From the Heart Church Ministries, Inc. v. African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, 3
Decision Date | 24 July 2002 |
Docket Number | No. 3,3 |
Citation | 370 Md. 152,803 A.2d 548 |
Parties | FROM THE HEART CHURCH MINISTRIES, INC., et al. v. AFRICAN METHODIST EPISCOPAL ZION CHURCH, Mid-Atlantic II Episcopal District, et al. |
Court | Maryland Court of Appeals |
Jack Lipson, (Darryl W. Jackson, Laura K. McNally, Jamellah L. Braddock, Stephen E. Jones, Erica Y. Williams of Arnold & Porter, on brief) Washington, DC, (Robert C. Park, Jr., Midgett S. Parker, Jr., Gerald W. Heller and James E. Gilbert of Linowes and Blocher LLP, on brief) Silver Spring, of counsel, (Steven E. Murray, Gloria J. Matthews, Norman D. Romney, Cecilia R. Jones and Malik O. Ellis of From The Heart Church Ministries, Inc., on brief) Temple Hills, for appellants.
James E. Ferguson, II (James E. Ferguson, III of Ferguson, Stein, Wallas, Adkins, Gresham & Sumter, P.A., on brief) Charlotte, NC, Thomas R. Kline and (Thomas E. Starnes of Thomas L. McCally and Tina Maiolo of Carr, Goodson and Warner, on brief) Rev. John L. Walker of Landover, for appellees.
Argued Before BELL, C.J., ELDRIDGE, RODOWSKY,1 RAKER, WILNER, CATHELL and HARRELL, JJ.
The issue presented in this case involves the ownership of church property after a local church, incorporated under the Maryland Religious Corporations Law, Md.Code (1957, 1999 Replacement Volume) Title 5, Subtitle 3 of the Corporations and Associations Article,2 but affiliated with a religious denomination, terminates that affiliation. The Circuit Court for Prince George's County determined that the church property belonged to the religious denomination. We issued the writ of certiorari to review the issue. We shall reverse.
From The Heart Church Ministries, Inc., one of the appellants ("From The Heart"), was organized in Marlow Heights, Maryland in 1981, as an affiliate of the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, one of the appellees3 ("A.M.E. Zion"). It was organized by Reverend Doctor John A. Cherry, the other appellant, its pastor, to whom A.M.E. Zion had given a Pastor's Certificate of Appointment and whom it had reappointed to that position for every term thereafter until the withdrawal, and the church's 24 members. On May 2, 1983, trustees, who had been elected by the congregation a year earlier, formally incorporated the church under the Maryland Religious Corporations Law, see § 5-304,4 as Full Gospel A.M.E. Zion Church, Inc.5 Its purpose, as stated in the Articles of Incorporation ("charter"),6 was:
Shortly after its incorporation, Full Gospel, on May 13, 1983, purchased "for use in its growing ministry" property located at 5311 St. Barnabas Road in Oxen Hill, Maryland. The deed to that property listed as owner Full Gospel A.M.E. Zion Church, Inc., a Maryland Religious Corporation. Full Gospel subsequently acquired additional, adjacent property, which it also took in its name alone, and, between 1988 and 1999, other real and personal properties, which were similarly titled. None of the deeds to the real properties, nor the documents reflecting ownership of any of the personal property, moreover, contained a clause creating a trust in favor of, or providing for reversion to, A.M.E. Zion, which did not make any direct financial contribution to the purchase of any of the property.
In 1991, Full Gospel's Board of Trustees adopted church By-laws and amended its Articles of Incorporation.8 The By-laws broadened Full Gospel's purpose, stating that it "is to conduct a church for Christian religious activities," as contrasted with the requirement to act "in accordance with the Discipline of the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church." Pursuant to the By-laws, moreover, the trustees were vested with full control of Full Gospel's church property. The By-laws provided that, in furtherance of the church's purpose:
The amendment of the Articles of Incorporation deleted all reference to the A.M.E. Zion denomination. In addition to the same broad statement of purpose as in the By-laws, the amended Articles addressed specifically the disposition of church property on the dissolution of the corporation. As amended, the Articles provided:
"In the event of dissolution or final liquidation of the Corporation, all remaining assets of the Corporation [the church] shall ... be distributed to such organization or organizations organized and operated exclusively for religious, or charitable, or educational purposes as shall at the time qualify as an exempt organization or organizations ... as the Board of Trustees shall determine."
