Davin v. The Kansas Medical
Decision Date | 11 May 1918 |
Docket Number | 21,282 |
Citation | 103 Kan. 48,172 P. 1002 |
Parties | FANNIE DAVIN, Appellant, v. THE KANSAS MEDICAL, MISSIONARY AND BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION, Appellee |
Court | Kansas Supreme Court |
Decided January, 1918.
Appeal from Sedgwick district court, division No. 2; THORNTON W SARGENT, judge.
Judgment affirmed.
SYLLABUS BY THE COURT.
CHARITABLE HOSPITAL--Not Liable for the Negligence of Its Medical Superintendent. A charitable hospital corporation is not liable in damages for the failure of its medical superintendent to comply with a contract made by him for the care of a patient being treated in the hospital.
Joseph Brubacher, James Conly, and W. P. Campbell, all of Wichita, for the appellant.
David Smyth, and J. W. Smyth, both of Wichita, for the appellee.
The plaintiff commenced this action to recover judgment for personal injuries. Judgment was rendered in favor of the defendant, and the plaintiff appeals.
The defendant is a charitable corporation organized under the laws of this state solely for purely philanthropic and charitable purposes. It conducts a hospital, or sanitarium, at Wichita. The plaintiff was afflicted with melancholia, and was, by her husband, taken to the defendant's hospital. He stayed with her for a couple of days, when he was advised by Dr. Sutter, the defendant's medical superintendent, to go home and stay away from the plaintiff. The husband agreed so to do on condition that a nurse be placed in charge of the plaintiff at all times, and that she be not left alone. To this Dr. Sutter assented. A special nurse was placed in charge of the plaintiff, but the nurse did not remain in the room with the plaintiff at all times. The nurse slept in the hall near the door to the plaintiff's room. While the nurse was so sleeping, the plaintiff got out of her bed, passed through an open window, fell to the roof of a porch below, and injured herself. She brought this action to recover damages for the injuries sustained by her. There was no allegation in the petition and there was no evidence to prove that the defendant did not exercise reasonable care in the employment of its physicians and attendants.
The jury returned a verdict in favor of the plaintiff and answered special questions as follows:
The court set aside the verdict and rendered judgment in favor of the defendant on the facts found by the jury.
The plaintiff says: "The only specification of error is the order sustaining the motion of the defendant for judgment on the special findings." Can the plaintiff recover under the facts found by the jury? In Nicholson v. Hospital Association, 97 Kan. 480, 155...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Sessions v. Thomas D. Dee Memorial Hospital Ass'n
... ... 367; Iowa: ... Mikota v. Sisters of Mercy , 183 Iowa 1378, ... 168 N.W. 219; Kansas: Nicholson v. A., T. & S ... F. Hospital Ass'n , 97 Kan. 480, 155 P. 920, L. R. A ... 1916D, 1029; Davin v. Benevolent Ass'n , ... 103 Kan. 48, 172 P. 1002; Kentucky: Pikeville Meth ... Hospital v ... in the maintenance of hospitals where they might have ... hospitalization and medical care at the lowest possible cost ... Indeed, hospitals, together with churches and schools, are ... ...
-
Rhodes v. Millsaps College
... ... establishes a hospital or medical department from which it ... draws no profit and collects monthly dues from its workmen to ... 130 So. 468 ... Illinois, ... Georgia, Missouri, Kentucky, Kansas, Maine, Maryland, Oregon, ... South Carolina, Wisconsin and Arkansas adhere to the rule of ... 799, 275 P ... 170; Nicholson v. Hospital Assn., 97 Kan. 480, 155 ... P. 920; Davin v. Benevolent Assn., 103 Kan. 48, 172 ... P. 1002; Morrison v. Henke, 165 Wis. 166, 160 N.W ... ...
-
Noel v. Menninger Foundation
...v. Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Hospital Association, 97 Kan. 480, 155 P. 920, L.R.A.1916D, 1029; Davin v. Kansas Medical, Missionary & Benevolent Association, 103 Kan. 48, 172 P. 1002; Webb v. Vought, 127 Kan. 799, 275 P. 170; Ratliffe v. Wesley Hospital & Nurses Training School, 135 Kan. 3......
-
Mississippi Baptist Hospital v. Moore
... ... C. L., page 944; ... Nickolson v. Hospital Association, 97 Kas. 480, 155 ... P. 920; Davin v. Benevolent Association, 103 Kan ... 48; Jordan v. Touro infirmary, 123 So. 731 (La.); ... ...