Elliott. v. Robert Sutor.
| Court | West Virginia Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | BROWN, President. |
| Citation | Elliott. v. Robert Sutor., 3 W.Va. 37 (W. Va. 1868) |
| Decision Date | 31 July 1868 |
| Parties | William A. Elliott et al. v. Robert Sutor. |
plaintiff "so much of the land in the declaration in controversy as is included in the lines S. P., P. A., A. G. and G. S.," as delineated on the plat of survey made in the cause, is sufficient to warrant a judgment thereon, without finding the character of the estate under which the plaintiff claims. The plaintiff alone has a right to complain and to have the verdict find the character of the estate, when it is in his favor.
surveyor made in the cause, shows that the boundaries and lines as described in the verdict finding for the plaintiff contains nine acres. Held:
1. The report of the surveyor is no part of the verdict, only the lines designated, as shown in the plat.
2. That as the only question in dispute was a common line claimed by the plaintiff and defendant, and the jury having found for the former, it is immaterial whether the quantity be five or nine acres, as the bounds and line claimed in the declaration correspond with the bounds and line found by the jury. No injury could result to the defendant by the variance in the quantity included in the line in dispute.
William A. Elliot, and others, heirs at law of Andrew Young, deceased, brought an action of ejectment in Hancock county, in June, 1860, against Robert Sutor, to recover five acres of land owned by them in fee simple. The declaration averred that they claimed the land by patent from the commonwealth, and that it adjoined certain parties named, and also that it "adjoined with Mathew Ritchie's survey by a line beginning at a white oak and running S. 65° W., 308 poles, and with the same course continued further, 68 poles to William Leclley's line," which was the lino in dispute.
The defendant pleaded not guilty and the statute of limitations. The trial was had at the November term, 1863, when the jury returned a verdict for the plaintiffs, finding that they were entitled to so much of the land in the declaration mentioned as was Who had made a survey in the cause by order of court.
The defendant moved the court to set aside the verdict and grant a new trial upon the ground that it was not in such form and to such effect as was required by the statute, which motion was allowed and a new trial was awarded. At a subsequent-trial a verdict was had for the defendant. On the last trial the plaintiff offered in evidence a deed from one of the prior grantors, which was objected to, because, as alleged, of its defective acknowledgement and recordation, which objection was sustained by the court, and the plaintiff excepted. This latter point is fully set forth in the president's opinion. The court divided on the admissibility of this deed, but the case was determined on other questions. The plaintiff applied to this court for a supersedeas.
Richardson for the plaintiffs in error. Meloin for the defendant in error.
PRown, President. Two questions arise in this cause.
1st. Was the verdict of November 6th, 1863, sufficient to authorize the court to render a judgment on?
The declaration is very loosely and informally drawn, but was not demurred to. In it the plaintiffs substantially complain of the defendant, for that they were possessed of five acres of laud in fee simple, in Yohogania county, viz in Hancock by virtue of a patent from the commonwealth 39 of Virginia, bounded by lands of William Ledley, Campbell Gibbs and Ritchie, and being so possessed thereof in fee simple, the defendant entered on said land and premises and unlawfully withheld the same from them, to their damage, &c. The defendant pleaded not guilty of unlawfully withholding the premises claimed by the plaintiffs in the declaration mentioned, also the statute of limitations of fifteen years. Issues were joined on the pleas. And the jury found a verdict in the following words:
Thereupon the defendant moved the court in arrest of judgment, because, as he alleged, the verdict was not in conformity with the 27th section of chapter 135 of Code 18G0, in that it did not specify the estate found in the plaintiff's. And upon consideration of said motion the court was of opinion no judgment ought to be rendered on said verdict and set it aside for that cause and awarded a venire de novo. An additional objection is taken here, viz: that the plaintiffs in their declaration only claim five acres, while the report of the surveyor Atkinson, which accompanies the plat referred to in the verdict, shows the verdict includes nine acres. To this objection there are two answers. 1st. The report is no part of the verdict, only the lines S. P., A. G. and G. S., as shown on the plat. 2d. The report and plat, if looked to, show that the plaintiff's and defendant claimed under different grants having a common lino, and the only question in dispute was whether that line was as claimed by the one or other of them, and the jury found it as claimed by the plaintiff's, and whether, therefore, the quantity as supposed in the declaration be five or nine acres it was wholly immaterial, as the bounds and line claimed in the declaration correspond with the bounds and line found by the jury.
