Hair Excitement, Inc. v. L'Oreal U.S.A., Inc.
| Court | New Hampshire Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | BRODERICK, C.J. |
| Citation | Hair Excitement, Inc. v. L'Oreal U.S.A., Inc., 158 N.H. 363, 965 A.2d 1032 (N.H. 2009) |
| Decision Date | 19 February 2009 |
| Docket Number | No. 2007–920.,2007–920. |
| Parties | HAIR EXCITEMENT, INC. v. L'OREAL U.S.A., INC. |
Shaines & McEachern, P.A., of Portsmouth (Robert A. Shaines and Laurie A. Lacoste on the brief, and Mr. Shaines orally), for the plaintiff.
Nixon Peabody, LLP, of Manchester (W. Scott O'Connell and David W. Ruoff on the brief, and Mr. O'Connell orally), for the defendant.
The plaintiff, Hair Excitement, Inc. (Hair Excitement), appeals from a judgment entered by the Superior Court (Houran, J.) rejecting its claim that the defendant violated the Consumer Protection Act, RSA chapter 358–A (1995 & Supp.2008). The defendant, L'Oreal U.S.A., Inc., (L'Oreal) cross-appeals. We affirm.
The record supports the following facts. Hair Excitement is a New Hampshire corporation which owns and operates a number of hair salons in New Hampshire, Maine and Massachusetts. L'Oreal manufactures and distributes hair care products, including Matrix and Redken brand products.
In 1993, Hair Excitement entered into purchase contracts with a Matrix distributor for the purchase of Matrix products, a line now owned by L'Oreal, for its salons. The contracts provided that Hair Excitement would "not resell or redistribute Matrix retail products to anyone other than [its] legitimate salon clients for home maintenance use." Either party could terminate the contracts "immediately upon notice."
In 1997, Hair Excitement entered into a Redken Products Chain Account Agreement (chain account agreement) with Redken Laboratories, Inc., a subsidiary of L'Oreal. Pursuant to this agreement, Hair Excitement was appointed "as an authorized, non-exclusive Redken Chain Account for the Redken products." The products to be sold under the account were either products that Hair Excitement could only sell to consumers for their own use or products that its professionals applied on clients at its salons. The chain account agreement provided that Hair Excitement would "sell the products ... solely from Chain Account's salons to consumers for their own use, and that it [would] not sell, offer for sale or otherwise transfer such products to anyone other than consumers for their own use." As for products labeled "For Professional Use Only," the agreement provides that Hair Excitement would "use such products only in [its] salons." The agreement also provided that "[e]ither party may terminate this Agreement at any time, with or without cause, by giving sixty (60) days prior written notice of such termination to the other party."
These provisions restricting the sale of L'Oreal's products are intended to serve as protection against the sale of products outside of salons in the so-called "gray market." The "gray market" is a market in which legal but perhaps unethical methods are used to avoid a manufacturer's distribution chain and thereby sell goods at prices lower than those envisioned by the manufacturer. As the trial court's order explains:
The diversion of product, and in particular product designed and marketed for salon-only sales, is a very large problem in the beauty industry. Manufacturers are constantly battling this problem, which harms the business reputations of both the manufacturer and the salon owner, which creates a mistaken impression that the manufacturer permits or endorses the sale of salon-only products outside of a professional salon setting, and which is likely to cause confusion concerning the quality of salon-only products. Among the few tools available to manufacturers to battle diversion are tips from informants, coding of product to track the product's distribution routes, and buying programs, known at L'Oreal as "loyalty tests." Buying programs or loyalty tests involve the manufacturer sending in an investigator to pose as someone other than a consumer purchasing for the consumer's own use, and are generally used by a manufacturer to confirm whether a salon reported to be reselling in violation of contracts is in fact doing so. Both the problem and the tools used by manufacturers to combat it are well known and well understood by those involved in the industry.
In December 2001, a distributor in Rhode Island informed Charles Domroe, L'Oreal's director of corporate security, that it had learned from at least two sources that Hair Excitement was engaged in product diversion. As part of its subsequent investigation, L'Oreal retained Paul Cosentino to pose as a "collector" in order to conduct a "loyalty test" to determine whether Hair Excitement would make an unauthorized sale of L'Oreal's products. In early January 2002, Cosentino, posing as Paul Kostanza, telephoned Hair Excitement's salon in Rochester seeking to purchase Redken and Matrix hair care products for resale. That same day he received a return call from John Langlois, the owner of Hair Excitement, and was directed to contact purchasing manager, Ed Sharon, to discuss the proposed sale. Langlois knew that Cosentino intended to resell the products. The next day Cosentino spoke by telephone with Sharon and confided that he planned to sell the Redken and Matrix products outside of the United States. Sharon agreed to sell the requested products but told Cosentino that he needed to "be careful because Hair Excitement, Inc. [was] a franchise" and it "could run into problems with the manufacturer." The following day, Cosentino arrived at the Rochester salon and purchased 150 bottles of consumer-use only Redken and Matrix products at fifty percent of their retail value. Cosentino was told that Hair Excitement could supply whatever additional products he needed.
