Cotton States Life Ins. Co. v. Crozier
Decision Date | 30 June 1927 |
Docket Number | 7 Div. 730 |
Citation | 216 Ala. 537,113 So. 615 |
Parties | COTTON STATES LIFE INS. CO. v. CROZIER. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Appeal from Circuit Court, Etowah County; O.A. Steele, Judge.
Action by Lula Crozier against the Cotton States Life Insurance Company. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant appeals. Transferred from Court of Appeals under Code 1923, § 7326. Reversed and remanded.
Death certificate was evidence only of compliance with requirements of policy.
This action is brought by plaintiff as beneficiary under a policy insuring the life of her adopted mother, Dillie Smith. The policy was issued on September 21, 1925, and the insured died on February 16, 1926.
The policy contains this provision following the insurance clause:
"Provided, however, that no obligation is assumed by this company prior to the date and delivery of this policy nor unless at the time of said delivery the insured is alive and in sound health."
Plea 2 sets up this provision of the policy, and "avers that at the time the policy was delivered the insured was not in sound health, but was afflicted with a serious disease of the heart." A demurrer was sustained to this plea, the grounds of which were as follows:
Plea 4 is as follows:
"For further answer to the complaint the defendant says that the insured made a written application to it for the issuance of said policy, and in said application she stated that she was in sound health, and the defendant avers that at this time she made and signed said application, she was not in sound health, in this, that the insured was then suffering from, and afflicted with, heart disease, and that she knew she was suffering from said disease, and was not in sound health and safely insurable, and that said answer was false, and said insured knew it was false, and it was made by her with intent to deceive, and did deceive, the defendant who relied on said representations in the issuance of said policy."
Demurrer to plea 4 was overruled.
Defendant then filed pleas 5 and 6, setting up the same provision as in plea 2, and averring that the insured in her application for the policy falsely represented that she was then in sound health, when in fact she was afflicted (plea 5) "with heart disease, and that such disease increased the risk of loss to the defendant"; and (plea 6) "with a serious disease of the heart, and that such misrepresentation increased the risk of loss."
Demurrers to these pleas were overruled, and plaintiff replied as follows:
Demurrer to this replication was overruled.
The jury found for the plaintiff, and from the judgment thereon defendant appeals.
Victor Vance, of Gadsden, for appellant.
O.B. Roper, of Gadsden, for appellee.
The provision of the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Commonwealth Life Ins. Co. v. Harmon
... ... National Life & Accident Ins. Co. v. Puckett, 217 ... Ala. 110, 115 So. 12; Cotton States Life Ins. Co. v ... Crozier, 216 Ala. 537, 113 So. 615; New York Life ... Ins. Co. v ... ...
-
New York Life Ins. Co. v. Zivitz, 6 Div. 900.
... ... National ... Life & Accident Ins. Co. v. Puckett, 217 Ala. 110, 115 ... So. 12; Cotton States Life Ins. Co. v. Crozier, 216 ... Ala. 537, 113 So. 615. The evidence is in dispute as to ... ...
-
Liberty Nat. Life Ins. Co. v. Reid
...certificate as to cause of death, while considered prima facie true is conclusive only if unrebutted. Cotton States Life Ins. Co. v. Crozier, 216 Ala. 537, 113 So. 615; Green v. Mutual Ben. Health and Accident Assn., 267 Ala. 56, 99 So.2d 694; National Sec. Ins. Co. of Elba v. Tellis, 39 Al......
-
Independent Life Ins. Co. of America v. Butler, 8 Div. 177.
... ... 289, 67 L. R. A. 631; Cushman v. United States Life ... Insurance Co., 70 N.Y. 72; note 37 C.J. 460, treating ... "Scope and meaning of the word ... Conceding that this ... certificate is evidence under the holding in Cotton ... States Life Ins. Co. v. Crozier, 216 Ala. 537, 113 So ... 615, the most it shows is that the ... ...