss in the amount of $32,188.29, to be prorated among the Insurers according to their respective liability, and made claim for that amount.
Following the fire, the Underwriters Salvage Company of Chicago took custody of the salvageable property pursuant to an Agreement and Direction signed by the Insured's President, B. A. Mendelson. Net return of the proceeds of the salvage is being held in escrow by the salvage company pending determination of ownership and interest...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. Filos, 1-96-0594
...N.E.2d 513 (1964); Spence v. Washington National Insurance, 320 Ill.App. 149, 50 N.E.2d 128 (1943); Commonwealth Insurance Co. v. O. Henry Tent & Awning Co., 287 F.2d 316 (7th Cir.1961). This doctrine is consistently adhered to in other jurisdictions. E.g., Sellers v. Allstate Insurance Co.......
-
Crown Life Ins. Co. v. McBride
...So.2d 282. See also Alaska Foods, Inc. v. American Mfr's Mut. Ins. Co., Alaska 1971, 482 P.2d 842; Commonwealth Ins. Co. of New York v. O. Henry Tent & Awn. Co., 7 Cir.1961, 287 F.2d 316. In other words, while an insurer may be estopped by its conduct from seeking a forfeiture of a policy, ......
-
Collegiate Mfg. Co. v. McDowell's Agency, Inc.
...Company v. Firemen's Insurance Company of New Jersey (1962), 18 Wis.2d 259, 118 N.W.2d 159, 164; Commonwealth Insurance Co. of New York v. O'Henry Tent & Awning, 7 Cir., 1961, 287 F.2d 316, 319; Albert v. Home Fire & Marine Insurance Co. of California (1957), 275 Wis. 280, 81 N.W.2d 549, 55......
-
Unijax, Inc. v. Factory Ins. Ass'n
...So.2d 282. See also Alaska Foods, Inc. v. American Mfr's Mut. Ins. Co., Alaska 1971, 482 P.2d 842; Commonwealth Ins. Co. of New York v. O. Henry Tent & Awn. Co., 7 Cir. 1961, 287 F.2d 316. In other words, while an insurer may be estopped by its conduct from seeking a Forfeiture of a policy,......