The land and line claimed being the same as the land and line found in the verdict no injury could possibly result to the defendant by the variance in the quantity included by the line in dispute. I think, therefore, that there is nothing in the objection taken here for that immaterial variance. Next as to the insufficiency of the verdict, as held by the circuit court; it will be observed that the declaration avers the plaintiffs were possessed in fee simple not of live acres only but also of the land or premises, of which the description and bounds had been given, and that the defendant entered and unlawfully withheld the same from the plaintiffs, to which the defendant pleaded that ho was not guilty of unlawfully withholding the premises claimed by the plaintiffs in their declaration mentioned. Here then was the issue distinct, and the jury were sworn to try it; and the verdict is responsive to every material part of it, viz: 1st. It finds the defendant guilty. Guilty of what? Of unlawfully withholding from the plaintiffs the "land and premises in the declaration mentioned." But what land and premises did the plaintiffs mention in their declaration? That which they described and of which they there claimed to have been possessed in fee simple, and upon which the defendant entered and unlawfully withheld from them.
2d. The verdict "further finds for the plaintiffs so much of the land in the declaration mentioned as is included in the lines S. P., A. G. S., as delineated on the plat, &c." Here the declaration claims title in fee simple in the land described. The verdict finds for the plaintiffs the land in the declaration mentioned.
In the case of McMurray vs. O'Neal, 1 Call, 246, it was held that a verdict in ejectment in these words: "We find for the plaintiff one cent damage," was properly amended by the court and made to read:" We find for the plaintiff the lands in the declaration mentioned and one cent damage." If it were competent in that case to refer the finding to the land in the declaration mentioned, why not in this to the estate in the declaration mentioned. If it were competent in that case to interpolate the land and...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Russell v. Webb
...by reference to monuments upon the ground or to some recorded map or by some well known and understood manner of location. Elliott v. Sutor, 3 W.Va. 37; Myers v. Ford, 9 W.Va. 184; v. Casselberry, 47 Pa. 376; Meier v. Meier, 105 Mo. 411, 16 S.W. 223; Leprell v. Kleinschmidt, 112 N.Y. 364, 1......
-
Berger v. Jonesboro Motor Co.
...Id. 612; 68 Id. 580; 50 Id. 506, 94 Id. 548; 2 Bibb 178; 4 Dana 271; 1 Tex. 93; 22 Enc. Pl. & Pr. 877. The verdict is sufficiently certain. 3 W.Va. 37; 9 W.Va. 184; Pa.St. 376; 105 Mo. 411; 112 N.Y. 364; 15 Cyc. 166. Where the only issue is the amount due, an assessment of the value of the ......
-
Lewis and Frazier v. Childers
...a; 1 Lev. 66; 6 Rand 118; 2 Gratt. 193; 14 Gratt. 287; 2 Bibb 150; Id. 236; 2 Wheat. 221; Hemp. 184; 1 W.Va. 1; 2 Wheat. 306; 14 How. 240; 3 W.Va. 37; Humph. 3; 4 B. Mon. 5; W.Va. 427; 20 Wend. 635; 42 Barb. 585; Bul. N. P. 110; 11 Gratt. 84. OPINION HAYMOND, JUDGE. In February, 1872, the p......
-
Lewis v. Childers
...1 Lev. 66; 6 Rand 118; 2 Gratt. 193; 14 Gratt. 287; 2 Bibb 150; Id. 236; 2 Wheat. 221; Hemp. 184; 1 W. Va. 1; 2 Wheat. 306; 14 How. 240; 3 W. Va. 37; Humph. 3; 4 B. Mon. 5; 2 W. Va. 427; 20 Wend. 635; 42 Barb. 585; Bul. N P. 110; 11 Gratt. 84. Haymond, Judge, delivered the opinion of the Co......