Fucela's Estate, In re
Citation | 132 N.W.2d 553,26 Wis.2d 476 |
Parties | In re ESTATE of Paul FUCELA, Deceased. Anna FUCELA, Appellant, v. John G. JURSIK, Ex'r of the Estate of Paul Fucela, deceased, et al., Respondents. |
Decision Date | 01 February 1965 |
Court | United States State Supreme Court of Wisconsin |
Stephen J. Hajduch, Milwaukee, for appellant.
Foley, Sammond & Lardner, Edwin F. Walmer and Robert J. Bonner, Milwaukee, for respondents.
The issue on this appeal is, does the widow of a decedent owning shares in a savings and loan association in the form prescribed in sec. 215.14(2), Stats. (1961), have a right to a widow's allowance or other statutory interest in such account which is payable upon death to named third persons.
The following statutes, 1961, are involved:
'215.14 Joint share accounts. (1) * * *
(Emphasis added.)
'313.15 Distribution of estate. When any person shall die possessed of any personal estate or of any right or interest therein, whether disposed of by will or not, the same shall be applied and distributed as follows: * * *
'(2) Allowance to family. The widow and minor children, or either, constituting the family of the deceased testator or intestate, shall have such reasonable allowance out of the personal estate or the real estate, or both, of the deceased as the county court shall judge necessary for their maintenance until an award shall be made or refused as provided in subsection (4)(a) of this section, or their shares assigned to them. * * *
'313.16 Debts; order of payment. (1) If, after the allowance provided for by section 313.15 has been made and after the amount of the claims against any estate shall have been ascertained by the court, it shall appear that the executor or administrator has in his possession sufficient to pay all the debts, he shall pay the same in full within the time limited for that purpose. If the assets received by the executor or administrator, and which can be appropriated to the payment of debts, shall not be sufficient he shall, after paying necessary expenses of administration, pay the debts against the estate in the following order:
'(a) The necessary funeral expenses;
'(b) The expenses of the last sickness;
'(c) Debts having a preference under the laws of the United States or the laws of the state of Wisconsin;
'(d) Wages due to workmen, clerks or servants which have been earned within three months before the date of the death of the testator or intestate, not to exceed three hundred dollars to each claimant;
'(e) Debts due to other creditors.'
This court in Tucker v. Simrow (1946), 248 Wis. 143, 21 N.W.2d 252, held that a savings and checking account payable to a named person at the death of the depositor is ineffectual to pass such account. At page 145, 21 N.W.2d at page 252, Mr. Justice Wickhem, speaking for the court, stated:
In response to a request by the commissioner of savings and loans for an opinion, the attorney general in 38 Op.Atty.Gen. (1949) 343 advised that although a certificate in the name of A payable upon death to B could be issued, it would not be effective to pass ownership to B because it would probably be construed as an invalid attempt to make a testamentary disposition without the formalities required to make a will.
It is apparent that sec. 215.14(2), Stats., was created to remove the prohibition of the Tucker decision. 1
In construing sec. 215.14(2), Stats., within the framework of the statutes pertaining to the probate of estates, consideration should be given to the apparent change of rule sought by sec. 215.14(2). 2 In construing a statute bearing on a particular subject (here the probate of estates), where possible, the related statutes should be interpreted so as to give effect to each provision of the statutes involved. Safe Way Motor Coach Co. v. City of Two Rivers (1949), 256 Wis. 35, 39 N.W.2d 847.
Secs. 313.15 and 313.16, Stats., quoted above, refer to different demands upon estate assets. Sec. 313.15 gives the widow an 'allowance' out of property which is in the estate. Sec. 313.16 refers to payment of debts due to creditors out of assets which are in the estate. Sec. 215.14(2) determines when certain assets are in the estate.
That 'allowances' and 'deb...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Michaels' Estate, In re
...is a statutory exception to sec. 238.06, Stats., the same as is sec. 215.14, Stats., which we were called upon to construe in Estate of Fucela, Wis., 132 N.W.2d 553. We summarize our determination of the issues in this appeal as follows: Legal title to the joint bank savings account passed ......
-
Stryker v. Town of LaPointe
...123; Bornemann v. City of New Berlin (1965), 27 Wis.2d 102, 133 N.W.2d 328; Giese v. Giese, supra, footnote 2.4 Estate of Fucela (1965), 26 Wis.2d 476, 482, 132 N.W.2d 553.5 (1962), 16 Wis.2d 79, 83, 113 N.W.2d ...
-
Hansen Storage Co. v. Wisconsin Transp. Commission, 77-850
...97 S.Ct. 373, 50 L.Ed.2d 320 (1976); we must attempt to give effect to each provision of the related statutes, Estate of Fucela, 26 Wis.2d 476, 480, 132 N.W.2d 553 (1965), and must avoid a construction that creates an absurdity. Volunteers of America v. Industrial Comm., 30 Wis.2d 607, 616-......
-
Bruckner v. Prairie Federal Sav. and Loan Ass'n, 75-692
...(Stats.1973) From the effective date of that statute POD accounts were permissible for state savings institutions (Estate of Fucela, 26 Wis.2d 476, 132 N.W.2d 553 (1965)), but were they also thereafter permissible in federal savings and loan associations doing business in Wisconsin? We conc......