Flowers v. Stringer, 27580

CourtUnited States State Supreme Court of Mississippi
Writing for the CourtGRIFFITH, J.
Citation120 So. 198,152 Miss. 897
PartiesFLOWERS v. STRINGER et al. [*]
Docket Number27580
Decision Date04 February 1929

120 So. 198

152 Miss. 897

FLOWERS
v.
STRINGER et al. [*]

No. 27580

Supreme Court of Mississippi

February 4, 1929


Division B

1. AUTOMOBILES. Finding that truck driver was not responsible for collision with automobile held against weight of evidence.

Finding of jury that truck driver operating truck at an excessive speed, and while he was drinking, was not responsible for collision with automobile, held against the overwhelming weight of the evidence.

2. DAMAGES. Finding that automobile passenger was not injured in collision with truck held against weight of evidence.

Finding of jury that automobile passenger was not injured in collision between automobile and truck held against weight of evidence.

HON. A. B. SCHAUTBEB, Special Judge.

APPEAL from circuit court of Smith county, HON. A. B. SCHAUBER, Special Judge.

Suit by Mrs. John Flowers against Ed Stringer and others. From the judgment, plaintiff appeals. Reversed and remanded.

Reversed and remanded.

Collins & Collins and E. M. Lane, for appellant.

R. S. Tullos and J. D. Martin, for appellees.

OPINION

[152 Miss. 898] GRIFFITH, J.

This suit grew out of a collision between a passenger automobile driven by John Flowers, the husband of appellant, and an automobile truck driven by the appellee Little. The passenger automobile was going west, and had arrived at a point near the intersection with a road coming in from a northwesterly direction. The appellee Little was driving from the northwest at a high rate of speed, and he turned eastwardly at the intersection aforesaid into the east and west road, in such a manner and at such a rate of speed as to swing too far to his left, and, as a consequence, collided with the Flowers car about four feet from the north bank of the east and west road. That the collision was within four feet of the north bank of the east and west road is shown by the clear and emphatic testimony of three of the four eyewitnesses, two of them disinterested, and by the undisputed physical fact that, immediately after the collision, the engine of the truck was within four feet of the north bank, or, as it was expressed, it was near enough that the witnesses could step from the engine of the truck to the said bank. The appellee Little admits that he was drinking, and the testimony was undisputed that he turned the sharp curve aforesaid at a speed greater than that allowed by law in turning such curves. It is established, therefore, that in...

To continue reading

Request your trial
13 practice notes
  • Mississippi Power & Light Co. v. Smith, 30745
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • March 12, 1934
    ...Moore v. Johnson, 103 Va. 88; M. & O. R. v. Johnson, 141 So. 581; M. & O. Railroad v. Bryan, 132 So. 539; Flowers v. Springer, 120 So. 198, 152 Miss. 897; Newton v. Homochitto Lbr. Co., 138 So. 564, 162 Miss. 20. The breaking of the belt was not the proximate cause of the injury. R.......
  • Meridian Amusement Concession Co. v. Roberson, 33973
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • January 29, 1940
    ...O. R. R. Co. v. Johnson, 141 So. 581, 165 Miss. 397; M. & O. R. R. Co. v. Bryant, 132 So. 539, 159 Miss. 528; Flowers v. Springer, 120 So. 198, 152 Miss. 897; Newton v. Homochitto Lbr. Co., 138 So. 564, 162 Miss. 20; C. & G. Ry. Co. v. Buford, 116 So. 817, 150 Miss. 832; M. & O.......
  • Mississippi Public Service Co. v. Scott, 32501
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • May 31, 1937
    ...witnesses on this issue. The undisputed physical facts sustain appellants' theory and condemn that of the appellee. Flowers v. Stringer, 152 Miss. 897, 120 So. 198; Thomas v. Fribelman, 164 Miss. 699, 145 So. 607; M. & O. R. R. Co. v. Johnson, 165 Miss. 397, 141 So. 581; C. & G. R. ......
  • Greer v. Pierce, 30336
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • March 20, 1933
    ...Mobile & Ohio Railroad Co. v. Johnson, 141 So. 581; Mobile & Ohio Railroad Company v. Bryant, 132 So. 539; Flowers v. Springer, 120 So. 198. Where evidence supporting verdict is against weight of the evidence, trial judge may grant new trial, but cannot direct verdict for adverse pa......
  • Request a trial to view additional results
13 cases
  • Mississippi Power & Light Co. v. Smith, 30745
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • March 12, 1934
    ...Moore v. Johnson, 103 Va. 88; M. & O. R. v. Johnson, 141 So. 581; M. & O. Railroad v. Bryan, 132 So. 539; Flowers v. Springer, 120 So. 198, 152 Miss. 897; Newton v. Homochitto Lbr. Co., 138 So. 564, 162 Miss. 20. The breaking of the belt was not the proximate cause of the injury. R.......
  • Meridian Amusement Concession Co. v. Roberson, 33973
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • January 29, 1940
    ...O. R. R. Co. v. Johnson, 141 So. 581, 165 Miss. 397; M. & O. R. R. Co. v. Bryant, 132 So. 539, 159 Miss. 528; Flowers v. Springer, 120 So. 198, 152 Miss. 897; Newton v. Homochitto Lbr. Co., 138 So. 564, 162 Miss. 20; C. & G. Ry. Co. v. Buford, 116 So. 817, 150 Miss. 832; M. & O.......
  • Mississippi Public Service Co. v. Scott, 32501
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • May 31, 1937
    ...witnesses on this issue. The undisputed physical facts sustain appellants' theory and condemn that of the appellee. Flowers v. Stringer, 152 Miss. 897, 120 So. 198; Thomas v. Fribelman, 164 Miss. 699, 145 So. 607; M. & O. R. R. Co. v. Johnson, 165 Miss. 397, 141 So. 581; C. & G. R. ......
  • Greer v. Pierce, 30336
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • March 20, 1933
    ...Mobile & Ohio Railroad Co. v. Johnson, 141 So. 581; Mobile & Ohio Railroad Company v. Bryant, 132 So. 539; Flowers v. Springer, 120 So. 198. Where evidence supporting verdict is against weight of the evidence, trial judge may grant new trial, but cannot direct verdict for adverse pa......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT