Ferber v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue
Decision Date | 07 May 1954 |
Docket Number | Docket No. 35462. |
Citation | 22 T.C. 261 |
Parties | FERBER, DECEASED, THE PENNSYLVANIA COMPANY FOR BANKING AND TRUSTS, CO-EXECUTOR, PETITIONER, v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, RESPONDENT. |
Court | U.S. Tax Court |
OPINION TEXT STARTS HERE
CAPITAL ASSETS.—SEC. 117(a)(1), I. R. C.—EXECUTIOR LIQUIDATING FURS OF A RETAIL STORE.—Auction and bulk sales of furs made by executors of retail fur dealer were of capital assets and produced capital gains. John B. Leake, Esq., and Stephen T. Dean, Esq., for the petitioner.
Charles J. Hickey, Esq., for the respondent.
The Commissioner determined deficiencies in income tax against the estate of Jacques Ferber of $18,329.36 and $6,551.46 for its taxable years ended February 28, 1947, and February 29, 1948. The issue for decision is whether the estate realized ordinary income or capital gain from auction and bulk sales during the taxable years of furs and fur garments which were part of the decedent's estate.
Jacques Ferber died on November 30, 1945. His executors filed fiduciary income tax returns for the taxable years with the collector of internal revenue for the first district of Pennsylvania.
Ferber, as sole proprietor, had operated a retail fur store known as Jacques Ferber in Philadelphia. He provided in his will that his executors could sell the business to his nephew under certain conditions, but the executors promptly concluded that the nephew did not have sufficient funds to make the purchase and they immediately decided to liquidate and dispose of the business and its assets as rapidly as possible without loss to the estate. The furs and fur garments which came into the hands of the executors were valued as a part of the decedent's estate at $233,634.35.
The executors, in their efforts to liquidate, endeavored to dispose of the business as a whole and to dispose of the merchandise in large lots. They continued in those efforts until they had disposed of all the merchandise. They kept the store open for the purpose of preserving the value and good will of the business and as a means of selling some of the finished garments while they searched for a buyer for the entire business or for goods in large lots. They were unable to find a purchaser who would buy the whole business, including all of the merchandise, but they sold the business name, the furniture, fixtures, and some of the furs and leased the store premises in August 1946. Thereafter, the executors took no part in the operation of the retail store.
The executors used inventories in computing those net profits.
The executors, after disposing of the store in August 1946, had merchandise in their hands which had a basis of $179,118. They attempted to sell that merchandise in bulk through a firm which regularly conducted auction sales in New York and were advised that it was too large a quantity for 1 sale and 3 auction sales would produce better results. Auction sales were held on October 16, 1946, January 29, 1947, and in December 1947 at each of which substantial quantities of the merchandise were sold. Some skins were sold to a dealer in New York City, some furs were sold to a wholesaler in New York City, and the remainder of the merchandise, including odds and ends, was sold to the persons who had bought the store.
The sales through the auctions and the other sales mentioned in the preceding paragraphs were reported on the returns for the taxable years in separate amounts, the totals of which were as follows:
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+ ¦Year¦Basis ¦Sale price ¦Long-term gain¦50% reported as Income¦ +----+----------+-----------+--------------+----------------------¦ ¦1917¦$88,201.00¦$131.000.00¦$42,799.00 ¦$21,399.50 ¦ +----+----------+-----------+--------------+----------------------¦ ¦1918¦90,917.00 ¦117,183.08 ¦26,266.08 ¦13,133.04 ¦ +-----------------------------------------------------------------+
The Commissioner, in determining the deficiencies, held that the entire amount of the gain thus reported was ordinary income and added to income the 50 per cent which the petitioner had not reported.
The only question for decision in this case is whether the furs sold by the executors after they had disposed of the retail store were capital assets so that the gains from those sales were long-term capital gains, as reported, rather than ordinary business income. The Commissioner sums up his argument as follows:
The executors operated the ratail store, selling the furs at retail, until August, 1946, when the principal fixed assets and some of the furs were sold in bulk. The executors sold the remainder of the furs by consignment sales and privately conducted auctions. These furs were held by the executors as stock in trade, or merchandise properly includible in...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Factor v. CIR
...See, Adams v. C.I.R., 8 Cir., 1940, 110 F.2d 578, 582-586; Faroll v. Jarecki, 7 Cir., 1956, 231 F. 2d 281, 286-288. See also, Estate of Ferber, 1954, 22 T.C. 261; Pool v. C.I.R., 9 Cir., 1957, 251 F.2d 233, 37 98 C.J.S., Witnesses, ? 477(a) (b), pp. 355-358; 58 Am.Jur., Witnesses, ? 791, pp......
-
Berger v. Commissioner
...v. Commissioner, supra, and we do so here. See Lawrie v. Commissioner [Dec. 25,042], 36 T.C. 1117 (1961); Estate of Ferber v. Commissioner [Dec. 20,321], 22 T.C. 261 (1954); Grace Bros., Inc. v. Commissioner [Dec. 16,227], 10 T.C. 158 (1948), affd. [49-1 USTC ¶ 9181] 173 F.2d 170 (9th Cir. ......
-
Berry Petroleum Co. v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue, 28578-91.
...entities, C.J. Co. being successor to Teorco's property but not to the character of that property. See Estate of Ferber v. Commissioner, 22 T.C. 261 (1954) (decedent's inventory became a capital asset when acquired by his estate). 49. The facts of this case are in contrast to a situation in......
-
Greenspon v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
...297; Garrett v. United States, 128 Ct.Cl. 100, 120 F. Supp. 193; Boomhower v. United States, D.C.N.D.Iowa, 74 F.Supp. 997; In re Estate of Jacques Ferber, 22 T.C. 261. There are also cases reaching the contrary conclusion, such as Richards v. Commissioner, 9 Cir., 81 F.2d 369, and Ehrman v.......