Hamric v. Wilderness Expeditions, Inc.
Decision Date | 26 July 2021 |
Docket Number | No. 20-1250,20-1250 |
Citation | 6 F.4th 1108 |
Parties | Alicia HAMRIC, individually, as representative of the Estate of Robert Gerald Hamric, and as next friend of Ava Hamric, a minor, Plaintiff - Appellant, v. WILDERNESS EXPEDITIONS, INC., Defendant - Appellee. |
Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Tenth Circuit |
William J. Dunleavy, Law Offices of William J. Dunleavy, Allen, Texas (Stephen A. Justino, Boesen Law, Denver, Colorado, on the briefs), for Plaintiff – Appellant.
Malcolm S. Mead (Peter C. Middleton and Jacob R. Woods with him on the brief), Hall & Evans, Denver, Colorado, for Defendant – Appellee.
Before TYMKOVICH, Chief Judge, HOLMES, and McHUGH, Circuit Judges.
Gerald Hamric, a Texas resident, joined a church group on an outdoor recreation trip to Colorado. The church group employed the services of Wilderness Expeditions, Inc. ("WEI") to arrange outdoor activities.
Before the outdoor adventure commenced, WEI required each participant, including Mr. Hamric, to complete a "Registration Form" and a "Medical Form." On the first day, WEI led the church group on a rappelling course. In attempting to complete a section of the course that required participants to rappel down an overhang, Mr. Hamric became inverted. Attempts to rescue Mr. Hamric proved unsuccessful, and he died.
Alicia Hamric, Mr. Hamric's wife, sued WEI for negligence. WEI moved for summary judgment, asserting the Registration Form and the Medical Form contained a release of its liability for negligence. Ms. Hamric resisted WEI's motion for summary judgment in four ways. First, Ms. Hamric moved for additional time to conduct discovery under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(d). Second, Ms. Hamric moved for leave to amend her complaint to seek exemplary damages based on willful and wanton conduct. Third, Ms. Hamric filed a motion for leave to disclose an expert out of time. Fourth, Ms. Hamric argued Texas law controlled the validity of the purported liability release in the Registration Form and the Medical Form, and additionally that the release was not conspicuous as required by Texas law.
In a single order, a magistrate judge addressed each of the pending motions. The magistrate judge first declined to grant leave to amend the complaint due to Ms. Hamric's failure to (1) sustain her burden under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16(b) because the deadline for amendments had passed; and (2) make out a prima facie case of willful and wanton conduct as required by Colorado law to plead a claim seeking exemplary damages. Next, the magistrate judge concluded WEI was entitled to summary judgment, holding the liability release was valid under both Colorado law and Texas law. Finally, the magistrate judge denied as moot Ms. Hamric's motions for additional discovery and to disclose an expert out of time.
We affirm the magistrate judge's rulings. As to Ms. Hamric's motion for leave to amend, a party seeking to amend a pleading after the deadline in a scheduling order for amendment must satisfy the standard set out by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 16(b). But Ms. Hamric concedes she has never sought to satisfy the Rule 16(b) standard. Turning to the discovery motions, where this case hinges on the validity of the liability release and all facts necessary to this primarily legal issue appear in the record, we reject Ms. Hamric's contentions that further discovery or leave to belatedly disclose an expert were warranted. Finally, while the magistrate judge's summary judgment analysis was not free of error, we apply de novo review to that ruling. And, under de novo review, we conclude (1) relying on contract law to resolve the choice-of-law issue, as argued for by the parties, Colorado law, rather than Texas law, controls whether the Registration Form and the Medical Form contain a valid liability release; and (2) the forms contain a valid release for negligence by WEI, barring Ms. Hamric's action.
