Godley v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue (In re Estate of Godley)
| Decision Date | 19 March 1953 |
| Docket Number | Docket No. 35057. |
| Citation | 19 T.C. 1082 |
| Parties | ESTATE OF IDA S. GODLEY, DECEASED, PAUL F. GODLEY AND JOHN W. YOUNG, JR., COEXECUTORS, PETITIONERS, v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, RESPONDENT. |
| Court | U.S. Tax Court |
OPINION TEXT STARTS HERE
Allen S. Hubbard, Esq., and John Westbrook Fager, Esq., for the petitioners.
Stanley W. Herzfeld, Esq., for the respondent.
A corporation having total earnings or profits available for dividends of $5,674,586.32 distributed to its shareholders cash in the amount of $2,113,722.03 with stock having a cost basis of $3,199,950 and a fair market value on the date of the distribution of $8,983,407.75. Held, the distributions were taxable as dividends only to the extent of earnings and profits available for dividends, section 115(a) of the Code, and the appreciation in value of the property distributed does not serve to increase the corporation's ‘earnings or profits.‘ Held, further, to the extent that the fair market value of the property distributed is not covered by the earnings or profits the excess is used to reduce the basis of the stock of the shareholder-distributees under section 115(d), and such excess is not taxable to the shareholders as ‘other income‘ under section 22(a) of the Internal Revenue Code.
The respondent determined a deficiency in the income tax of the petitioners' decedent for the taxable year 1947 in the amount of $550.47. The question presented for our decision is whether certain corporate distributions in cash and property made by Southern Natural Gas Company were taxable to the decedent, a stockholder, in full or only to the extent that the fair market value of the distributions was covered by earnings and profits, the balance being applied to reduce the basis at which the decedent held her stock.
All of the facts are stipulated and are found accordingly.
The petitioners' decedent, Ida S. Godley, was an individual residing in Madison, New Jersey, during the taxable year 1947. The decedent filed her Federal income tax return for the calendar year 1947 with the collector of internal revenue for the fifth district of New Jersey.
Decedent died on February 9, 1952, leaving a last will and testament appointing petitioners Paul F. Godley and John W. Young, Jr., executors. The petitioners duly qualified as executors and have been and are now acting as executors of her estate.
The petitioners' decedent was the owner of 200 shares of the outstanding common stock of Southern Natural Gas Company (hereinafter referred to as Southern), a Delaware corporation, with principal offices at Birmingham, Alabama. During the year 1947 she received cash distributions on March 12, June 12, September 12, and December 12 of $75 each, or $300 in the aggregate. On July 28, 1947, she received 200 shares of common stock of Southern Production Company, Inc. (a corporation organized by Southern in 1942), having a fair market value on this date of $6.375 per share. The total fair market value of the distributions received by decedent from Southern was $1,575.
By letter dated February 20, 1948, the decedent was advised by Southern that Southern's tax consultant had recommended two alternative methods of reporting the distributions received by stockholders from Southern during the year 1947. The decedent included in her income tax return for the year 1947 the distributions received by her from Southern as taxable to the extent of $740.25, having elected to follow one of the alternatives suggested in the letter from Southern dated February 20, 1948.
In the notice of deficiency the respondent determined that the decedent understated her dividends in the amount of $2,074 and that the total distributions received by her from Southern were 100 per cent taxable.
The total distributions made by Southern to its stockholders in 1947 amounted to $2,113,722.03 in cash and 1,409,162 shares of common stock of Southern Production Company, Inc. The adjusted basis to Southern of the stock of Southern Production Company, Inc., was $3,199,950. The fair market value of the Southern Production Company, Inc., shares distributed by Southern in 1947 was $8,983,407.75. The earnings and profits of Southern for the year 1947 were $2,936,819.51. The accumulated earnings and profits as of January 1, 1947, were $2,737,766.81, or a total of earnings and profits available in 1947 for dividends of $5,674,586.32.
The respondent informed Southern by letter dated March 25, 1952, that it had been determined that the distributions made by Southern to its stockholders were 100 per cent taxable as follows: 51.13562% or $4.027 as ordinary dividends, and 48.86438% or $3.848 as other income.
A statement attached to the letter contained the following:
Since the available earnings exceed the cash and cost of property distributed, the entire distribution to the extent of the available earnings is held 51.13562% taxable as an ordinary dividend and the balance is held taxable to the shareholders as other income.
The cost to the decedent of her 200 shares of stock of Southern was in excess of $769.60.
Southern was organized under the laws of Delaware: on October 30, 1935, and acquired as of January 1, 1936, the business and properties of a predecessor company named Southern Natural Gas Corporation, pursuant to section 77B of the Bankruptcy Act. Southern operates an interstate natural gas pipeline system, extending from gas fields in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi to its principal markets in Mississippi, Alabama, and Georgia.
