Dowler v. Cushwa
| Court | Maryland Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | BOWIE, C.J. |
| Citation | Dowler v. Cushwa, 27 Md. 354 (Md. 1867) |
| Decision Date | 28 June 1867 |
| Parties | JAMES C. DOWLER v. JAMES R. CUSHWA, Insolvent Trustee of JOHN SPRINGER. |
APPEAL from the Circuit Court for Washington County.
This was an action of trover instituted on the 19th of March, 1864, by the appellee, as insolvent trustee of John Springer, against the appellant to recover for the conversion of certain goods and chattels which had belonged to the insolvent, including one-half of the grain growing on the farm of the appellant, and which was occupied by the insolvent as tenant. On the 31st of December, 1859, the insolvent, in consideration of a large indebtedness to the appellant, who was also liable as his security and endorser to a considerable amount, executed to him an absolute bill of sale of his entire personal property. A defeasance was executed on the same day, but not recorded. The property was delivered to the grantee. In March following the grantor applied for the benefit of the insolvent laws, and one Whetstone was appointed trustee. Four years afterward, in March, 1864, the appellee was appointed trustee in the place of Whetstone, and a few days after his appointment instituted this action.
The pleadings and bills of exceptions are sufficiently referred to in the opinion of the Court.
The cause was argued before BOWIE, C.J., BARTOL and CRAIN, J.
Andrew K. Syester and William T. Hamilton for the appellant.
The third and fifth exceptions present questions in connection with the trustee's bond, all of which resolve themselves primarily into this. Did this bond require a revenue stamp? As sustaining the affirmative, the following considerations are respectfully submitted: That bonds of this description are not within the meaning of the Act of Congress of 1st June, 1862, exempting ""bonds required in legal proceedings." "Bonds for the due execution of the duties of any office, and to account for money received by virtue thereof," require stamps. If the term "office," in this connection, should be interpreted to mean only public offices, that is, offices created by law and constituting part of the machinery of Government, it is evident that a large class of bonds given for the due execution and performance of an office, and to account for money received, would not fall within its terms. Such as cashiers of banks. An office may be either public or private. It is defined to be the exercise of a public or private employment. 2 Bla. Com., 36.
The bond in this case is not required by law of the party instituting the ""legal proceedings," but is the bond of the appointee of the Court, to an office, with the due performance of the duties of which the party instituting and conducting the proceeding has nothing to do. It is taken to secure the performance of duties that in no manner affect the proceeding instituted by the applicant, who is discharged or not, and whose proceeding is terminated without the slightest regard to the duties, responsibilities or office of the trustee.
Bonds in legal proceedings are such as the party instituting them is required to give, such as replevin, appeal, injunction bonds, &c., in which proceeding, under another provision, the stamp has already been paid. Without a legal bond the appellee was not, in contemplation of law, a trustee, it is the bond and the perfection of it that gives him authority to sue. Winchester vs. Union Bank of Mary-2 G. & J., 79.
And assuming that this bond ought to have been stamped, it is in proof that it was not stamped at the time of its execution nor afterwards, and being lost, it will be presumed to have continued in the same state, that is unstamped. Closmadeuc vs. Carrel, 18 Com. B., 44, (86 Eng. Com. Law, 43.) And it was the duty of the appellee setting up the bond to have shown that a proper stamp was upon it. Crowther vs. Solomons, 6 Man. Gran. & Scott, 763, (60 Eng. Com. Law, 762.)
The fourth exception was taken to the rejection of evidence. The defendant below offered to prove that before, and at the time of the execution of the bill of sale, Springer was largely indebted to him, and that he (defendant) was responsible to a large amount as surety, &c., for Springer, and also offered to prove the amount of such indebtedness, as also the extent and amount of such responsibility as surety, &c. And in connection with such offer, proffered further proof to show that before his application, Springer actually delivered to him all the property sued for, to be held by him as security to answer such indebtedness, &c. And that this property was in defendant's possession, under that agreement, before and at the time of Springer's application. The offer to show this state of facts was rejected. We insist that it was admissible. The property delivered (the same sued for) was under the agreement, a pledge.
At common law this pledge could not be removed on sale for the pledgor's debt. Nothing but his right to redeem could be sold, the pledge remained with the pledgee. Edwards on Bailments, 205.
In an action brought for the conversion of the pledge, the pledgee shall have the amount of his debt recouped in the damages. Edwards on Bailments, 213, citing Bac. Abr., Bailment B; Jarvis, Adm'r, vs. Rogers, 15 Mass., 389; Stearns vs. Marsh, 4 Denio, 227.
There is nothing in the insolvent system of this State that contravenes this right of the pledge.
For although a trustee may take and sell the pledge, he nevertheless takes it, and must sell it encumbered with the pledgee's demand. Alexander vs. Ghiselin, 5 Gill, 138; Bank of Westminster vs. Whyte, 3 Md. Ch. Dec., 513.
But here he has laid by for four years, and suffered the property to be consumed. It was not only the privilege, but the duty of the trustee to have taken this property, sold it and administered the proceeds with reference, in the first place, to the pledgee's claim; and this should have been done forthwith, (Code, Art. 48.) He now sues, not for the property, but its value, and this value is to go into his hands unmarked by our demand, but generally to creditors. By this means all the substantial rights of the pledgee are nullified, without any default on his part. The defendant had a right to recoup his demand in the damages. Baldwin vs. Porter, 12 Conn., 473-487; Curtis vs. Ward, 20 Conn., 204; Pierce vs. Benjamin, 14 Pick, 356; Whitehall vs. Squire, Carthew, 104; Ewing vs. Blount, 20 Alab., 694; McEmory vs. Dyer, 4 L. R., New Series, 167, 168; Ward vs. Fellers, 3 Mich., 286, 287, 288.
Richard H. Alvey, for the appellee.
On the second, third and fifth exceptions, there being no question as to the sufficiency of the parol evidence of the contents of the bond, it will be contended:
1st. That the proof offered of the execution, approval, filing and loss of the bond, was ample to let in the secondary evidence of its contents; and the defendant, in order to let in evidence of the non-stamping of the bond, having proved the making, approval, filing and loss of said bond, cannot be permitted to raise a question as to the admissibility or sufficiency of the evidence offered by the plaintiff of these facts; for by his own proof, and the assumption upon which he proceeded, he admitted and conceded their truth, and thus established the conditions under which the secondary evidence was admissible. Waters' Lessee vs. Riggin, 19 Md. Rep., 551, 552.
2d. That the parol evidence of the contents of the bond was immaterial, and therefore not injurious to the defendant; for while it is true that an insolvent trustee has no right to sue, or maintain an action, without first executing and filing an approved bond, yet it is only necessary to show that such bond has been filed and approved; and the sufficiency of the contents being matter of law, is not for the consideration of the jury, and therefore immaterial as evidence to them. Winchester, Trustee, vs. The Union Bank of Maryland, 2 Gill & John., 78.
In this case, it being proved by both parties that such bond had been executed, approved and filed, and that it was lost at the time of trial, nothing more was required as evidence to the jury. But the bond having been since found and certified in this record, whereby it is shown that there was such bond, and that it was duly approved and filed, and remains part of a proceeding in a Court of Record; and it thus appearing that no injury could have been done the defendant by the absence of such bond at the trial; this Court would not reverse even if there were error in regard to admitting evidence of the contents of the bond; for if the bond be sufficient, the contents could in no way have influenced the finding of the jury.
3d. That the bond being required in legal proceedings, was not required to be stamped. Act of Cong. of June 1, 1862, schedule B.
But, even if it had been subject to the stamp, by the 163 sec. of the Act of June 30th, 1864, it was made valid and effective by applying the stamp in Court, which was done in this instance from abundant caution. Cooke vs. England, 27 Md. 14.
On the fourth exception it is respectfully urged, that the appellant having previously offered in evidence the bill of sale to sustain the issue on his part, and in the proffer of the proof rejected, referred to such bill of sale as an existing muniment of title that had been accepted by him, of the property therein mentioned, being the same sued for, it was not competent for him, in order to evade the effect of the unrecorded writing in the nature of a defeasance, to pretend that after the making and acceptance of the bill of sale, he took the property by delivery as a pledge, rather than by the bill of sale itself. Having accepted and produced it, he can set up no title subsequently acquired by delivery and of a different character from that conveyed...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Colton v. Dover Perpetual Bldg. & Loan Ass'n of Baltimore
...tends to sustain that position, but that case has not met with approval. See (N. Y. App.) 31 N.E. 1028, 17 L. R. A. 458, note. In Dowler v. Cushwa, 27 Md. 354, this quoted with approval from Van Wagoner v. Gaslight Co., 23 N. J. Law, 291, that: "The rule pervades both bankrupt and insolvent......
-
Hennighausen v. Tischer
...kinds, that the true amount to be recovered by the assignee is the balance found after adjusting claims of each against the other. Dowler v. Cushwa, 27 Md. 354; Marshall v. Cooper, 43 Md. 46; High on 163; Barbour on Set-off, 190; Smith v. Gaslight Co. 31 Md. 12; Penniman v. Loney, 40 Md. 47......