Full Gospel amended its Articles of Incorporation again on June 15, 1998. This amendment adopted the church's present name, From The Heart Ministries, Inc., and provided, consistent with its By-laws, that the church would have all of the general powers of a Maryland corporation, as enumerated in § 2-103 of the Corporations & Associations. Article.9 The 1998 charter amendment, like the predecessor 1991 amendment did with respect to Full Gospel, also expressly authorized From The Heart to distribute its assets and property, upon dissolution or final liquidation, to such charitable organizations as its Board of Trustees should determine. Moreover, the 1998 amendment gave the Board of Trustees full power to act on behalf of the church and to conduct any business matters of the church, to adopt By-laws for the church, and to amend, or promulgate new, Articles of Incorporation for the church.
The A.M.E. Zion Church,10 founded in 1898, is a religious denomination, international in scope, made up of affiliated churches. It's organizational structure is hierarchical, although the church itself characterizes it as "connectional." Under this structure, the affiliated local churches report to one of twelve bishops, who in turn report, quadrennially, every four years, to the General Conference, the governing body of A.M.E. Zion. Comprised of clergy and lay delegates from around the world, the responsibilities of the General Conference include revising the Book of Discipline of the African Methodist Episcopalian Zion Church, A.M.E. Zion's governing policies. Between sessions of the General Conference, A.M.E. Zion is governed by its bishops, who also oversee the various Annual Conferences, which meet yearly to address concerns of the clergy and laity located within the various regions into which the administration of the church is divided.
The rules and regulations of the A.M.E. Zion denomination are codified, and published, in its Book of Discipline of the African Methodist Episcopalian Zion Church. The "Book of Discipline" is published quadrennially. Because they were applicable either when property was purchased or while it was being held prior to From the Heart's disaffiliation, several editions of the Book of Discipline, specifically those dating from 1980 through 1996, are relevant to the resolution of the case sub judice. Given that the applicable provisions of each of those editions are identical and both parties rely only on the 1996 edition of the Book of Discipline, however, we likewise shall restrict our consideration to that edition.
The 1996 Book of Discipline addresses, as did the predecessor and successor editions, the requirement that places held or hereafter acquired by a local church, for the purpose of worship or parsonage, be held in trust for A.M.E. Zion denomination. Paragraph 494 provides:
Under ¶ 493, "[i]t is the duty of the Pastor and Presiding Elder to see that our Church Property is deeded according to our Book of Discipline, and duly incorporated in accordance with the laws of the State or the Territory in...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Heartland Presbytery v. Gashland Presbyterian Church
...nom. Green v. Campbell, –––U.S. ––––, 130 S.Ct. 2088, 176 L.Ed.2d 580 (2010); From the Heart Church Ministries, Inc. v. African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, 370 Md. 152, 803 A.2d 548, 571 (2002) (reversing grant of summary judgment to denomination based on consideration of property prov......
-
Latty v. St. Joseph's Soc'y of The Sacred Heart Inc.
...in questions of religious doctrine, polity, and practice.” From the Heart Church Ministries, Inc. v. African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, Mid–Atl. II Episcopal Dist., 370 Md. 152, 179, 803 A.2d 548 (2002). In explaining why Maryland does not recognize the tort of clergy malpractice, thi......
-
Presbytery of Greater Atlanta, Inc. v. Timberridge Presbyterian Church, Inc.
...or even an attempted return to the unconstitutional “departure from doctrine” approach. From the Heart Church Ministries v. AME Zion Church, 370 Md. 152, 803 A.2d 548, 569–570(III) (2002). Although the majority does consider relevant documents other than the Book of Church Order or the Book......
-
Masterson v. Diocese Texas
...local incorporated church “did not, in fact, consent to the trust provisions” in the national church's Book of Discipline. 370 Md. 152, 803 A.2d 548, 569 (2002). Key to the court's holding was the local church's deletion, many years before the property dispute arose, of a requirement in its......