E.E.O.C. v. Board of Trustees of Wayne County Community College, 82-1741
| Decision Date | 21 December 1983 |
| Docket Number | No. 82-1741,82-1741 |
| Citation | 723 F.2d 509 |
| Parties | 33 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. 911, 33 Empl. Prac. Dec. P 33,995, 15 Ed. Law Rep. 132 EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF WAYNE COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE, Defendant-Appellee. |
| Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Sixth Circuit |
Warren Duplinsky, argued and Marcia B. Ruskin, Washington, D.C., Charlie C. Taylor, Librado Gayton, Detroit, Mich., for plaintiff-appellant.
Leonard D. Givens, Miller, Canfield, Paddock & Stone, Thomas Hustoles (argued), Detroit, Mich., for defendant-appellee.
Before MERRITT and JONES, Circuit Judges, HOLSCHUH, * District Judge.
The defendant is a publicly elected college governing board. In this appeal of the District Court's dismissal of plaintiff's age discrimination action against the board, the issue is whether the position of president of Wayne County Community College falls within the exemption for "policymakers" set forth in section 11(f) of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, 29 U.S.C. Sec. 630(f) (1976). 1 We conclude that the position of president does fall within that exemption and therefore affirm the District Court's judgment.
Richard Simmons, Jr. was appointed by the Board of Trustees of Wayne County Community College to a three-year term as president on December 28, 1980. He was subsequently removed from that position by the Board on June 27, 1982. He then filed a charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and the Michigan Department of Civil Rights, alleging that the Board of Trustees had discriminated against him on the basis of his age.
The EEOC sought a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction to prohibit the Board of Trustees from discharging Simmons. In addition, the EEOC filed a complaint alleging that the Board's actions constituted age discrimination in violation of section 4(a) of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, 28 U.S.C. Sec. 623(a) (1976).
The Board of Trustees moved to dismiss the EEOC's complaint under Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b)(6) for failure to state a claim, on grounds that the EEOC lacked subject matter jurisdiction of Mr. Simmons' charge of discrimination because the Age Discrimination in Employment Act specifically exempts policymaking, appointed officials from its coverage. After oral argument the District Court found that 29 U.S.C. Sec. 630(f) does contain an exemption for the position of president of a Michigan community college. The EEOC appeals from the District Judge's dismissal of its action.
The Age Discrimination in Employment Act "prohibit[s] arbitrary age discrimination in employment." Id. Sec. 621. The Act expressly excepts elected public officials, persons appointed by an elected official to his or her personal staff, and persons appointed to the policymaking level or as immediate advisers with respect to the exercise of the constitutional or legal powers of the office. Id. Sec. 630(f). 2 Persons whose positions lie within these parameters are not protected by the Act's prohibitions.
The term "policymaking level" is not expressly defined in the Act or in its legislative history. The EEOC argues that the District Court erred in finding that the president of Wayne County Community College was on a "policymaking level" under the Act. Even construing the policymaking exemption narrowly, however, we conclude that the position of president of Wayne County Community College is on a "policymaking level," and therefore falls within that exemption to the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.
The president is the highest appointed official in the Wayne County Community College District, a political subdivision of the state of Michigan. Even the EEOC analogizes the president's position and function to that of a chief executive officer of a company. The Board of Trustees has defined his role in the broadest of terms:
Under the general direction, and within the authority framework delegated by the Board of Trustees, [the president] executes policies, formulates plans and programs for and directs [the] administration of the College. [The president also] [p]romotes a favorable community environment for the operation of the College and provides broad leadership in attaining the College mission.
Wayne County Community College Job Description, Joint App. at 96. 3 It is manifest that the president has a significant role in the policymaking of the college, and that he is more than a mere administrator with some measure of discretionary power.
In support of its contention that the Wayne County Community College president does not function on the "policymaking level," the EEOC argues that under Michigan law, the policies of the community colleges are to be determined solely by the Board of Trustees of a particular college. The EEOC's analysis is grounded on an overly broad construction of the statute and its meaning, however. It is true that, under the Michigan Community College Act of 1966, Mich.Comp.Laws Secs. 389.1--.195 (1970), the Boards of Trustees have broad authority to direct and govern the community colleges. See, e.g., id. Sec. 389.121 (). Nevertheless, policymaking is not a zero-sum game. The exercise by the board of extensive policymaking power does not preclude, and in fact is complementary to, the concurrent exercise of wide-ranging policymaking authority by the president as the highest appointed official of the college. The fact that there exist some decisions that the president cannot, or would not choose, to make alone, does not diminish the very significant policymaking power that he possesses. The EEOC's argument to the contrary is tantamount to saying that because the chief executive officer of a company must obtain the approval of the board of directors before proceeding with some policies that he has determined are in the company's best interests, he is not a policymaker. Such an analysis is disingenuous and plainly wrong.
As a further twist on this line of analysis, the EEOC cites a recent Opinion of the Michigan Attorney General for the proposition that the Board of Trustees cannot legally delegate its powers to make policy affecting the college, and therefore cannot appoint a person to a "policymaking level" as that term is used in the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. Again, the EEOC's interpretation is wide of the mark, in part because it fails to take account of the limited nature of the Attorney General's inquiry.
The Opinion was confined to consideration of the following question:
May the board of trustees of a community college delegate to the president or other officers of the community college the power to...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Gregory v. Ashcroft
...on the policymaking level. See, e.g., EEOC v. Reno, 758 F. 2d 581 (CA11 1985) (assistant state attorney); EEOC v. Board of Trustees of Wayne Cty. Comm. Coll., 723 F. 2d 509 (CA6 1983) (president of community Petitioners argue that the "appointee[s] on the policymaking level" exception shoul......
-
Costenbader-Jacobson v. Pennsylvania
...Astoria Fed. Sav. and Loan Ass'n v. Solimino, 501 U.S. 104, 111 S.Ct. 2166, 115 L.Ed.2d 96 (1991); E.E.O.C. v. Board of Trustees of Wayne County Cmty. Coll., 723 F.2d 509, 511 (6th Cir.1983). Second, courts look to whether the appointee serves at the pleasure of the appointing authority. St......
-
Stillians v. State of Iowa, 87-1321
...These include: 1) whether the Director has discretionary, rather than solely administrative powers, E.E.O.C. v. Bd. of Trustees of Wayne Cty. Com. Col., 723 F.2d 509, 511 (6th Cir.1983); 2) whether the Director serves at the pleasure of the appointing authority, E.E.O.C. v. Reno, 758 F.2d 5......
-
Chonich v. Wayne County Community College, s. 90-1697
...discriminatory actions were taken by Wayne through an authorized, official policymaker. See EEOC v. Board of Trustees of Wayne County Community College, 723 F.2d 509 (6th Cir.1983).10 The 1991 amendment to Title VII changes the concept of denying damages except for back pay and specific for......