By letter dated February 8, 2002, L'Oreal informed Hair Excitement that due to its alleged product diversion and based upon other independent investigation, it was terminating the chain account agreement and would no longer sell it any Redken products. L'Oreal also barred its distributors from further sales of any of its product brands, including Matrix products, to Hair Excitement.
Hair Excitement brought suit against L'Oreal alleging that it had violated RSA chapter 358–A. It contended that L'Oreal willfully and knowingly misrepresented the identity of its agent and also misrepresented the agent's intent with the purpose to deceive and induce it to sell the products to third parties in violation of its purchase contracts and chain account agreement, resulting in its termination as an approved franchise. L'Oreal brought a counterclaim alleging that Hair Excitement violated RSA chapter 358–A because its distribution of Redken products outside of the salon-only sales to consumers harmed Redken's business reputation with both salon owners and consumers, created a mistaken impression that L'Oreal permits or endorses the sale of Redken products outside of a professional salon setting, and was likely to cause confusion concerning the quality of Redken products.
The parties agreed to bifurcate the trial of liability and damages. Over Hair Excitement's objection, the case was tried to the court and not to a jury. Following a four-and-a-half-day trial, the trial court found in favor of L'Oreal on Hair Excitement's claim and in favor of Hair Excitement on L'Oreal's counterclaim. This appeal followed.
Hair Excitement argues that the trial court erred in finding that: (1) it was not entitled to a jury trial; (2) L'Oreal did not engage in unfair and deceptive acts under RSA chapter 358–A; (3) L'Oreal's anti-diversion policy contained in the distributor contracts is a legitimate business practice; and (4) L'Oreal did not engage in price fixing. L'Oreal's cross-appeal raises four issues, including whether the trial court erred in ruling that: (1) the choice of law provision in the contract was inapplicable; (2) Hair Excitement's claims are not barred by the economic loss doctrine; (3) Hair Excitement's claims may not be limited by the terms of the contract; and (4) the doctrine of unclean hands does not bar Hair Excitement's claims. L'Oreal does not appeal the trial court's ruling in favor of Hair Excitement on L'Oreal's RSA chapter 358–A counterclaim. Accordingly, because we affirm the trial court's ruling in favor of L'Oreal on Hair Excitement's consumer protection claim, we need not address the issues raised by L'Oreal's cross-appeal. For purposes of this appeal, we assume without deciding that RSA chapter 358–A applies.
Prior to trial, L'Oreal moved to strike Hair Excitement's jury trial demand. The trial court granted the motion on the basis that "there is neither a constitutional nor statutory right to a jury trial on a claim brought under RSA 358–A:10." Noting that it "has the discretion to seek the advice of a jury on such a claim," the court declined to exercise such discretion.
Part I, Article 20 of the New Hampshire Constitution provides:
In all controversies concerning property, and in all suits between two or more persons except those in which another practice is and has been customary and except those in which the value in controversy does not exceed $1,500 and no title to real estate is involved, the parties have a right to a trial by jury. This method of procedure shall be held sacred, unless, in cases arising on the high seas and in cases relating to mariners' wages, the legislature shall think it necessary to alter it.
The right to a jury trial under the New Hampshire Constitution "is not without limitation; it extends only to those cases for which the jury trial right existed when the constitution was adopted in 1784." State v. Morrill, 123 N.H. 707, 712, 465 A.2d 882 (1983) ; see Hallahan v. Riley, 94 N.H. 338, 339, 53 A.2d 431 (1947) (). Part I, Article 20 ...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Ridlon v. N.H. Bureau of Sec. Regulation
...explained, " Part I, Article 20 did not create or establish a right to a jury trial not before existing." Hair Excitement v. L'Oreal U.S.A., 158 N.H. 363, 368, 965 A.2d 1032 (2009) (quotation and brackets omitted). Rather, "[i]t was a recognition of an existing right, guaranteeing it as it ......
-
Luckey v. Alside, Inc.
...(interpreting MUPTA and two other related Minnesota statutes governing consumer protection); see Hair Excitement, Inc. v. L'Oreal U.S.A, Inc. , 158 N.H. 363, 965 A.2d 1032, 1037–38 (2009). While claims under these statutes must still be pled with particularity under Rule 9(b), the statutes ......
-
Adelaide v. George
...of the statute, the court is vested with the authority to decide claims brought under RSA chapter 358–A.” Hair Excitement v. L'Oreal U.S.A., 158 N.H. 363, 369, 965 A.2d 1032 (2009). Here, the first jury determined that the defendant's conduct violated the CPA. The trial court then informed ......
-
Patane v. Nestlé Waters N. Am., Inc.
...Protection Act "creates new statutory rights which did not exist in New Hampshire common law." Hair Excitement, Inc. v. L'Oreal USA, Inc. , 158 N.H. 363, 965 A.2d 1032, 1037 (2009).• Pennsylvania. The Pennsylvania Consumer Protection Law "is based upon the Federal Trade Commission Act .... ......
-
Making Business Claims Under The NH Consumer Protection Act
...is met, as the Supreme Court held that there is no right to a jury trial on CPA claims. See Hair Excitement, Inc. v. L'Oreal U.S.A, Inc., 158 NH 363 Finally, counsel should be aware of a recent decision from the US District Court for the District of New Hampshire, which granted summary judg......