Fleming v. Clark Tp. of Chariton County
Decision Date | 11 June 1962 |
Docket Number | No. 1,No. 48829,48829,1 |
Citation | 357 S.W.2d 940 |
Parties | C. A. FLEMING et al., a Partnership, d/b/a Fleming & Son Maufacturing Company, Respondents, v. CLARK TOWNSHIP OF CHARITON COUNTY, Missouri, Appellant |
Court | Missouri Supreme Court |
James J. Wheeler, Keytesville, Missouri, for appellant.
Arthur M. O'Keefe, Moberly, C. B. Burns, Jr., Brookfield, for respondents.
This is an appeal from a judgment ordering a judgment to be entered reviving a previous judgment. We have jurisdiction because Clark Township, an organized township of Chariton County with township organization, is a party. See Missouri Township, Chariton County v. Farmers' Bank of Forest Green, 328 Mo. 868, 42 S.W.2d 353, transferred 12 S.W.2d 763.
Application for revival of a judgment obtained against defendant on October 16, 1939, was filed on October 13, 1949, by G. A. Fleming as sole survivor of the partnership of himself and B. S. Fleming under the name of Fleming & Son Manufacturing Company, original plaintiffs, joined in by H. E. Trader, assignee of the judgment who asked that it be revived either in his name or in the name of the surviving partner. Scire facias was issued and hearing held by Honorable V. C. Rose, assigned as Special Judge to hear the case, after which the following judgment was entered:
No decree was filed but on March 24, 1961, a motion was filed by G. A. Fleming stating that on April 14, 1951, a judgment was rendered by Judge Rose, 'decree to be filed by plaintiff'; that 'no decree was filed'; and that 'plaintiff now moves the Court to enter its decree and judgment in said case.' Honorable Samuel E. Semple, assigned as Special Judge to hear this motion, ordered it sustained on April 7, 1961, and a judgment and decree was entered reviving the judgment of October 16, 1939, in the name of G. A. Fleming, from which defendant appealed.
The judgment ordered entered March 24, 1961, was as follows:
'WHEREFORE: It is ordered, decreed and adjudged that the judgment heretofore entered on the 16th day of October, 1939, by this court against Clark Township of Chariton County, Missouri, is revived in the name of plaintiff G. A. Fleming in the amount of $979.87 for debt and damages and $321.85 for costs as heretofore appears in the records of this court.'
Over defendant's objection, at the 1961 hearing, plaintiff introduced oral testimony of the attorney for plaintiff at the 1951 hearing, who said the decree referred to was never prepared and who explained the reason for the provision in the decree finding void an assignment to H. E. Trader. (He said the assignment to Trader was for the purpose of having one suit brought on several claims by him and that this case had been dismissed.) It was stipulated by the parties at the 1961 hearing that Trader was deceased but the date of his death does not appear.
Both parties consider the 1961 order as a nunc pro tunc entry. Defendant contends the record entry of April 14, 1951, was not a valid judgment and says it does not support the judgment ordered March 24, 1961. Defendant also says the judgment of March 24, 1961, is in conflict with the...
To continue reading
Request your trial