Edelman v. Boeing Air Transport

Decision Date17 April 1933
Docket NumberNo. 571,571
Citation53 S.Ct. 591,77 L.Ed. 1155,289 U.S. 249
PartiesEDELMAN, State Treasurer, et al. v. BOEING AIR TRANSPORT, Inc
CourtU.S. Supreme Court

Messrs. James A. Greenwood, George W. Ferguson, and Richard J. Jackson, all of Cheyenne, Wyo., for petitioners.

Mr. Wm. M. Allen, of Seattle, Wash., for respondent.

Mr. Justice STONE delivered the opinion of the Court.

Respondent, a Washington corporation operating airplanes in Wyoming, brought this suit in equity in the District Court of Wyoming against petitioners, state tax officials, and the cities of Cheyenne and Rock Springs, to enjoin the collection of a state excise tax levied upon the use of gasoline by respondent within the state, as a violation of the Commerce Clause of the Constitution (article 1, § 8, cl. 3). As respondent waived relief by interlocutory injunction, see Smith v. Wilson, 273 U.S. 388, 391, 47 S.Ct. 385, 71 L.Ed. 699, the case was tried before a single judge who upheld the tax and dismissed the case on the merits. 51 F.(2d) 130. On appeal the Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit reversed the decree and directed that the petitioners be enjoined from assessing the tax on gasoline procured by respondent by 'purchases completed outside the State of Wyoming and then brought into that state and used in its planes in interstate commerce.' 61 F.(2d) 319, 324. This Court granted certiorari. 288 U.S. 595, 53 S.Ct. 386, 77 L.Ed. —-.

The statute1 levis a 'license tax of four cents per gallon * * * on all gasoline used or sold in this State * * * for domestic consumption' and requires every 'wholesaler' engaged in the 'sale or use of gasoline' within the state to report to the state treasurer each month all the gasoline 'sold or used' by it in the state, and to pay the tax upon it. Gasoline 'exported or sold for exportation from the State' is exempted from the tax. A 'wholesaler' is defined as any person (1) who 'imports or causes to be imported gasoline * * * for sale in the State * * * to the jobber or consumer, or to the persons * * * who, in turn, sell to the jobber or consumer,' or (2) who 'produces, refines, manufactures, blends or compounds gasoline' in Wyoming 'for use, sale or distribution in this State.' In addition the statute provides that 'every person * * * who shall use any gasoline in this State upon which the said tax has not been paid by any wholesaler in this State,' shall render a like statement and pay a like tax.

Respondent maintains an airplane service for the transportation in interstate commerce of passengers, mail and express with airports at Cheyenne and Rock Springs. It purchases gasoline both within and without the state, which it intermingles and stores in tanks at the two airports. It pays the tax without objection on all gasoline which it sells within the state at its airports or withdraws from the tanks for local use. But it contends, and the court below held, that the tax cannot validly be applied to the gasoline imported from outside the state, stored in tanks at the airports and used for 'filling' the interstate airplanes in which it is eventually consumed.

The opinion below leaves us uncertain whether the injunction was granted upon the ground that the taxing statute does not, in any event, apply to gasoline purchased without the state, if not sold within it, or upon the ground that the taxation of gasoline purchased outside the state and used at respondent's airports to 'fill' its interstate planes, though authorized by the statute, is a prohibited burden on interstate commerce. But the bill of complaint sought no relief on the ground that the statute does not apply to the gasoline so used and no question of the applicability of the tax is argued here. Issue is joined on the only question raised by the pleadings, whether the taxation of the gasoline which respondent withdraws from storage and uses for 'filling' its planes imposes an unconstitutional burden on interstate commerce. Hence we confine our decision to that question.

As the statute has been administratively construed and applied, the tax is not levied upon the consumption of gasoline in furnishing motive power for respondent's interstate planes. The tax is applied to the stored gasoline as it is withdrawn from the storage tanks at the airport and placed in the planes. No tax is collected for gasoline consumed...

To continue reading

Request your trial
104 cases
  • Shell Oil Co. v. State Bd. of Equalization
    • United States
    • California Supreme Court
    • June 6, 1966
    ...themselves. (See also, Nathan v. Louisiana (1850) 49 U.S. (8 How.) 73, 80--81, 12 L.Ed. 993; Edelman v. Boeing Air Transport, Inc. (1933) 289 U.S. 249, 252, 53 S.Ct. 591, 77 L.Ed. 1155; Martin Ship Service Co. v. City of L.A., supra, 34 Cal.2d 793, at p. 799, 215 P.2d For the foregoing reas......
  • Roy Stone Transfer Corp. v. Messner
    • United States
    • Pennsylvania Supreme Court
    • March 24, 1954
    ... ... v. Stone , supra ; Western ... Live Stock v. Bureau of Revenue , supra ; ... Edelman v. Boeing Air Transport, 1933, 289 U.S. 249, ... 53 S.Ct. 591, 77 L.Ed. 1155; Chassaniol v. City ... ...
  • Puget Sound Power Light Co v. City of Seattle, Wash 12 8212 15, 1934
    • United States
    • U.S. Supreme Court
    • March 19, 1934
    ...the tax are not disclosed by the record, no constitutional infirmity in the ordinance is revealed. See Edelman v. Boeing Air Transport, Inc., 289 U.S. 249, 53 S.Ct. 591, 77 L.Ed. 1155; Pacific Telephone & Telegraph Co. v. City of Seattle, supra. 3. Appellant asserts a contract under its fra......
  • State Board of Equalization v. Blind Bull Coal Co.
    • United States
    • Wyoming Supreme Court
    • April 16, 1940
    ...tax upon gasoline, in which the court followed the rule laid down in Superior Oil Company v. Mississippi, supra, are: Edelman v. Boeing Air Transport, Inc., 289 U.S. 249; Nashville R. Co. v. Wallace, 288 U.S. Wiloil Corporation v. Pennsylvania, 294 U.S. 169; Union Stock Yards v. Commission ......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT