DeShazo v. Miller
Decision Date | 27 May 1977 |
Citation | 346 So.2d 423 |
Parties | Manon DeSHAZO, III, et al. v. Helen DeShazo MILLER et al. SC 1525. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
S. Eason Balch, Jr., Balch, Bingham, Baker, Hawthorne, Williams & Ward, Birmingham, William E. Hereford, Jr., Gaines, Hereford & Cleckler, Pell City, for appellants.
J. Zack Higgs, Jr., Hornsby, Blankenship, Higgs, Smith & Robinson, Huntsville, for appellees.
The plaintiffs below, who are the appellees here, filed two suits. One of the suits sought to have a sale and division of the lands in the estate of Clara George and the other sought to have a 45-acre tract of land which had been deeded to Manon DeShazo, Jr., declared to be a part of the estate. These cases were combined for trial and were heard ore tenus. This appeal only concerns the trial court's ruling that the deed which conveyed the 45 acres from Clara George to Manon DeShazo, Jr., should be set aside and the 45 acres considered to be part of the Clara George Estate.
The trial court's final decree provided in pertinent part as follows:
After this ruling the defendants below, appellants here, moved for a judgment n. o. v. or in the alternative for a new trial. The denial of these motions is the basis upon which the appellants bring this appeal.
The appellants in this case are the widow and two children of Manon DeShazo, Jr. The appellees constitute all the heirs of Clara George, except for the two children of Manon DeShazo, Jr.
During the time relevant to this suit, Clara George was a widow with no living children or grandchildren. Her closest living relatives were the children of her brother, Manon DeShazo, and their children. It appears that Clara George had great affection for these nieces and nephews as well as for their children. As Clara George progressed in age and began to need the assistance of another in the management of her affairs she turned to her nephew, Manon DeShazo, Jr., who accepted the responsibility of seeing after her interests even though he resided in Tennessee and she in St. Clair County and Jefferson County in Alabama. Manon DeShazo, Jr., had a general power of attorney for Clara George, was listed jointly on her bank accounts, paid her bills, and in general managed her affairs.
On April 19, 1969, Clara George executed a deed which conveyed the 45 acres that is in dispute here to Manon DeShazo, Jr. On the day the deed was executed, Manon DeShazo, Jr., drove Clara George to the office of her long-time attorney and then left. Mrs. George conferred with her attorney, after which the lawyer directed his secretary to prepare a deed which was then signed by Mrs. George and witnessed. Shortly thereafter Manon DeShazo, Jr., arrived and the two left together. The deed was recorded on the same day. Apparently there was no monetary consideration paid by Manon DeShazo, Jr., for this property, which at that time was valued at $70,000.
Clara George was 78 years old when she conveyed this property and resided in a nursing home. Although she had suffered a stroke in 1963, the evidence tends to show that at the time of the conveyance she was mentally competent and completely aware of the nature of her act. Also, it appears that she was in good physical health for someone her age and that the reason she resided in a nursing home was due to convenience rather than necessity.
During this period of time, Clara George was receiving a monthly pension from the Veterans Administration in the amount of $108. In order to be entitled to this widow's pension Mrs. George could not have an annual income in excess of $2,000.
On May 1, 1969, Manon DeShazo, Jr. entered into a long-term lease agreement with A-B Realty Investment Co. whereby the 45 acres here involved were leased for use as a mobile home park. The lease agreement initially called for a monthly rental of $250 with the rental to increase during the term of the lease to a minimum of $500 a month.
Manon DeShazo, Jr., died of a heart attack in April of 1970. Article II of his last will and testament, which was prepared in July 1969, provided for a $200 monthly payment to Clara George for the rest of her life; the remainder of his estate was left to his wife and children.
Clara George died on July 1, 1971, and in her will she devised and bequeathed her estate to her five nieces and nephews or if they were deceased, to their children. The will named Manon DeShazo's widow as the executrix and the son of Manon DeShazo, Jr., as alternate executor. This will was prepared in December of 1970.
During the trial of this case, the trial court was continually called upon by the defendants to rule on the competency of some of the plaintiffs to testify to certain facts under the Alabama Deadman's Statute, Title 7, § 433, Alabama Code of 1940 (Recomp.1958).
This statute provides in pertinent part as follows:
"(N)o person having a pecuniary interest in the result of...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Schoenvogel v. Venator Group Retail, Inc.
...is called in behalf of such interest." 279 Ala. at 630,189 So.2d at 146. Citing Taylor, supra, the Court stated in DeShazo v. Miller, 346 So.2d 423, 426 (Ala.1977): "The following four questions paraphrase this statute and an affirmative reply to each of the questions means that the Deadman......
-
First Nat. Bank of Birmingham v. Chichester
...can be no question but that much testimony of plaintiff falls within the statute as applied and interpreted by the courts. DeShazo v. Miller, 346 So.2d 423 (Ala.1977). Plaintiff contends that defendant waived the statute. Plaintiff says defendants waived the incompetency of plaintiff to tes......
-
Melvin v. Parker
...the suit? "4) Is the interest of the witness opposed to the interest of the party against whom he is called to testify?" DeShazo v. Miller, 346 So.2d 423, 426 (Ala.1977). See, also, Lett v. Watts, 463 So.2d 138, 139 (Ala.1984); Staik v. Jefferson Federal Savings & Loan Association of Birmin......
-
Lavett v. Lavett
...is adverse to the deceased person or his or her estate. See Bank of the Southeast v. Koslin, 380 So.2d 826 (Ala.1980). DeShazo v. Miller, 346 So.2d 423 (Ala.1977). Claude Lavett transferred one acre to Warren in 1975, and Warren reconveyed the property the same day, although the reconveyanc......