As of December 31, 1946, Southern's capitalization consisted of long-term debt in the amount of $22,500,000 and 1,409,212 shares of common stock of the par value of $7.50 each. Its earned surplus, according to the books, as of December 31, 1946, was $14,106,850.03. The net income for the year 1947, according to the books, was $3,226,156.79, and the book earned surplus at the end of the year 1947, including net adjustments to earned surplus and before deducting dividends on the common stock, was $17,669,983.23.
Southern Production Company, Inc., was organized under the laws of Delaware on August 8, 1942. It acquired from Southern as a contribution to capital, all of the capital stock of Southern Production Company, Inc., an Alabama corporation, and all of the assets of the Alabama corporation by merger effective February 12, 1946. The Alabama corporation, Southern Production Company, Inc., was organized by Southern in 1940 for the purpose of acquiring oil and gas leases and engaging in the business of producing oil and gas. The cost to Southern of its stock interest in the Delaware corporation was as follows:
+----------------------------------------------+
¦Paid to the Alabama corporation: ¦ ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦May 31, 1940 ¦$1,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦May 31, 1941 ¦999,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦August 21, 1941 ¦75,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦September 17, 1941 ¦25,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦ ¦$1,100,000¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦Paid to the Delaware corporation: ¦ ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦December 1945 ¦$1,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦February 12, 1946 ¦800,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦June 6, 1946 ¦200,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦July 29, 1946 ¦200,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦March 25, 1947 ¦899,000 ¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦ ¦$2,100,000¦
+-----------------------------------+----------¦
¦Total ¦$3,200,000¦
+----------------------------------------------+
On July 28, 1947, Southern Production Company, Inc., had outstanding 1,409,212 shares of stock of the par value of $1 each, all of which were owned by Southern. Southern distributed to its stockholders on July 28, 1947, 1,409,162 shares of the common stock of Southern Production Company, Inc., leaving 50 shares of such stock in the treasury of Southern. Such 50 shares were sold in the open market for $336.45. After this sale, the adjusted basis of the stock distributed was deemed to be $3,199,950 as a price of $1 a share was allocated to the stock sold in the open market.
The dividend of shares of stock of Southern Production Company, Inc., was declared by the board of directors of Southern at a meeting of the board duly called and held on June 15, 1947, by resolutions reading as follows:
RESOLVED, that a dividend be and the same hereby is declared in kind of one share of stock of Southern Production Company, Inc., a corporation of the State of Delaware, for each share of stock of Southern Natural Gas Company issued and outstanding, such dividend to be deliverable on July 28, 1947, to stockholders of record of Southern Natural Gas Company at the close of business on July 3, 1947; and further
RESOLVED, that the proper officers of the Company be and they hereby are authorized to charge the cost to the Company of the stock of Southern Production Company, Inc. (i.e., the sum of $3,200,000.) to earned surplus on the books of account of the Company.
For the year 1947, on the books, Southern charged earned surplus with $2,113,722.03, representing the cash distributed as dividends during this year and $3,199,663.55, representing cost to Southern of the shares of the stock distributed to stockholders as a dividend. The book earned surplus of Southern on December 31, 1947, after making such deductions, was $12,356,597.65.
The parties agree that the correct amount of the total cash...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Anderson v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue
...a Memorandum Opinion of this Court. cert. denied 348 U.S. 861 (1954); Commissioner v. Godley's Estate, 213 F.2d 529 (3d Cir. 1954), revg. 19 T.C. 1082 (1953), cert. denied 348 U.S. 822 (1954). 23. See Reid, ‘To what extent will distributions in redemption of stock reduce earnings and profit......
-
H.H. Robertson Co. v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue, Docket No. 2587-70.
...secs. 301(b)(1)(C), 301(c)(1), and 316, I.R.C. 1954. Petitioner's reliance on the decisions of this Court in Estate of Ida S. Godley, 19 T.C. 1082, reversed 213 F.2d 529 (C.A. 3), certiorari denied 348 U.S. 862, and Fannie Hirshon Trust, 12 T.C.M. 364, reversed 213 F.2d 523 (C.A. 2), certio......
-
Commissioner of Internal Rev. v. Godley's Estate
...KALODNER, and STALEY, Circuit Judges. STALEY, Circuit Judge. The Commissioner petitions for review of a decision of the Tax Court. 19 T.C. 1082 (1953). The facts were stipulated and were found accordingly. We will attempt to state them generally so that this opinion does not become a welter......
-
Commissioner of Internal Rev. v. Hirshon Trust
...established by § 115. The decisions of the Tax Court have fairly consistently supported the taxpayer's position. Estate of Godley v. Commissioner, 1953, 19 T.C. 1082, relating to the identical distributions here involved, and upon which the decision below was based; Dean v. Commissioner, 19......