Goldberg v. Soc'y Hill E. Condo. Ass'n, Inc.
| Decision Date | 11 March 2021 |
| Docket Number | DOCKET NO. A-0790-19 |
| Parties | SCOTT GOLDBERG, Plaintiff-Respondent, v. SOCIETY HILL EAST CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., Defendant-Appellant. |
| Court | New Jersey Superior Court — Appellate Division |
NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT THE APPROVAL OF THE APPELLATE DIVISION
This opinion shall not "constitute precedent or be binding upon any court." Although it is posted on the internet, this opinion is binding only on the parties in the case and its use in other cases is limited. R. 1:36-3.
Before Judges Whipple and Firko.
On appeal from the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, Middlesex County, Docket No. L-3284-16.
Ansell Grimm & Aaron, PC, attorneys for appellant (Mark M. Wiechnik, Nicole D. Miller and David J. Byrne, on the briefs).
Law Offices of John T. Bazzurro, LLC, attorneys for respondent (David P. Levine, on the brief).
Defendant Society Hill East Condominium Association, Inc. (the Association) appeals the orders of September 27, and October 2, 2019, awarding counsel fees. We reverse and remand for further findings.
Plaintiff Scott Goldberg, a condominium owner, filed suit against the Association after a fire damaged his unit. Plaintiff then filed a complaint seeking damages and injunctive relief so he could begin repairing the unit. After plaintiff refused to pay common expense assessments to the Association, the Association filed an answer and counterclaim to plaintiff's complaint.
In its counterclaim, the Association sought unpaid homeowner's association fees. Plaintiff argues the Association refused to make the necessary repairs to the unit and failed to meet its responsibility in compensating him for repairs he made. Following discovery, the Association moved for summary judgment against plaintiff. In September 2018, the trial court issued an order granting the Association's motion for unpaid Association dues. However, the judge reserved decision on defendant's request for attorney's fees, pending adjudication of plaintiff's complaint.
The Association filed an offer of judgment on July 13, 2018, and the parties' claims were ultimately settled by a consent judgment in April 2019.1 As a term of the consent judgment, the Association reserved its right to seek attorney's fees and costs, and plaintiff reserved his right to oppose such a motion. The consent judgment also awarded plaintiff $350 to resolve his claims but entered judgment against him as well. Thus, the Association was entitled to $12,390 from plaintiff for unpaid assessments.
Following the entry of the consent judgment, the Association filed two applications seeking awards of attorney's fees and costs: the first application was pursuant to Rule 4:58-1; the second was pursuant to New Jersey's Condominium Act, N.J.S.A. 46:8B-1 to -38, and the Association's master deed. These applications, combined, sought $138,000 in total legal fees. On September 29, 2019, the trial court entered two orders: (1) "granting motion for payment of counsel fees and costs pursuant to [Rule] 4:58-1," filed by the Association, and (2) "granting motion for payment of counsel fees and costs pursuant to [Rule] 4:58-1," again filed by the Association. On October 2, 2019, the trial judge issued an additional order, "granting [the] motion for payment of counsel fees and costs pursuant to the governing documents" filedby the Association. These orders awarded the Association $12,902.92 but did not explain the significant reduction from the $138,000 the Association sought. The Association appealed.
The Association does not appeal the underlying determination that it is entitled to a fee award, but asserts that the orders ignore a large portion of the fees requested and the court did not properly apply the rules related to a determination of a legal fee award. The Association argues the trial court improperly merged facts and law and did not separately address each application.
The court's orders combine the Association's separate and distinct applications, failing to address the Rule 4:58 application, and further fail to provide a separate analysis of the Association's Condominium Act application. Furthermore, the orders erroneously apply New Jersey Rule of Professional Conduct (RPC) 1.5(a) to reduce fees.
Rule 4:58-3 imposes mandatory financial consequences on a party who rejects a settlement offer that turns out to be more favorable than the ultimate judgment. Serico v. Rothberg, 234 N.J. 168, 176 (2018). The Rule seeks to prevent a party who has rejected a settlement from escaping mandatory payment for costs that were incurred because of that rejection. Id. at 176-77.In general, the purpose of Rule 4:58 is "as a mechanism to encourage, promote, and stimulate early out-of-court settlement of . . . claims that in justice and reason ought to be settled without trial." Willner v. Vertical Reality, Inc., 235 N.J. 65, 81 (2018) (internal quotation omitted).
Here, the trial court's September 27, 2019, orders state the attorney's fee and cost awards were appropriate pursuant to Rule 4:58-1. Nevertheless, the two orders each state that the Association sought only $15,529.92 and are devoid of explanation for the court's reduction of that amount under Rule 4:58. Instead, the orders provide an attached statement of reasons for reduction under RPC 1.5(a), resulting in a total award of $ 12,902. RPC 1.5(a) states that "[a] lawyer's fee shall be reasonable," and lists eight factors to be considered in determining the reasonableness of a fee. RPC 1.5(a)(1) to -(8). The court provided scant explanation for how it arrived at these figures, or why its starting point was so significantly far from the Association's original application of $65,905.53 in its offer of judgment. The court's order was conspicuously silent on whether it considered the affidavits that, as required by RPC 1.5, accompanied the Association's application. Thus, the trial court's reduction here was in error.
New Jersey's Condominium Act, N.J.S.A. 46:8B-1 to -38, entitles a condominium association to an award of...
To continue reading
Request your trial