Members of the Keller Church of Christ in Keller, Texas, scheduled an outdoor excursion to Colorado, contracting with WEI for adventure planning and guide services. WEI is incorporated in Colorado and has its headquarters in Salida, Colorado. Jamie Garner served as the coordinator for the church group and the point-of-contact between the church members and WEI. The experience WEI provided included guides taking participants rappelling. WEI required all participants, before going on the outdoor excursion, to complete and initial a "Registration Form" and complete and sign a "Medical Form."1
The Registration Form has three sections. The first section requires the participant to provide personally identifiable information and contact information. The second section is entitled "Release of Liability & User Indemnity Agreement for Wilderness Expeditions, Inc. " App. Vol. I at 57, 83.2 The text under this bold and underlined header reads, in full:
Id .3 Immediately after this paragraph, the form reads, "Adult participant or parent/guardian initial here: ____ (Initials)." Id . The third and final section of the form is entitled: "Adult Agreement or Parent's/Guardian Agreement for Wilderness Expeditions, Inc. " Id . The text of this provision states:
I understand the nature of the activities may involve the physical demands of hiking over rough terrain, backpacking personal and crew gear, and voluntarily climbing mountains to 14,433 feet in elevation. Having the assurance of my, or my child's, good health through a current physical examination by a medical doctor, I hereby give consent for me, or my child, to participate in the activities outfitted by Wilderness Expeditions, Inc. I have included in this form all necessary medical information about myself, or my child, that should be known by the leadership of the program. I assure my, or my child's, cooperation and assume responsibility for my, or my child's, actions. I understand that I am responsible for any medical expenses incurred in the event of needed medical attention for myself, or my child. I further agree that I will be financially responsible to repair or replace all items lost or abused by myself or my child. In the event of an emergency, I authorize my consent to any X-ray examination, medical, dental, or surgical diagnosis, treatment, and/or hospital care advised and supervised by a physician, surgeon, or dentist licensed to practice. I understand that the designated next of kin will be contacted as soon as possible. By signing my initials below, I certify this is a release of liability.
Id . And, as with the second section, the form then provides a line for the participant or the parent or guardian of the participant to initial.
The Medical Form has four sections. The first section seeks information about the participant. The second section is entitled "Medical History ." Initially, this section asks the participant if he suffers from a list of medical conditions, including allergies, asthma
, and heart trouble. If the participant does suffer from any medical conditions, the form requests that the participant explain the affirmative answer. Thereafter, the section includes the following language:
Note: The staff will not administer any medications, including aspirin
, Tums, Tylenol, etc. If you need any over the counter medications, you must provide them. Be sure to tell your staff members what medications you are taking.
List any medications that you will have with you: _______________
Note about food: Trail food is by necessity a high carbohydrate, high caloric diet. It is high in wheat, milk products, sugar, com syrup, and artificial coloring/flavoring. If these food products cause a problem to your diet, you will be responsible for providing any appropriate substitutions and advise the staff upon arrival.
* Doctor's signature is required to participate. No other form can be substituted. By signing below a physician is verifying the medical history given above and approving this individual to participate.
Id. at 58, 84. The form then includes a section titled "Physician's Evaluation ." Id. This section seeks certification of the participant's medical capability to partake in the outdoor activities...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
AH Aero Servs., LLC v. Heber City
...allegations. The court accordingly declines to consider these asserted incidents of retaliation. See Hamric v. Wilderness Expeditions, Inc. , 6 F.4th 1108, 1118 (10th Cir. 2021) ; Gordon v. Jordan Sch. Dist. , 333 F.R.D. 220, 224–25 (D. Utah 2019).Aero also alleges in its Complaint that the......
-
Navajo Agric. Prods. Indus. v. United States
...No. 8. Moreover, it is well settled that discovery is not permitted as a fishing expedition. See, e.g. , Hamric v. Wilderness Expeditions, Inc. , 6 F.4th 1108, 1119 (10th Cir. 2021).In sum, Plaintiff has not alleged facts sufficient to suggest that either prong of the Berkovitz test is not ......
-
Lopez v. Western Surplus Lines Agency, Inc.
...is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.’ " Hamric v. Wilderness Expeditions, Inc. , 6 F.4th 1108 (10th Cir. 2021) (quoting Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a) ). "A fact is material if it can have an impact on the outcome of the lawsuit and......
-
Valenzuela v. City of Anaheim
... ... Marks, Mardirossian & Associates Inc., Los Angeles, California; for Plaintiffs-Appellees. Christopher D. Hu, ... ...