Hansen v. Woods
| Court | Idaho Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | VARIAN, J. |
| Citation | Hansen v. Woods, 290 P. 379, 49 Idaho 656 (Idaho 1930) |
| Decision Date | 25 July 1930 |
| Docket Number | 5419 |
| Parties | J. M. HANSEN, ROBERT DIETRICH, WALTER EICKELBERGER, EDWARD IRELAND, C. T. JUDY, ---- MOFFATT, WALTER KARN, W. A. HOCKING, EDWARD BURKET, CLARENCE JACKSON, M. L. JONES, HARRY MAYS, G. G. HARROLD, J. H. KING, H. COWGILL, ROSE MORGAN, JOHN LOGAN and LESTER SERMON, Appellants, v. M. H. WOODS, JACOB KELLER, JOHN DIETRICH, BLAINE COUNTY INVESTMENT COMPANY, a Corporation, and BLAINE COUNTY CANAL COMPANY, a Corporation, Respondents |
WATER AND WATERCOURSES - CORPORATIONS - ULTRA VIRES ACTS-RIGHTS OF STOCKHOLDERS-ESTOPPEL.
1. That irrigation construction company's director, being also operating company's director, knew canals carried water belonging to another company's stockholders who were also operating company's stockholders, held insufficient to show fraud.
2. Irrigation assessments, being voluntarily paid, were ratified, precluding stockholders from subsequently questioning validity.
3. After knowingly receiving benefits from irrigation construction company's reservoir, operating company's stockholders held estopped to contend maintaining reservoir was ultra vires operating company.
APPEAL from the District Court of the Sixth Judicial District, for Butte County. Hon. R. W. Jones, Judge pro tem.
Action by stockholders for accounting against corporate directors and for injunction. Judgment for defendants. Affirmed.
Judgment affirmed, Costs to respondents.
G. F Hansbrough and J. H. Andersen, for Appellants.
If the directors are making an illegal application of the funds of the corporation, the question whether they are acting corruptly or honestly is immaterial, and the complaining stockholders need not allege or prove any actual or wilful fraud or collusion on the part of the company, the directors or others. (14a C. J. 162.)
It is also a well-settled rule of law that one or more stockholders of a corporation may maintain a suit in equity, to restrain the directors and managing officers and agents, of the corporation from employing its funds contrary to or in a manner not authorized by the charter, governing statute articles of the association or other instrument. (14a C. J 155; Dodge v. Woolsey, 18 How. (U.S.) 331, 15 L.Ed. 401.)
The evidence in this case shows conclusively that M. H. Woods was an officer and director of both corporations, and was by voting illegal stock, in control of both. The fact that the officers of one corporation are also the officers of another does not make the corporations the same, nor the acts of one of the acts of the other. (Fort Smith Light Co. v. Kelley, 94 Ark. 461, 127 S.W. 975; Holder v. Cannon Mfg. Co., 138 N.C. 308, 50 S.E. 681.)
Peterson, Baum & Clark, W. J. Lamme and Wm. Story, Jr., for Respondents.
It would seem that the rule we are contending for here is conceded by the plaintiffs through their amendment to their complaint, which attempts to set forth the efforts alleged to have been made to obtain redress through the board of directors of the canal company, and conceding that their showing in this respect is sufficient, there is not sufficient showing that any effort was made to obtain redress through other corporate channels, i. e., through the stockholders of the company. Their only allegation in this respect, which they plead as an excuse for their failure to seek redress through the stockholders, is that the majority of the stock of the corporation is controlled by the defendant. (Fletcher, Cyc., Corp., secs. 468, 5263; Howze v. Harrison, 165 Ala. 150, 51 So. 614; Blades v. Billing Mercantile Co., 154 Mo.App. 350, 134 S.W. 579; Smiley v. New River Co., 72 W.Va. 221, 77 S.E. 976; Secord v. Wheeler G. M. Co., 53 Wash. 620, 17 Ann. Cas. 914, 102 P. 654.)
This case involves analogous questions to those in Blaine County Canal Co. v. Hansen (No. 5401), just decided, ante, P. 649, 292 P. 240.
Appellants are settlers, contract holders and purchasers under a Carey Act project situate in Butte county, Idaho. They are likewise stockholders in respondent Blaine County Canal Company, and bring this action in the nature of an accounting as to the application of moneys raised by assessments levied during the years 1920 to 1926, both inclusive, by respondent Blaine County Canal Company, for an injunction prohibiting the unlawful expenditure of the funds of said canal company, and by supplemental complaint prayed the removal of respondents Woods, Dietrich and Keller as directors and officers of said company; that respondents be enjoined from allowing water other than Carey Act project water to be run through the canals of the Blaine County Canal Company; and that a deed granting an easement to transport water belonging to the Butte Land & Water Company through the canals of said Blaine County Canal Company, be canceled. A receiver was applied for, but the application was abandoned at the opening of the trial.
Among other facts, the court found that the Blaine County Investment Company is the successor in interest of the Blaine County Irrigation Company, Ltd., organized under the laws of Idaho to construct a reservoir and system of canals for what is designated as the Blaine County Projects, in Butte County, Idaho (Idaho Segregation List No. 53), pursuant to a contract with the state of Idaho dated June 29, 1910. The respondent Blaine County Canal Company is a corporation organized by said Blaine County Irrigation Company, Ltd., pursuant to the terms of said contract with the state of Idaho, to take over and operate the irrigation systems and distribute the water when said system should be so far completed as to permit of operation thereof, and for the purpose of levying and collecting tolls, assessments and charges for the operations, maintenance and management of said system. As provided for in the construction contract, the entire capital stock of said Blaine County Canal Company was issued to the Blaine County Irrigation Company, Ltd., and sold by it to settlers on the project, including appellants and others not parties to this suit.
The reservoir contemplated by the original contract having been found to be pervious to water and not capable of storing the required amount of water, the state and the Blaine County Investment Company, successor in interest of said Blaine County Irrigation Company, Ltd., on August 24, 1917, entered into a supplemental agreement, whereby the said Blaine County Investment Company agreed to construct what is called the Dry Creek reservoir and pipeline, in lieu of completing the original reservoir. The supplemental contract provides that the Dry Creek dam shall be constructed to a height of 110 feet, but because of the physical condition of the canyon walls, it was able to construct said dam to a height of eighty-five feet. The pipe-line, extending from said reservoir to Corral Creek, whereby the waters of said reservoir are discharged into West Creek, a tributary of Little Lost River, and thence upon the lands of the project, has been completed, and during the years 1920 to 1927, both inclusive, said stored waters of Dry Creek have been diverted through said pipeline and constitute sixty-five per cent of the aggregate water supply available for the entire project.
The third findings of facts is as follows:
"Pursuant to said supplemental contract between the defendant, Blaine County Investment Company, and the State of Idaho, that part of the irrigation system described in the said contract between Blaine County Irrigation Company, Ltd., and the State, consisting in general of the main diverting canals, laterals and other works for diversion of the waters of Little Lost River and distribution of the same over the land included in said project, was turned over, with the approval of the State Land Board, to the defendant, Blaine County Canal Company, Ltd., during the year 1920, for operation, and has since been operated by said company, but because of the said Dry Creek Reservoir not having been completed in accordance with the said supplemental contract between the defendant Blaine County Investment Company and the State, the said reservoir, pipe line and appurtenant water rights have not been conveyed to a reservoir company by the defendant, Blaine County Investment Company, for operation and for the purpose of levying and collecting tolls and assessments for operation and maintenance thereof, as contemplated by the said supplemental contract between the said Investment Company and the State."
The court further found that for eight years last past, or since 1920, the construction company, Blaine County Investment Company, has been and now is insolvent; that it is without funds, or the means of obtaining founds, to pay the expenses of maintaining or operating the Dry Creek reservoir and pipe-line, or otherwise perform the covenants of the supplemental agreements aforesaid; that notwithstanding there has been no formal order for the transfer to the Blaine County Canal Company for the operation, it has been necessary for it to operate and maintain the said Dry Creek reservoir pipe-line, etc., during said period of more than eight years, and that no part of the funds expended by it have been for original construction as distinguished from repairs and maintenance; that without the waters from the Dry Creek source, it would have been impossible for appellants and other settlers on the project to raise profitable crops on any of their lands since the year 1920, and that the cost of maintenance of the Dry Creek works and system is a necessary legitimate part of the expense incident to the operation and maintenance of the project by respondent Blaine...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting