Guthrie by and through Herring v. Missouri Methodist Hosp.
| Court | Missouri Court of Appeals |
| Writing for the Court | NUGENT |
| Citation | Guthrie by and through Herring v. Missouri Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938 (Mo. App. 1986) |
| Decision Date | 25 March 1986 |
| Docket Number | No. WD,WD |
| Parties | Toby Lee GUTHRIE, a minor By and Through his natural father and Next Friend Toby HERRING and Sandra Clark, Plaintiffs-Appellants. v. MISSOURI METHODIST HOSPITAL and David L. Garrison, M.D., Defendants- Respondents. 36618. |
Martin M. Bauman (argued), Bauman & Liles, St. Joseph, for plaintiffs-appellants.
Frank K. Nichols (argued), St. Joseph, Pope, Nichols, Hicks, for Methodist Medical Center.
Ken Rogers (argued), Springfield, Robert W. Freeman, Freeman, Fredrick, Bennett & Rogers, for Garrison.
Before NUGENT, P.J., and SHANGLER and MANFORD, JJ.
This appeal arises from the entry of a judgment on a jury verdict returned against the plaintiffs and for defendants Garrison and Missouri Methodist Hospital. Plaintiffs, Toby Lee Guthrie (the decedent's minor son) and Sandra Clark (the decedent's mother) brought the action for the wrongful death of Julie Guthrie allegedly resulting from the negligence of the two defendants.
The allegations of negligence arise out of decedent Julie Guthrie's hospitalization for the delivery of her minor son and involve a medical condition, hemangiomas, with which the decedent had been inflicted since early childhood. Hemangiomas may be best described as blood tumors that cause the blood vessels to grow and "lakes" of blood to accumulate. Decedent had a number of hemangiomas on her body, but the one at issue in the trial covered the exterior of her throat and extended into her mouth and covered portions of her tongue and tonsils. Occasionally, when decedent was under stress the hemangioma in her throat would start to bleed and she would have to cough to keep the blood from accumulating in her lungs. Among the special precautions she had to take because of her condition was sleeping with her head propped on two pillows since if she lay flat the hemangiomas would swell and cut off her air passageways.
Defendant Garrison delivered decedent's baby without incident at defendant hospital. After delivery of the baby and a short stay in the recovery room, decedent was taken to a regular nursing floor. Defendant Garrison left a number of orders for her care, all standard orders he regularly gave for his patients who delivered by caesarian section. Notably, the orders contained nothing regarding decedent's hemangiomas or any special care required to keep them from presenting complications.
Early the morning after decedent delivered her baby, the nursing staff could not awaken her. Her respiration was labored, and they noted a marked swelling of her tongue and the tumor in her neck. The chronology of events from that point on is as follows:
6:45 a.m.--decedent stopped breathing and code blue was called; code blue team responded immediately.
6:55 a.m.--Dr. Garrison was notified of decedent's condition.
7:20 a.m.--decedent was transferred to the intensive care unit.
7:25 a.m.--decedent was admitted to the intensive care unit.
Dr. Garrison was present. Decedent receiving air mixture of 100 percent oxygen. Faint pulse, color pale--gray lips and nails cyanotic. No audible blood pressure. Pupils dilated and fixed.
7:30 a.m.--Dr. Garrison left intensive care unit. He talked to decedent's family and then went on daily rounds. He testified that at time he left decedent "was very near death."
7:32 a.m.--decedent's heart atrial rhythm fibulating with ventrical rate of 60 to 70 but no perfusion.
7:35 a.m.--neurological condition unchanged; decedent bleeding from the oral cavity.
7:38 a.m.--cardiac compression begun as no pulse palpitation and no blood pressure. CPR perfuses radically. Pupils dilated and fixed.
7:39 a.m.--heart rhythm very tachycardia. Code blue called as all doctors had left and doctor called in by Dr. Garrison for consultation not arrived yet. No pulse or blood pressure. CPR continued.
7:42 a.m.--left diastolic ventricular rhythm now. No perfusion. Pupils dilated and fixed. Code blue team present. CPR stopped.
7:50 a.m.--no respiration, pulse or blood pressure. Pupils dilated and fixed.
The death certificate introduced into evidence by the plaintiffs showed the time of death at 7:50 a.m.
Plaintiffs brought their wrongful death action in separate counts against defendants Garrison, the clinic by which he was employed and Missouri Methodist Hospital. The allegations of negligence against the doctor and the hospital were identical. The petition claimed that each was individually negligent in (1) failing to provide sufficient medical personnel to observe decedent during her hospitalization, (2) failing to provide sufficient monitoring equipment for decedent during her hospitalization, (3) administering central nervous system depressant drugs which hampered or prevented decedent from calling or signalling for help, (4) administering central nervous system depressant drugs which hampered or prevented decedent from helping herself, (5) failing to take precautions that would have prevented decedent's death from the difficulty with bleeding in her throat, and (6) failure to take the steps necessary to see that decedent was given proper medical care in time to prevent her death as a result of the difficulty in her throat.
At a pretrial conference, the defendants made a motion in limine seeking to prohibit or exclude any testimony regarding any of the facts, treatment and circumstances of the two "code blues" and subsequent treatment in the intensive care unit. The motion was premised on testimony elicited from plaintiffs' medical expert during a videotaped deposition that was to be played to the jury and in which the expert stated that decedent was "brain dead" at the time she arrived in the intensive care unit and that any actions taken in that unit would not have had any effect on the outcome. The motion was denied, and the plaintiffs presented their case. The only expert medical testimony plaintiffs offered pertaining to the conduct of the defendants during the first or second code blue was that of plaintiffs' expert witness, which was presented to the jury by way of the videotaped deposition. During that testimony, the expert said that decedent was "brain dead" on being admitted to the intensive care unit and that little or nothing, could have been done to save her from that point on. Defendants renewed their motion in limine at the close of plaintiffs' case. The trial judge sustained it, stating that he did so because he felt the code blue situation presented a separate issue and that no expert medical testimony had been adduced that the manner in which either of the code blues were handled constituted medical malpractice or that anything occurring during that time caused decedent's death. The defendants presented their case, and the jury, returned a verdict in their favor.
The plaintiffs present five points of error: The court erred (1) in sustaining the motion in limine as there was evidence of negligence occurring during the code blues; (2) in not granting plaintiffs motion for new trial against defendant Missouri Methodist Hospital as the jury verdict was against the weight of the evidence; (3) in not allowing the jury to be instructed on aggravated circumstances under MAI 5.01 as it is not necessary to plead aggravated circumstances under the Missouri wrongful death statute, or, alternatively, the issue was tried by implied consent of the parties; (4) in not allowing plaintiffs to read from the mortality tables contained in the Missouri statutes as there was no evidence that decedent would not have lived a normal life span; and (5) in allowing defendant Garrison to introduce decedent's social security records as the documents were not the originals and, thus, not the best evidence.
Although not clearly presented, the plaintiffs' argument regarding the defendants' motion in limine appears to be that the evidence ultimately excluded related to defendant Garrison's duty to see that his patient was provided with competent and adequate care and to the issue of aggravating circumstances justifying an enhancement of the damages levied against the defendants. The plaintiffs contend that "[t]he denial of this evidence seriously limited the Plaintiffs' ability in showing the true callous disregard the Defendant Garrison had for his patient."
A court's ruling on a motion in limine to exclude particular evidence "is merely a preliminary expression of the court's opinion as to the admissibility of the evidence." Annin v. Bi-State Development Agency, 657 S.W.2d 382, 385 (Mo.App.1983). When the motion is sustained, its propriety is to be judged by the admissibility or inadmissibility of the evidence excluded. The instant motion in limine pertains to the relevancy of evidence concerning the two code blues so that review of the trial court's action must address that particular issue. Evidence is relevant "if the fact it tends to establish tends in turn to prove or disprove a fact in issue, or to corroborate evidence which is relevant and which bears on the principal issue." Charles F. Curry and Co. v. Hedrick, 378 S.W.2d 522, 536 (Mo.1964).
The trial court correctly sustained the motion in limine because plaintiffs' own evidence established that the activities occurring during the code blues were not the cause of the decedent's death. While the elements of a medical malpractice action may be the same as any negligence action, generally in a malpractice case the elements of duty, breach and causation are beyond the common knowledge and understanding of the jury and must be established by expert medical testimony. See, e.g., Steele v. Woods, 327 S.W.2d 187, 189 (Mo.1959); Williams v. Chamberlain, 316 S.W.2d 505, 511 (Mo.1958); Pedigo v. Roseberry, 340 Mo. 724, 102 S.W.2d 600, 606 (1937); and Miller v. Scholl, 594 S.W.2d 324, 328 (Mo.App.1980). Plaintiffs in the instant case failed to produce any substantial evidence of probative value establishing a causal...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
State ex rel. Webster v. Missouri Resource Recovery, Inc.
...which bears on the principal issue. Charles F. Curry and Co. v. Hedrick, 378 S.W.2d 522, 536 (Mo.1964); Guthrie v. Missouri Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938, 941 (Mo.App.1986); Lawson v. Schumacher & Blum Chevrolet Inc., 687 S.W.2d 947, 951, 64 A.L.R.4th 109 (Mo.App.1985). The relevance thre......
-
Letz v. Turbomeca Engine Corp.
...disprove a fact in issue or to corroborate evidence which is relevant and which bears on the principal issue. Guthrie v. Missouri Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938, 941 (Mo.App.1986). An award for exemplary damages such as aggravating circumstances damages must have some reasonable relation t......
-
Riley v. Union Pacific R.R.
...never reaches that issue." Collins v. West Plains Memorial Hosp., 735 S.W.2d 404, 409 (Mo.App.1987) (citing Guthrie v. Missouri Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938, 943 (Mo.App.1986)). Furthermore, any error in damage instructions is harmless error when the jury finds no liability on the substa......
-
Hagen v. Celotex Corp.
...cases recognize that an instruction on aggravating circumstances is appropriate only if supported by evidence. Guthrie v. Missouri Methodist Hospital, 706 S.W.2d 938 (Mo.App.1986). ...
-
Section 14.6 Life Expectancy—Mortality Tables
...329 S.W.2d 14 (Mo. banc 1959) · Kilmer v. Browning, 806 S.W.2d 75 (Mo. App. S.D. 1991) · Guthrie ex rel. Herring v. Mo. Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938 (Mo. App. W.D. 1986) In Kilmer, 806 S.W.2d 75, the court addressed the timely issue of a plaintiff who had hemophilia, had been exposed to ......
-
Section 11 Generally
...E.D. 1936). The provision is intended both to punish and to deter outrageous conduct, Guthrie ex rel. Herring v. Mo. Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938, 942 (Mo. App. W.D. 1986), and an increase based on aggravating circumstances is permissible only if the decedent, had he lived, would have be......
-
Section 28 Life Expectancy
...to show proof that the decedent would have led a normal, in terms of longevity, life. Guthrie ex rel. Herring v. Mo. Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938, 943 (Mo. App. W.D. 1986). Mortality tables are seen as guides, and their probative value may be weakened by evidence of the ill health of the......
-
Section 13 Causal Connection Necessary
...aggravating circumstances, those “circumstances” must be causally related to the death. Guthrie ex rel. Herring v. Mo. Methodist Hosp., 706 S.W.2d 938, 942 (Mo. App. W.D. 1986); Super v. White, 18 S.W.3d 511 (Mo. App. W.D. 2000). The language of § 537.090, RSMo Supp. 2011, itself mandates s......