Department of Health, State of Colo. v. Donahue, 82CA0456

Decision Date30 December 1982
Docket NumberNo. 82CA0456,82CA0456
Citation668 P.2d 946
PartiesDEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, STATE OF COLORADO, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Mamie DONAHUE and State Personnel Board, Defendants-Appellees. . I
CourtColorado Court of Appeals

J.D. MacFarlane, Atty. Gen., Richard F. Hennessey, Deputy Atty. Gen., Joel W. Cantrick, Sp. Asst. Atty. Gen., Anthony Marquez, Asst. Atty. Gen., Denver, for plaintiff-appellant.

James R. Gilsdorf, Denver, for defendants-appellees.

PIERCE, Judge.

The State Department of Health appeals the judgment of the district court affirming an award of the State Personnel Board. The award reinstated Mamie Donahue in her position as Migrant Health Program Director with full back pay. We affirm.

Donahue was employed as a probationary employee in May of 1977 when she was dismissed from her position before obtaining certified status. She was informed of the disciplinary action at a meeting with her supervisor on April 20, 1978, when she was handed a letter, bearing the same date, which advised her of her dismissal. She had no previous notice of the impending dismissal or the allegations against her. At the meeting she did not respond to charges because she believed the decision was irrevocable and had already been made.

Donahue filed a timely appeal with the State Personnel Board, which in turn referred the matter to the Colorado Civil Rights Commission for investigation of Donahue's allegation of unlawful discrimination. On January 6, 1980, in compliance with an order of the hearing officer, Donahue submitted a prehearing statement setting forth the issues to be raised at the hearing. She alleged, among other things, that she had not been given a hearing with the appointing authority prior to the imposition of the dismissal as was required by State Personnel Board Rule 7-3-1.

The final agency decision ruled that discrimination was not involved in her dismissal, but affirmed the hearing officer's holding that the Department had not complied with the State Personnel Board rule. The Board then ordered Donahue be reinstated to her position with full back pay.

The Department of Health complains the issue of compliance with Rule 7-3-1 was not timely raised and that, even if it were, Donahue was not entitled to back pay, less earnings for unemployment compensation received between the time of the discharge and the present. The Department reasons that Donahue was a probationary employee who had no vested right in her employment and could be summarily discharged without cause.

As a general rule, a probationary government employee may be summarily dismissed without a hearing and...

To continue reading

Request your trial
1 cases
  • Department of Health v. Donahue, 83SC91
    • United States
    • Supreme Court of Colorado
    • November 13, 1984
    ...Denver, for respondent. QUINN, Justice: We granted certiorari to review the decision of the court of appeals in Department of Health v. Donahue, 668 P.2d 946 (Colo.App.1982), which held that Mamie Donahue, who was discharged as a probationary employee of the Department of Health without bei......

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT