Dahnke-Walker Milling Co. v. Bondurant
| Decision Date | 17 October 1919 |
| Citation | 185 Ky. 386,215 S.W. 76 |
| Parties | DAHNKE-WALKER MILLING CO. v. BONDURANT. |
| Court | Kentucky Court of Appeals |
Appeal from Circuit Court, Fulton County.
Action by the Dahnke-Walker Milling Company against C. T. Bondurant. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals. Affirmed.
Robbins & Robbins, of Mayfield, for appellant.
W. J. Webb, of Mayfield, and B. T. Davis, of Hickman, for appellee.
This is an action by the Dahnke-Walker Milling Company against C. T. Bondurant to recover damages for a breach of contract. Upon a former appeal of the case a judgment in favor of the plaintiff was reversed, upon the ground that the contract was unenforceable by the plaintiff, a foreign corporation, because of its failure to comply with section 571 of Kentucky Statutes, and the cause was remanded for a new trial, with directions to direct a verdict for defendant if the evidence should be the same as on the first trial. See Bondurant v. Dahnke-Walker Milling Co., 175 Ky. 774, 195 S.W. 139.
The evidence being the same upon the second trial as upon the first, the trial court, in obedience to the mandate of this court, directed a verdict for the defendant and dismissed the petition, from which judgment the plaintiff has prosecuted this appeal.
Since no question of either fact or law, not decided by our former opinion in this case, is presented by this appeal, and the judgment now appealed from was rendered in obedience to our mandate and in conformity with our view of the law, as fully set forth in that opinion, reported in 175 Ky. 774, 195 S.W. 139, and to which we adhere, it is obvious that the judgment must be, and it is, affirmed.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Milling Co v. Bondurant
... 257 U.S. 282 ... 42 S.Ct. 106 ... 66 L.Ed. 239 ... DAHNKE-WALKER MILLING CO ... BONDURANT ... Reargued and Submitted Oct. 10, 1921 ... Decided. Dec. 12, 1921 ... Page 283 ... Mr. John C. Dollan, of Louisville, Ky., for plaintiff in error ... [Argument of Counsel from page 283-284 intentionally omitted] ... Page ... ...
-
E.C. Artman Lumber Co. v. Bogard
... ... avoidance of the defense, would prevail. We held in the case ... of Bondurant v. Dahnke-Walker Milling Co., 175 Ky ... 774, 195 S.W. 139, that a transaction possessing ... ...
-
Hughes v. R.O. Campbell Coal Co.
... ... Commonwealth v. Eclipse Hay Press Co., 104 S.W. 224, ... 31 Ky. Law Rep. 824; Bondurant v. Dahnke-Walker Milling ... Co., 175 Ky. 774, 195 S.W. 139; Id., 185 Ky. 386, 215 ... S.W. 76; ... ...
-
E. C. Artman Lumber Co. v. Bogard
...involved was not one in interstate commerce. The doctrine of that opinion was adhered to in a second appeal of the same case, reported in 185 Ky. 386, from which an appeal was prosecuted to the Supreme Court of the United States where the case is now pending; and whether our conclusions in ......