Harold v. Modern Homes Const. Co.

Decision Date22 September 1961
Docket NumberNo. 39020,No. 3,39020,3
Citation121 S.E.2d 809,104 Ga.App. 415
PartiesHenry HAROLD, Jr. v. MODERN HOMES CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
CourtGeorgia Court of Appeals

Syllabus by the Court

In order to evict a person in possession of land under the provisions of Code § 61-301 the relation of landlord and tenant must exist between the parties.

Modern Homes Construction Co., by its agent, executed an affidavit seeking to gain possession of certain real property then in the possession of the defendant Henry Harold, Jr. The defendant filed a counter affidavit and bond, and after the original affidavit was amended, the issue thus made came on for trial in the Superior Court of Coffee County. At the conclusion of all the evidence the defendant made a motion for directed verdict which was denied. Thereafter, after the jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff, the defendant's motion for a judgment non obstante veredicto or, in the alternative, for a new trial was overruled and it is to such judgment adverse to him that the defendant now excepts.

J. Laddie Boatright, Douglas, for plaintiff in error.

Robert L. Cork, Horace Campbell, Valdosta, for defendant in error.

NICHOLS, Judge.

Both the plaintiff and the defendant contended that their title was derived from W. M. Denton. The evidence disclosed the following facts without contradiction. On July 22, 1958, W. M. Denton made a deed conveying a vacant lot, the property in dispute, to Ollie Brackins, Jr., that the defendant's wife paid the consideration for such deed, and after such deed was signed it was delivered to a bank who held the same until the balance of the purchase price was paid, that on July 26, 1958, the warranty deed was recorded by the Clerk of the Superior Court of Ware County (the land was located in Coffee County), that on August 9, 1958, Ollie Brackins, Jr., executed a deed to secure debt on such property to the plaintiff which was recorded on August 11, 1958, that on September 20, 1958, such deed to secure debt was assigned to Commercial Trust Co. of Atlanta, Ga., that on July 14, 1959, the defendant obtained a quitclaim deed from W. M. Denton conveying the property in dispute, and on August 5, 1959, the plaintiff, as attorney in fact for Brackins, executed a deed to itself under the authority purportedly derived from the deed to secure debt, that on August 18, 1959, the deed to secure debt was re-purchased by the plaintiff from the assignee of such loan deed (Commercial Trust Co. of Atlanta, Ga.), and that on July 29, 1960, the plaintiff made affidavit in connection with the dispossessory warrant which formed the original pleadings in the present case.

'1. 'Under the provisions of section 5385 of the Civil Code 1910, [61-301] in order to maintain a proceeding to evict a person in possession of lands, the relation of landlord and tenant must exist between the parties.' Edwards v. Blackshear, 24 Ga.App. 622, 101 S.E. 585, and citations. 2. 'Where all right,...

To continue reading

Request your trial
3 cases
  • Thomas v. Wells Fargo Credit Corp.
    • United States
    • Georgia Court of Appeals
    • July 5, 1991
    ...it purchased the property to rebut appellants' averments that appellee was not their landlord. See Harold v. Modern Homes Constr. Co., 104 Ga.App. 415, 416-417, 121 S.E.2d 809 (1961). 2. It is not clear from my reading of the record and briefs in this case that appellee seeks dismissal of t......
  • Williams v. Slusser
    • United States
    • Georgia Court of Appeals
    • September 22, 1961
  • Collins v. Administrator of Veterans Affairs
    • United States
    • Georgia Court of Appeals
    • November 10, 1980
    ...the provisions of Code § 61-301, the relation of landlord and tenant must exist between the parties," (Harold v. Modern Homes Const. Co., 104 Ga.App. 412, 121 S.E.2d 809 (1961)), and "tenancy is not established by the mere showing of ownership in one person and possession in another" (Johns......

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT